Rusta - Nordic discount retailer

Opening a thread for Rusta, whose performance may also be useful to follow for those interested in Tokmanni and Puuilo – in Tokmanni’s case, particularly through Dollarstore. Like its competitors, Rusta also intends to grow by expanding its store network. Time will tell which of these companies will ultimately be the most successful. Without further ado, let’s dive into the Rusta case.

rusta_historiallinen träkki

Rusta is a Swedish international discount retail chain founded in Uppsala in 1986, which listed on the Stockholm Stock Exchange in the fall of 2023. At the time of writing, it has over 200 stores in Sweden, Norway, Finland, and Germany, complemented by online stores in Sweden and Finland.

The majority of Rusta’s revenue comes from brick-and-mortar stores, as e-commerce accounted for only 1.6% of revenue in the 2022/23 financial year (10,202 MSEK). During the same period, Rusta’s adjusted operating profit (“adjusted EBITA”) was 5.3% and return on equity (ROE) was 20.5%. These figures will be updated very soon, as Rusta will report the results of its non-calendar financial year later this week.

Rusta has over 5 million loyalty members (“Club Rusta”), whose purchases accounted for nearly 80% of total sales in the previous financial year. Rusta’s main product categories are Home & Interior, Garden, DIY, Leisure, and Beauty & Care. Over 50% of the customer base is female, whereas for most competitors, the customer distribution is male-dominated.

Expanding the store network as a key growth driver

Virtually all stores in Rusta’s Swedish and Norwegian networks are profitable, while 85% of the stores in the Finnish and German networks were profitable in the 2022/23 financial year. In addition to growth, it is essential for Rusta to improve the profitability of its Finnish and German store networks to be closer to Swedish levels. More on this later.

Expanding the store network is a central part of the strategy for many companies focused on discount retail, and this is also the case for Rusta. Rusta has opened an average of more than 10 new stores per year in recent years, and the pace of expansion is expected to remain rapid between 2024 and 2026, with 40–60 store openings planned. Time will tell how many they eventually reach, but as of January 2024, Rusta had signed agreements for 25 locations (14 in Sweden, 8 in Norway, 2 in Finland, and 1 in Germany).

According to the company’s own estimate, there are approximately 150 potential store locations in its current markets (Sweden ~60, Norway ~40, Finland ~20, and Germany ~30). Currently, about half of the network of over 200 stores is located in Sweden, with 40–50 stores in Norway and Finland respectively. There are about a dozen stores in Germany.

On average, opening a new Rusta store has historically cost about 4 MSEK (excluding inventory), and the store has typically paid for itself (“average payback period”) in less than a year—specifically 10–11 months. In Rusta’s IPO prospectus, the average payback period is defined as the investment related to establishing the store (including store interior but excluding working capital) relative to the store’s contribution margin.

I could not find exact information on the age of the store network, but based on my own conclusions, about 30% of the stores in the current network could be less than 5 years old, and these presumably have the highest ramp-up potential for sales.

Summary

Store network growth

rusta_myymäläverkoston kehitys

Financial targets

Rusta aims to grow its revenue by an average of about 8% per year (CAGR ~13% 2019–2023) without acquisitions. A significant part of the growth is built on network expansion, as the underlying target for like-for-like (LFL) sales growth is over 3 percent per year.

The profitability target is an 8% EBITA margin (~5% 2022/23). In Sweden and Norway, Rusta already achieves significantly higher profitability than this. Therefore, efficiency must be improved most in Finland and Germany to prove the scalability of international growth.

A significant portion of the profit is reinvested into business growth, as according to the targets, 30–50% of Rusta’s net profit should be distributed as dividends.

rusta tavoitteet

The market in brief

A good overview of the Nordic discount retail market and its competitive landscape can be found in the market overview of Rusta’s IPO prospectus (pages 43–54). According to Rusta’s estimate, the size of its relevant market was 67 billion SEK (Sweden 29, Norway 20, Finland 18) in 2022. The share of discount retail in the total retail market was less than 4% in all countries, while in the USA, for example, it was estimated to be at least 9%.

Between 2018 and 2022, the discount retail market grew by a total of 8.9% in Sweden, Norway, and Finland according to Rusta’s estimate, driven partly by strong pandemic years. Despite this, the market overview predicted that growth would continue at a rate of about 8% per year, explained by, among other things, the uncertain economic situation supporting discount retail and increasing price consciousness among consumers.

rusta_markkinakatsaus

In the competitive landscape, Rusta competes in all markets (excl. Germany) with Biltema, Clas Ohlson, and Jula. In addition to these, key local competitors include DollarStore and ÖoB in Sweden, Europris in Norway, and Tokmanni and Puuilo in Finland. Ikea is naturally a competitor for Rusta in all countries in the interior category. The summary below (click to open) gives a good idea of which categories Rusta differentiates itself in relative to its main competitors.

Summary

Competitive landscape in Sweden
rusta_kilpailijat ruotsi

Competitive landscape in Norway
rusta_kilpailijat norja

Competitive landscape in Finland
rusta_kilpailijat suomi

Competitive landscape in Germany
rusta_kilpailijat saksa

This information could be supplemented by the fact that the share of private labels in Rusta’s sales is clearly the largest among its peer group (over 60%), and its gross margin percentage (over 40%) is among the highest. Fixed costs as a percentage of sales are correspondingly at the highest level, partly due to the overhead required for international growth.

Summary

rusta_private label

rusta_myyntikate

rusta_kiinteät kulut

rusta_oik.liikevoitto

By far the most important market for Rusta, in terms of both revenue and the number of stores, is Sweden, which currently accounts for ~60% of sales and about half of the stores. Based on previous quarters, it is also clearly the most profitable market area for Rusta.

Since Rusta’s operations are divided into three segments (Sweden, Norway, and Other Markets), one can get a fairly good idea of market-specific development, even though “Other Markets” covers Germany and e-commerce in addition to Finland. The summary below shows the market/segment-specific figures for the previous 12 months and the financial year in more detail.

Summary

Sweden segment
rusta_ruotsin segmentti

Norway segment
rusta_norjan segmentti

Other Markets segment (Finland, Germany, Online)
rusta_muut markkinat segmentti

Further resources

Since not much time has passed since the IPO at the time of writing, the most comprehensive information about Rusta can be found by reading its IPO prospectus. Below are also other relevant links related to Rusta.- IPO 2023 Prospectus

Here is a brief summary of what the company is roughly about. More analysis will likely be added over time as I get to know the company better—for example, regarding returns on capital, leverage, risks, share valuation, management and ownership, and the breadth and differentiation of the product range. Finally, it should be noted that any errors, blunders, or misunderstandings are my own, and I do not own the stock at the time of writing.

39 Likes

Thanks for the concise overview! If I remember the different stages correctly, it went as follows:

In connection with Rusta’s IPO, I got to know the company and its figures, including a Lynch-style field visit to the store itself. I also listened to, among other things, the IPO interviews given by the CEO and read analyst assessments made in Sweden.

Based on these, the summary was that it is definitely an interesting case, and especially the growth opportunities toward Germany are promising in principle. However, the pricing was not cheap at all relative to the figures. If I recall correctly, it was 45 kr/share. After the IPO, the stock had to be supported by stabilization purchases, and shorters went after it.

At that time, I considered buying a batch at the 44 kr level, but I didn’t follow through because the combination of stabilization purchases and shorting made me hesitate. Then the share price rose, if I remember correctly, to over 90 kr in the wake of a good interim report, and is now somewhere around 80 kr. My Rusta investment would have been a bet on the decline of Europe and especially Germany (phasing out nuclear power, etc.), where I saw potential for a player like Rusta.

Rusta’s cash cow is thus Mother Sweden’s domestic market, but the returns from international expansion haven’t been anything special. However, if things take off, especially in Germany, then the visions painted by the CEO in the IPO interviews I heard would come true. And it wouldn’t be a bad deal to pay the current price. If, on the other hand, profitability remains dependent only on the home market, similar to Kamux, and the international operations don’t take off, then it’s overpriced, perhaps even significantly so.

The upcoming interim report will soon provide more information on where things stand. Let’s hope for that takeoff :slight_smile:

10 Likes

Thanks for the great opening; I’ve been waiting a bit for someone more capable to take the initiative and start a dedicated thread for Rusta. :slight_smile:

The business is wonderfully simple. The customer enters, has to circle the entire store “mini-IKEA” style before reaching the checkouts. The snack and candy sections placed at the end of the store save the weary shopper.

In my opinion, the store layout is clever, and at least in the locations I’ve visited, the departments are very clearly divided: if you know what you’re looking for, you find the items very quickly. If you don’t, something small always ends up coming along anyway. There’s always traffic at our local Rusta, and it feels like sales are moving at a steady pace. Especially now in the spring/summer, the garden section has been drawing people in nicely (I get a good view of the situation on my way to work).

In addition to the Lynch-style observations, the already mentioned Q4 report is indeed essential, as it will be published tomorrow morning at 8:00 AM Finnish time. Below are the forecasts picked from Quartr to give us a ballpark to compare with tomorrow.

WhatsApp-Kuva 2024-06-12 klo 09.45.36_247f4a5a

On an annual level, Q1 and Q3 are the strongest quarters for Rusta (summer season & Christmas. Note! Exceptional dates for the quarters). Q4 is usually Rusta’s weakest quarter.

8 Likes

I suspect that in Finland, development is being somewhat hindered by the baggage of the “Hong Kong” brand. It has been about 4 years now since the “Honkkari” stores turned into Rusta. The selection, store concept, and especially the target audience are now very different from what they were during the Hong Kong era. If, in addition to the garden section, the main draws back then were fishing gear, car accessories, hardware, tools, and electrical supplies, today the angle is more home decor, decor, decor. It probably takes time for customers to get used to it.

6 Likes

For some, interior design is a hobby. Of course, flea markets and recycling centers sometimes complain that even Finns change their home decor too often.

I visited Rusta, lured by an advertisement. They were selling foldable stools that were about 25 cm high and, if I recall correctly, had a 150 kg weight capacity. I bought one and realized how convenient it is to keep it between the sink cabinet and the wall. It reduces the need to fetch that two-step Ikea stool—which probably every household has—from the kitchen.

The stool didn’t creak or squeak, and I was able to properly clean the top of the mirror cabinet; I even put paper on top, just as the Marthas (Martat) advise, to make it easier for next time. I noticed that the stool gives me just the right amount of extra height in the bathroom too when I’m hanging laundry (longer cardigans and other coats) to dry on the shower curtain rod.

I was in a hurry to go buy a couple more stools for myself and one for an elderly relative. It folds up and fits into a narrow space. Sticking your own hand into the gap takes up more room than taking the stool out.

At the same time, I bought a couple of pairs of thermal leggings. In freezing weather, it doesn’t matter whether they have a fly or not. They warm men’s legs nicely as well. When spending hours indoors, you can put the thermal leggings in a backpack and put them on again when going out into the cold.

It’s such a gender-neutral garment that it’s also suitable for a young male student. He won’t bother washing any long johns made of merino wool. For him, it’s enough to be able to walk from point A to point B even in the cold without freezing. No one is peering in the restroom at what you’re putting on or taking off.

There is a huge amount of stuff at Rusta, and it would take a whole workday to get acquainted with the entire selection. Due to my own dietary restrictions, I didn’t start reading the labels on the treat packages, but I do believe a “more normal” individual would find treats there to satisfy a craving.

5 Likes

Rusta’s interim report: earnings in the gutter.

Blames the weather and TietoEvry. It feels a bit like making excuses and an attempt to find external scapegoats?

4 Likes
  • Net sales increased by 2.9% (8.4%) and amounted to MSEK 2,268 (2,204

  • Gross profit increased by 8.0% and amounted to MSEK 976 (903) and the gross margin was 43.0% (41.0%)

  • Operating profit (EBIT) amounted to MSEK -49 (-57) and the operating profit margin was -2.2% (-2.6%)

  • The Board of Directors proposes a dividend of SEK 1.15 (SEK 0.69) per share

  • The fourth quarter was negatively impacted by operational disruptions as a result of the IT incident at Rusta’s hosting provider Tietoevry, with a total sales loss of approximately MSEK 61 million with a negative EBITA effect of approximately MSEK 48 million.

From what I read through the report myself, it doesn’t raise any concerns. Forecasts were pretty much met, there was a strong increase in loyal customers, a well-started summer season, and potential compensation from Tietoevry for the IT incident. The fact that the result is poor now in Q4 hopefully doesn’t surprise an investor who follows the company :).

10 Likes

Based on what I’ve read, it was quite a good year and quarter for Rusta, even though the IT incident disrupted this quarter as well. Discussions with Tietoevry regarding compensation for the mess are ongoing, and a resolution is apparently being sought through arbitration.

In the quarterly briefing presentation, the impact of the IT incident was detailed further. According to the company’s estimate, without the issues, comparable sales would have grown by 1.4% year-on-year instead of the -1.2% decline seen now, and the result (EBITA) would have been practically break-even during what is seasonally Rusta’s weakest quarter. Management commented in the briefing that the fourth quarter has historically always been loss-making, so breaking even is an improvement.

Summary of the IT incident's impact

rusta_it-sotkun kustannukset

For Rusta’s story, comparable sales growth and the scalability of profitability are key. Revenue can indeed be increased by opening new stores, but what matters in the long run is the sales and profitability extracted from each square meter over time. When looking at the annual development and comparing it to Rusta’s own targets, progress was as it should be: LFL growth of 4.6%, total growth of 9%, and adjusted EBITA of 7.1%. Without the IT complications, Rusta estimates these would have been 5.7%, 10.1%, and 7.5%, respectively; the financial targets are LFL growth of 3%, total growth of 8%, and EBITA of 8%.

Summary of the full year's development

rusta_koko vuosi

The “Other Markets” segment suffered the most from the problems, as Rusta—quite rightly—aimed to minimize damage primarily in its Swedish and Norwegian operations and keep store shelves full. Full-year profitability was slightly positive, apparently for the first time in history, and based on management comments, improvement has occurred especially in Finland. Comparable sales for the full year were -0.6%, which leaves room for improvement, even though the IT problems complicated things.

Management commented that the summer season has started well: ”We’ve had a good start on summer sales. And why is that important? Well, that usually goes a long way to support our gross margins in our first quarter, because the more of our summer sales we sell in the beginning of the season, the less the need for sellouts towards the end of the quarter.”

Store network development

rusta_myymäläverkosto

Regarding the development of the store network, it should be noted that there were 212 Rusta stores at the end of the quarter: 112 in Sweden, 48 in Norway, 42 in Finland, and in Germany. Additionally, 29 new store locations have been agreed upon and are waiting to be launched. This number has increased since the beginning of the year, even though stores have been opened from the 25 sites mentioned earlier. The CEO mentioned that most of the stores currently being opened are located in Sweden, where the payback period is shortest and profitability is highest.

10 Likes

A new extensive report on Tokmanni has been published, and it contains useful information about the market and competitive landscape (pp. 29-34) also from Rusta’s perspective, including comparative graphics on the differences in concepts and assortments between various players.

Graphics

valikoima_tokmanni_rusta

kategoriat_tokmanni_rusta

9 Likes

@Heikki_Keskivali has written a comprehensive post about Rusta. :slight_smile:

Discount retailers have one particularly attractive feature; they improve their performance in a recession, as the image from Rusta’s listing prospectus shows.

When people face financial hardship, companies selling more affordable products perform better than those selling expensive ones. This provides security during difficult times.

16 Likes

A day of celebration, not just for the devalued stock, but also in honor of the 50th Norwegian Rusta! Hurray! :partying_face:

On September 4, Rusta opened its 50th store in Norway. Rusta was established in Norway in 2014 and has since expanded in the Norwegian market, which is Rusta’s second largest after Sweden. The Norwegian market accounts for approximately 21 percent of Rusta’s total net sales, and Rusta has a nationwide store network in the country, from Lyndal in the south to Alta in the north.

6 Likes

Rusta released its results today:

My observations while reading the report:

  • Revenue grew by only 3.7% (missed estimates, strong start in May but faded throughout the quarter)
  • EBIT rose (beat estimates), margin increased by over a percentage point to 43.8
  • Weak consumer - price-conscious - the company expects a stronger autumn
  • Number of club members rose 14 percent to 5.8 million (very positive in my opinion - 80/20 rule etc.)
  • Cash flow weakened slightly
  • Other markets (Finland, Germany, and online) profitability improved slightly with EBITA margin at 5.7% (4.2%)

Additionally:
During the quarter, we reached an agreement with
Tietoevry on compensation for the operational disruptions
following the significant IT attack earlier this year. While the
details of the agreement are confidential, we consider the
settlement to be reasonable. The impact of the
compensation on earnings is positive but not material.

I’m not the best number cruncher, so I don’t know if this compensation has made the other numbers look better (e.g., improvement in other markets’ profitability YoY, if this money was recorded as online revenue etc.?)


I expected significantly stronger growth and am a bit disappointed. The consumer is more sour than I thought - on the positive side, good growth in club members. Stock price reaction is a total toss-up - I’m guessing downwards, though.

6 Likes

DNB is more positive

IMG_4130

2 Likes

Greetings from Stockholm!

Rusta Q1’24: Impressive profitability boost - Inderes
20240912_101948

9 Likes

In the afternoon, I excitedly thought, “Yes, a brand new interview in English” (the video was timestamped in English), but to my disappointment, it was in Swedish. :smiling_face_with_tear:
edit: The timestamping was perhaps the result of some automatic translator. :sweat_smile: Now it shows in Swedish, thanks @Sijoittaja-alokas

I’m not doubting anyone’s language skills but my own, but I don’t think this will reach everyone interested. If someone is able/has the time to write just a few bullet points on the core points (things that might not be apparent from the report), I would be very grateful. :pray:t3: :slight_smile:

The market really liked the report.

The Rusta video has been viewed 37 times on YouTube (two of which were mine :sweat_smile:). The language barrier probably pushes some investors away right from the start.

edit: And nothing away from @Isa_Hudd! It’s awesome that Swedish companies are getting coverage and interviews! :slight_smile:

7 Likes

@Arhi_Kivilahti’s thoughts on Rusta’s and Puuilo’s results can be found in the tweet and the link within the tweet, which I’ve also included separately below. Definitely worth checking out. :slight_smile:

Like Puuilo, Rusta’s profitability also improved. This was partly driven by a change in the sales structure. Additionally, the company has invested in improving the efficiency of its own value chain. Rusta intends to channel the resulting savings into offering lower prices. This, in turn, increases sales volumes, which in turn facilitates further efficiency improvements.

https://x.com/ArhiKivilahti/status/1834465444268323286

image

https://www.kaupantila.fi/p/puuilo-ja-rusta-menestyvat-vaikean?r=8kh0k&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&triedRedirect=true

8 Likes

Hi, I wrote some short notes for the SE side and translated them (NOTE: with the help of AI, so I can’t promise anything about quality + accuracy, but here’s at least something to go on.
Original text can be found here:
https://forum.inderes.se/t/rusta-en-ledande-aktor-pa-den-nordiska-lagprismarknaden/631/4?u=isa_hudd

DIRECT TRANSLATION BELOW:

My own short notes from the interview and Q1 presentation (Rusta has a split fiscal year - in connection with Thursday’s report release, figures for May, June, and July were presented).

Difficult market for retail: customers are holding back on “capital-intensive purchases”: meaning they buy all the small items very price-consciously (toothbrushes, toilet paper, etc.), but refrain from larger purchases, such as new outdoor grills or sofa furniture.

Despite this, Rusta is growing in all segments: SWE, NO + others (FIN, GER + online).

Margins are improving and moving towards “normalization” at the gross margin level (the 44-45 percent target has almost been reached at the 43+ percent level right now).

Improving margins at the same or lower price levels - i.e., for the right reasons - bodes well.

Poorer “macro times” pave the way for more store openings, because you then have a good negotiating position for good premises in central locations at low prices.

Currently, there are plans to open as many as 35 stores - across the Nordics.

In Denmark, as you know, there are no operations (yet), but it’s not something they are closing the door on for the future.

Germany: currently reviewing all actions taken so far and what the next initiatives look like. A large and interesting market for the family.

Club Rusta is growing continuously. GW notes that few loyalty programs or operators in general reach as many customers across such diverse segments.

Number of products in-store: about 6,000 items, which is significantly fewer than at Tokmanni, Dollarstore, and Puuilo. This also contributes to the winning concept: a focused product range that is just right.

What was discussed in the webcast, but I simply forgot to bring up in the interview: The Tietoevry fiasco is now over. (They couldn’t talk about the details anyway, but a settlement has been reached).

Personal comments: A CEO who is clear in his communication. Doesn’t dodge any questions, and you can see that he is passionately involved in his work.

11 Likes

I tried to interpret the interview, and I reached the exact same conclusion. I’m happy to let this man steer the company that represents the largest position in my portfolio. :slight_smile:

Thank you so much for the great summary, and I hope my previous message didn’t come across as dismissive; I really appreciate the work you’re doing there! I’m truly glad we’re getting high-quality analysis/interviews on Swedish companies. :smiling_face_with_three_hearts:

6 Likes

Annual General Meeting held today, key takeaway:

  • Dividend SEK 1.15 / share. Record date 24.9., payment 27.9.
2 Likes

Press/investor news from a few days ago regarding the opening of new stores in Sweden and Norway. In terms of sales and profitability, Sweden and Norway are clearly Rusta’s most important markets. With these new openings, the network now has a total of 217 stores, and the next couple are under development in Sweden.

4 Likes