The following account is descriptive, not judgmental. I don’t know if the Fed could do something better.
It seems that the Fed has played a big role in the past a few times (e.g., 1984 and 1994) in achieving a soft landing.
But on the other hand:
- Soft landing is rare, the sample size is small
- Macro is infinitely complex; it’s impossible to clinically separate the Fed’s skill, how luck might have been on the Fed’s side, and other factors (of which there are infinitely many in macro) from each other.
- The economy changes over time; it could be that inflationary pressures have become so much harder to predict that it’s right for the Fed to have thrown in the towel.
My thesis is that it’s pointless to expect the Fed, with its current system, to master any soft landings. Below is a description of how we got here.
The Fed spent decades, the input of hundreds (or thousands?) of economists, and billions of dollars developing models for macroeconomic forecasting.
By the 2010s, confidence within the Fed was not very high that this project had been very useful.
However, in 2018, when models developed at the Fed signaled the threat of an overheated economy, the Fed adopted a tightening stance in monetary policy based on this.
The tightening ended with the famous Powell pivot.
In 2019 and early 2020, the Fed analyzed the 2018 tightening campaign. The conclusion was that there was no acute threat of an overheated economy in 2018. In other words, the attempt to create a soft landing through monetary policy tightening had unnecessarily jeopardized good employment development.
This was the last straw.
The Fed radically changed its approach. The new approach adopted in 2020 is this:
- Use the substantial resources granted by Congress to try to get the clearest and most up-to-date picture of where the economy is going right now.
- Based on the above picture, make a subjective assessment of what monetary policy the economy needs.
Such situations can no longer occur:
- Subjective assessment “loosen,” but a model or leading indicator says “tighten” ==> tighten
- Subjective assessment “tighten,” but a model or leading indicator says “loosen” ==> loosen
So the Fed tries to invest in having the clearest possible picture of where things are now. Forecasting is considered difficult, and for example, during the 6-week intervals between FOMC meetings, efforts are made to keep the situational picture up to date. Based on this, they aim for the best possible performance.
This approach is so far from how soft landings were achieved before…
…that I no longer expect the Fed’s monetary policy to prevent any recessions in the future.