Nordic Mining - Norwegian mining company in transition

I thought I’d open a thread for this Norwegian mining company, as we are currently living through decisive moments in the company’s long journey. I’ll start by providing some background, but it would be great to hear the views of others familiar with the company and to follow its development together in the future.

Nordic Mining (i.e., NOM) was founded in 2007, and its beginning, typical for a new mining company, was accompanied by hype. The company had several prospects, the best of which was the Engebø rutile deposit on the Norwegian coast. There were other deposits as well, but most of them have been abandoned over the years. NOM was also an early-stage financier of the Finnish company Keliber and at its peak owned over 38 percent of the company. Today, the ownership has diluted to approximately 14 percent. Currently, NOM’s value consists mainly of Engebø and, to a lesser extent, of Keliber, which is currently developing positively.

I personally invested in this for the first time in 2012, and since then, I have followed its progress quite closely. Typically for a mining project development company, operations have been financed through regular share issues, of which there have been more than a dozen over the years. The project has progressed well in itself - to the extent that the company itself could influence it - but slow bureaucracy, in particular, has caused delays. Obtaining permits has been difficult, requiring many additional studies over the years. The environmental permit was granted in 2015, followed by a pre-feasibility study, a definite feasibility study enabling bank financing, and an updated feasibility study due to the changed market situation caused by the pandemic. The operating permit for the mine was granted in summer 2020, and appeals against it were rejected in late 2020. However, the rejections still need to be confirmed by the ministry, and that decision is still awaited.

Recent setbacks also include a “competing mining company,” Arctic Mineral Resources, whose founders include a former board member of NOM. The company was founded when this founder and some landowners in the area claimed that NOM did not have the right to conduct mining operations in the area. The background to this is that minerals in Norway are divided into two categories, “state minerals” and “landowner minerals,” and different legislation applies to them. Engebø’s main mineral is rutile, which is a state mineral, but garnet, which is a landowner mineral, comes as a byproduct. AMR claims that profitable mining operations would be possible based solely on garnet, meaning NOM would not have the right to conduct mining operations in the area. This was litigated last month, and a decision is expected by September 24, 2021. AMR thus demanded the rejection of NOM’s mining permit. There was an interesting twist in the legal process: since AMR’s claim relates to a permit granted by an authority, the Norwegian state should have been involved in the lawsuit. For this reason, I consider the most likely outcome to be that AMR’s claim will be rejected, and if they wish to continue the process, they will have to sue the Norwegian state instead of NOM. This should not prevent NOM from commencing mine ramp-up. Overall, this AMR debacle has caused general uncertainty for the project and has certainly delayed financing negotiations for the mine ramp-up. However, AMR’s arguments are on weak ground - there has been a great deal of discussion about these in a shareholder group on Facebook, where the seven-day trial was followed in real-time.

But the reason I wanted to open a thread for this discussion now relates to the following matters expected to occur in the coming months:

  • The NFD (Norwegian Ministry of Trade, Industry and Fisheries) confirms Engebø’s operating permit, which the Directorate of Mining has already granted. This decision was supposed to come earlier in the year but has been delayed, according to the ministry, due to urgent matters caused by the pandemic. Norwegian co-owners consider the parliamentary elections on September 13 to be a more likely reason - granting the permit before the elections could have a negative impact on the Venstre party, which is responsible for the ministry.

  • The decision of the AMR lawsuit is due by September 24. If (and presumably when) it is favorable to NOM, it will reduce project-related uncertainty and accelerate the ramp-up.

  • For rutile, offtake agreements are already in place with Japanese and European parties; for garnet, which is a byproduct, an agreement could come at any time.

  • Financing negotiations are intended to be finalized during the autumn. The project aims to be financed mainly by a bank loan, secured by, among other things, the aforementioned offtake agreements. I expect news on financing soon after the NFD decision and the court ruling.

If the above points materialize, this project will rapidly move from the mine project development phase to the mine ramp-up phase. That is, to a similar stage where Keliber is currently. Production could start perhaps around 2024-2025.

The company’s market value is currently around 60 million euros. According to the updated profitability calculation, the mine’s (conservative) net present value after taxes is around 220 million, with significant potential beyond that. On top of this, there’s the share in Keliber, whose net present value is nearly 400 million.

More detailed information on the project and figures can be found through Engebø’s updated feasibility study:

As a final note, it must be said that the project has been interesting to follow for the past ten years, but these funds would have generated better returns elsewhere until now. The stock price has not yet priced in the true potential; instead, due to the aforementioned risks, among others, the price has remained low. However, we are living in moments when things should start to happen - I don’t believe operations will need to be financed by share issues for the next 10 years.

Hopefully, the introduction wasn’t too rambling and confusing, but rather provides some kind of overview of the company. Let’s elaborate on this in future messages if there are others interested or familiar with the topic here.

22 Likes

There’s a good thread about this company on the KL side; the schedules have stretched a bit… I was involved in this myself some time ago but bailed out when nothing much got done. An interesting project; perhaps I’ll jump in closer to the opening.

3 Likes

Elections were held in Norway yesterday. It was already known beforehand that the right-wing would lose and power would change. For NOM, the essential question was how strong a position the Socialist Left Party (SV) would gain and whether the far-left Rødt or MdG (Greens) would have to be brought into the government. Both outcomes were favorable. SV is part of the government but did not strengthen significantly, unlike the Centre Party. And the Labour Party, the Centre Party, and SV together have a majority of three, meaning Rødt or MdG are not needed in the government. So perhaps this could be described as a “defensive victory.”

And today, the share price saw some life, as the CEO bought shares (perhaps encouraged by the election results): Nordic Mining ASA: Mandatory notification of trade – primary insider - Nordic Mining ASA

We continue to await other news in the near future.

1 Like

The stock exchange announcement that just came out says that the court’s decision is expected in week 41, i.e., mid-October. The original deadline was this Friday. A small but annoying delay.

Ruling in case against Artic Mineral Resources expected mid-October - Nordic Mining ASA (cision.com)

The mood of anticipation continues. NFD’s permit decision could come at any time.

2 Likes

No verdict this week. Delays seem to be in this company’s DNA. This probably applies more broadly to the entire mining industry. This time, an unofficial message from the Oslo District Court states:

“The verdict is not ready yet, but is expected next week. It will be sent out as soon as it is ready. It is true that it was planned ready for week 41, but there have unfortunately been some delays.” caseworker Oslo District Court

So, until next week.

3 Likes

The decision came from the court, which sided with Nordic Mining. This again reduces uncertainty regarding the realization of the mining project. Apparently, AMR also had to pay 3.5 million Norwegian kroner in compensation.

1 Like

Yes, finally! The decision is here. This significantly reduces the risk of the project. Of course, we are still waiting for the processing of appeals regarding the environmental permit (Finnish: käyttölupa), which I would guess will also be decided in the coming days or weeks. After that, the path is clear.

AMR will also have to pay NOM’s legal costs, 3.5 million Norwegian kroner. This additional cost on top of everything else might be a tough pill for the landowners to swallow. We’ll see if they dare to appeal the verdict and go for another round. I doubt it, as this case was so clear.

Here’s a recent article from Firda on the matter: Førde, Naustdal | AMR lost in court – must pay 3.5 million kroner to Nordic Rutile

Financing has been prepared for a long time, and I believe it has been negotiated and is ready for signatures. Now that a resolution has been reached in this legal process and once the appeals are handled, I believe news of the financing solution will follow immediately. Still this autumn.

Tomorrow, I believe the stock price will react very positively. This is the first step towards the true value of the mining project, for which there is still a long way to go.

2 Likes

{“content”:“Clearly, AMR is appealing, and if I understood correctly, they interpret that they are entitled to the garnet proceeds based on that court decision. Even though the decision should be in Nordic Mining’s favor, is there still some room for interpretation here? How do you see that court decision?”}

I haven’t read the verdict myself, but from what the Norwegians have said, I’ve understood the following:

  • The stock exchange release stated: “–company has the right to extract and - within the limits of the Norwegian Mining’s Act - utilize garnet and all other minerals on the Vevring side of the Engebø deposit.”
  • Apparently, AMR has interpreted the court’s decision to mean that NOM can start mining, but AMR would have the right to all profits from the garnet. This would naturally undermine the entire project.
  • NOM, on the other hand, interprets the matter as I quoted above, meaning that NOM is indeed obligated to compensate landowners for the garnet - as stipulated by the Norwegian Mining Act. This does not mean that all profits must be compensated, but a small share as mandated by law. There is nothing surprising about this; it has naturally always been known.

I can’t personally interpret whether AMR’s claim has any basis or if it’s more about communication to its own owners, i.e., the landowners on the Vevring side, who have money at stake and a lost court case behind them. Naturally, AMR’s management and legal firm want to continue the case; they have nothing to lose.

If the court’s decision could be interpreted as AMR does, meaning they would be entitled to all profits, then NOM would hardly be able to communicate about it as it has done. But the question is probably whether some authority can resolve this matter directly (e.g., by denying a new appeal) or if it will have to be resolved in court. That would be another proceeding whose outcome would itself be clear, but it would take time and could affect the project’s other progress.

However, I personally believe that even if this goes to court for another round, this verdict is clear enough that NOM could secure financing immediately after the processing of the operating permit appeals and start ramping up the project. The question is whether financiers dare to join a project with ongoing legal proceedings. I believe they would dare now, as a verdict has already been rendered on the matter.

I also read Ivar Fossum’s interview, a snippet of which was on that Norwegian discussion forum. He was very convinced, as you also said, that they now have the rights to all minerals in the mining area. There should be no more ambiguity about this, and we will proceed according to Norwegian mining laws.

Here’s the verdict if anyone wants to take a look. Use Google Translate if Norwegian isn’t your strong suit.

87_Dom i sivil sak-fagdommer.pdf (316.0 KB)

I received a notice that AMR is appealing the decision. Does anyone have information about the possible processing time for this appeal? It’s annoying how the opposing party knows how to and can prolong the matter. Will this lawsuit drag on well into next year?

Fortunately, in recent weeks, I’ve also been able to read about new personnel selections and contracting agreements for the project. If only we’d hear news from the ministry as well.

1 Like

Here is the link to the Q3 report, which again includes a summary of mining projects and events.

2 Likes

Good news.

1 Like

Hehe, for a couple of minutes in the FB group, people thought it was a decision regarding complaints about the operating permit - someone probably even opened champagne. :sweat_smile: Judging by the stock reactions and trading volumes, many others were mistaken too. I didn’t even remember that such complaints were being processed.

However, one could speculate from this that there would be some coordination of work at the ministry and that this decision increases the probability of a positive decision on the operating permit as well.

@Waldeboy A notice came out that AMR is appealing the decision. Does anyone have information on the possible processing time for this appeal? Annoyingly, the opposing party knows how to and can prolong the matter. Will this lawsuit drag on well into next year?

The processing could take a long time, but elsewhere it was speculated that this would no longer affect the ramp-up of Engebø or the securing of financing. For the first 15 years, operations can take place elsewhere than on the Vevring side, which this dispute concerns. Of course, it affects the valuation of the mine. But perhaps the NFD operating permit decision already means a lot here - how they will react to the court’s interpretation that garnet is a “landowner mineral” (landowner mineral) in the Engebø deposit. This question was part of the court’s decision and is significant for determining what kind of compensation NOM will have to pay to landowners / AMR.

2 Likes

I also had to go back and read old announcements to figure out which decision regarding the appeals was in question.

This sounds reasonable. It would be good to get to the mine construction phase soon.

NFD requested a consultation from the Ministry of Climate and Environment regarding the processing of the permit.

The response was released the day before yesterday and is here:
Vurdering av anførsler om miljømessige konsekvenser i klager om Nordic Rutiles prosjekt i Engebøfjellet.pdf (213.1 KB)

In practice, the response refutes all complaints and states that previous permits have been handled properly.

This consultation has probably been part of the “assurance” in handling the permit, meaning they want to do everything as thoroughly as possible and secure it in advance.

Based on the response, one can again be a little more certain that a positive message will come soon. Perhaps even today? Hopefully before Christmas, at least.

5 Likes

Well, the permit didn’t arrive before Christmas.

Around Christmas and since then, a few documents have been collected in the FB group that shed some light on where things stand.

On December 16, NFD requested comments from NOM and AMR’s lawyers regarding the decision to extend NOM’s mining permit.

image

This matter was dealt with as part of the autumn court proceedings and it was stated that the permit is valid. This request is probably only due to NFD wanting to handle the case “from the ground up”.

A deadline of January 6 was given for responses. NOM’s lawyer submitted his response on December 21. Glittertind, the law firm acting on behalf of AMR, requested an extension on January 3 to prepare its response, and on January 4, NFD replied that no extension would be granted. Since then, Glittertind has not sent a response.

Today, the entire letter sent on December 16 was finally displayed. It specifically requested comments from landowners. The background to this is likely that the court’s decision stated that although the permits were processed correctly, landowners could have been heard better in the process. Now, NFD wants to correct this error and give landowners the opportunity to comment.

Anmodning om innspill til vurdering av omgjøring av Direktoratet for mineralforvaltning.pdf (148.5 Kt)

So the responses were submitted by yesterday. Now it is estimated that the permit could arrive within 2-3 weeks, so during January. The share price has started to rise nicely. Few dare to sell anymore, and many are taking their last positions before the permit decision. I also refueled a little more today, just to be sure.

8 Likes

Just a little more information:

One group member asked NFD in early November about the timetable for handling complaints. The answer came the day before yesterday and, freely translated into Finnish, read as follows:

“We respond to your inquiry sent on November 2, 2021, regarding the handling of Engebø complaints. The complaint is being processed by the Ministry of Trade and Industry. The finalization of the decision has been delayed, as the Ministry has had limited capacity for a long time due to the management of the coronavirus pandemic. The Engebø case has priority, and a decision will be made shortly.”

Especially that last sentence (English: “The case has priority, and a decision will be made shortly.”) suggests to me that the decision will be made in the coming weeks.

5 Likes

More information on investing in NOM can also be found on Norway’s Tekinvestor website. However, it requires registration.

2 Likes