Stock Market Direction (Part 3)

There has been excellent discussion in the thread about an important topic (I quoted P-Eka’s message there, but I could quote many others), to which I haven’t had time to add my two cents due to delicious work commitments (preparations for the next few Vartti/pod/presentations :stuck_out_tongue: ), but the subject area is interesting to me as well.

A few thoughts and highlights.

i) Economic growth is indeed expected to fizzle out

The Bank of Finland recently published its long-term economic growth forecast for Finland. The outline is based on the development of the working-age population, human capital (i.e., education level), and fixed capital (in practice, companies’ fixed assets, both intangible and tangible, i.e., software and smokestacks).

At the current rate, the Finnish economy will take a double hit: the working population will collapse, and at the same time, the education level of new age groups will actually decline. Net immigration does not fully compensate for this. Finland’s economic growth potential will disappear in the 2040s and turn into a permanent decline in the 2050s.

Note: these long-term forecasts are highly theoretical. What if, for example, the AI hype delivers on expectations for productivity growth? What if Finland’s future governments start investing in the education of a small nation instead of making cuts? What if Finns and immigrants who have moved here become active in bedrooms in the 2030s without protection? What if the Swedish working class gets tired of the king and taxation favoring the rich and starts a revolution in the 2040s, driving 500,000 rich Swedish refugees with all their money to Finland? Will hilly Lahti be Finland’s bustling capital of a million inhabitants and a renowned wine region in the 2060s, when Helsinki was previously overshadowed by rising sea levels due to climate change and the aesthetically foolish towers of Kalasatama? The further one thinks about things, the more seemingly incredible scenarios and turns can become possible.

I don’t know, but I would imagine many other countries are on a similar development path as Finland.

ii) Impact on the stock market.

This is difficult to outline. For investors and companies, growth is such a self-evident concept hammered into their heads that even in interviews with company CEOs, a decline in revenue is actually negative growth! Who, for example, would talk about negative weight loss if their weight goes in the wrong direction? Or who talks about negative mental growth for young people? Presumably, no one. This illustrates well how, even at the conceptual level, we have cemented in our minds the idea of eternal economic growth, whereas in many other areas of life, we can imagine things also declining or shrinking.

The absence of growth affects many things. If economic change is 0%, what level would long-term interest rates settle at? Probably around 0%. So what would happen to the required rate of return on stocks? It would presumably drop to just a risk premium, perhaps around 5-8% depending on the company. In this case, the “basic” P/E multiple of a static company would actually be 12.5x-20x.

What if the economy declined? Could interest rates be negative more permanently? Why not, if there is no longer the same demand for capital as before. But on the other hand, does an economy dominated by older age groups generate savings in the same way as before? I don’t know. In principle, if economic growth slows down but savings remain at the same level, the wealth-to-GDP ratio would start to swell, as has happened in Europe. Since many asset classes are ultimately debt, this is reflected inversely as an expansion of debt ratios.

Or does the decline in the working-age population rather cause severe wage inflation, as skilled workers are soon pulled from every corner of the world to turn the wheels of our capitalist perpetual motion machine? Will the power dynamics between capital and labor be turned upside down? Will the economy and development stagnate when young and dynamic skilled workers no longer enter the economy as before?

What can we learn from previous population collapses? For example, the consensus view of the Black Death in the 14th century is that the wages of the surviving people skyrocketed, economic efficiency grew, and it provided a basis for the capitalist economic system and commercialism. Is the same happening now, but a bit slower? Does the upcoming population collapse lay the groundwork for a new kind of social order?

Many questions, to which I, at least, cannot readily come up with comprehensive answers.

iii) What an investor can do.

Firstly, the current value of companies is their future cash flows discounted to today. The further away the cash flows are, the less weight they have in today’s value. If something permanently turns results into a decline in the 2050s, it won’t be very visible in today’s stock price. And not even tomorrow.

However, I’ll write down a good general rule here. Don’t pay too much for stocks. A maximum P/E of 10-15x is a good rule of thumb, taking into account the company’s quality factors. In this case, it doesn’t matter if the company doesn’t grow much.

If you buy cheap and the global economy doesn’t grow, you probably won’t get much profit. If you buy cheap and things go quite well, you might even get good returns. :slight_smile:

126 Likes