Remedy - The pride of Finnish AAA games (Part 2)

Here is an excellent analysis of Remedy’s new CEO selection. Highly recommended to watch/listen to this 15-minute video, even though the beginning is a bit provocative.

They also cover Epyllion’s latest analysis, which I summarized in the gaming industry news thread.

Regarding Remedy, it is essential that growth in Remedy’s main market (EU/US) is practically flat, and market growth in the gaming industry comes largely from China. If you are not present and successful in China, you must sell 1.6x in the flat market to keep up with market growth.

12 Likes

@Pia_Maljanen and @Atte_Riikola discussed Remedy regarding Q4 :slight_smile:

Remedy’s investment story is entering a pivotal year, as the company is about to release what is arguably its most important game so far: Control Resonant. For the value creation of Remedy’s share, it is essential to succeed with the release. Analyst Atte Riikola summarizes.

This video can also be found on the Inderes Nordic channel:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrl8Srz0eEQgdLhTvKzS85g

11 Likes

The PlayStation 5 exclusive Marvel’s Wolverine, developed by Insomniac Games, has received a release date. The action-adventure starring the popular comic book hero will be released on September 15th.

September is now booked. Remedy should ideally act by early August at the latest.

8 Likes

I can’t help but put on my speculation hat regarding at least Alan Wake Remastered finally making its way to Steam. A fairly comprehensive PC update was released for the game today. I don’t think there have been any for about three years?

What makes this peculiar is that AWR was, I believe, a remaster done by a subcontracting firm, but I have a gut feeling that these are updates made by an in-house team. Still, Epic is still the publisher, and one would imagine they wouldn’t have much interest in putting resources into AWR support just for the sake of the Luna deal. :thinking:

Of course, this could be part of Remedy’s own “wanting to take care of the back catalog” culture and there happened to be developers available to do it. But since these updates really haven’t been seen in ages, it was hard not to take this as some kind of signal.

13 Likes

Interesting.

A few-second release date reveal for Wolverine 2 weeks after Sony’s own State of Play as a PS5 exclusive release seems quite… random? Either they are outrageously confident or in deep trouble up to their hairlines. The latter wouldn’t be surprising, as the game was announced back in 2021 and the creative leadership seems to have changed at some point.

It wouldn’t hurt Resonant at all if Wolverine flopped, although usually one has to hope for the best for Sony’s single-player games and especially Insomniac so that Sony understands to keep making and releasing single-player games too.

Agreed. I thought the earlier “Alan Wake Origins” name change was quite a far-fetched indication that the newer AW games were coming to Steam. Updating AWR only now at the end of February is indeed strange, given that the game was, as I understand it, “Free with Amazon Prime/Luna” already in early January.

Other chatter and speculation

Control Resonant has continued its nice growth in wishlist rankings. It’s currently 56th on Steam wishlists, even though the release date isn’t even known. For example, I/O Interactive’s 007: First Light, coming out in May, is at 43. However, there hasn’t been any very dramatic explosion on Gamalytic after the gameplay reveal trailer; it rose about 5% from 600k → 630k. Still, wishlist activity has dropped quite low, so another trailer or more marketing is definitely needed soon.

By the way, the new CEO starts next week. Hopefully, they can get right to coaching the publishing team and use their Asian network partners to support the launch of Control Resonant.

As a final piece of speculation, I’ve been wondering when on earth the game will start pre-orders. Sony just had a SoP, and Wolverine’s release date was dropped randomly, so nothing new is likely coming from Sony before May-June. Maybe at most some Saros deep dive from Sony, if Housemarque is lucky. A Summer Game Fest release date announcement might be a bit tight for marketing pre-orders through July if the release is in August-October—and of course, it’s a bit too close to GTA and Wolverine anyway.

I started wondering if Control Resonant could also be coming to Game Pass?

Considering the company’s history and risk avoidance, taking a risk-free Game Pass deal would make sense. Because if Resonant were a flop on the level of Firebreak, the company would essentially be forced back into subcontracting or under the dictates of publishers for a long time, maybe permanently. From the perspective of main owner Markus Mäki, he probably doesn’t want to put everything on red in roulette after 30 years in the company. I don’t believe they would take such a risk.

If Control flops, the publishing terms from potential partners for Alan Wake 3 would also be very harsh. Regardless of how well or poorly Resonant sells, the company must have some cash support of its own for AW3 funding to improve its own negotiation and financing position.

If roughly €7.5M was received for Firebreak, then Resonant, with double the budget, should get at least €15M. Likely more. Even conservatively, they should get €20-25M from a Game Pass deal. Based on last year’s leak, the biggest AAA games are paid up to $50M.

We already saw with Alan Wake 2, where the original game was an Xbox exclusive at launch, that it’s impossible to sell anything on Xbox other than “forever games” or the very top games of the year.

€25M would roughly correspond to 0.5M copies at an average price of €60 after VAT and distribution shares. It’s hard to imagine reaching that very easily on Xbox, at least in the launch window, no matter how good the game is.

2024 might have already hinted at Game Pass because I really don’t know how a 100% ROI, i.e., €110-120M in game sales after VAT and distribution shares, is achieved with 3-4M LIFETIME (!) copies, especially as the average price of the game drops over time. Atte predicts a break-even at roughly 1.8M copies. Of course, the game can’t maintain the same average price until the end of its lifecycle, but if there were twenty million or so in Game Pass money, it would look at least a bit more realistic.

On the other hand, they fell short of that 3M copy target for Firebreak by about 3M copies, so maybe one shouldn’t give too much weight to Tero’s story slides anyway.

Anyway, the point of this whole post is that if Xbox organizes its own Partner Preview event in March, that might be the last hope for a Q2 release date. Previously, I thought the event would be too small for Resonant, but the situation changes if the game is available as a Game Pass Ultimate Day 1 title. In that case, dropping the release date in the same event would make sense.

On the other hand, an Xbox Partner Preview has only been held in March once before, on March 6, 2024. Otherwise, the Partner Preview has been held annually in October. On the flip side, even though Sony is majorly bungling their PR with Bluepoint, Xbox is superior in the competition for negative PR, now that Phil Spencer was kicked out and an AI exec was brought in to lead. To clean up the mess from this bungling, diverting players’ attention elsewhere with a Partner Preview could be a pretty low-risk, high-reward move if they show a bit more of Crimson Desert and Marathon, and why not Subnautica 2, which is also supposed to come out this year.

Personally, I’d at least take the easy wins from Xbox while they’re available. The next couple of weeks should show whether a late Q2 release is realistic, or if it moves to Q3.

11 Likes

One potential venue for a release date trailer would be the Future Games Show on March 12th, where Firebreak was also showcased last year. If we don’t hear anything then, it’ll likely be pushed to the summer, and by then it’ll be almost certain that the game won’t be out until later in the fall.

I was also surprised by that AW Remastered update, considering it probably sells about one copy a day on Epic, which makes you wonder if it’s worth investing much into it. It inevitably brings a Steam release to mind, but we’ll see…

6 Likes

I would guess the update is related to the fact that AW2 and AWR just became available on Amazon Luna (a GeForce Now-style cloud service where the game runs on a server and the image is streamed to the TV, for example, via an Amazon Fire TV stick). So it would just be some minor fine-tuning and tech updates with that platform in mind.

1 Like

In-depth analysis of Control Resonant. They got to see more of the game last week at an “Extended Preview” event. This likely means more of the game has been shared with the gaming media, so one could imagine we’ll hear more about Resonant soon in the form of a trailer. Perhaps a release date will be pushed out then as well.

Edit:

Also a preview out from IGN.

From what I’ve seen so far, it looks very good.

17 Likes

So the preview dropped at the exact same time as the previews for Crimson Desert, which is one of the most anticipated games of the year. And the Crimson Desert preview embargos have been public knowledge. :person_facepalming:

I also don’t quite understand why Remedy wants to repeatedly highlight this “not-soulslike” thing in their communication? Even in the comments, it shifts the discussion toward whether it is or isn’t a soulslike, and simply bringing the matter up might alienate Souls fans from the game. Unbelievable. :person_facepalming:

They should just show the game and let players form their own opinions.

The publishing team certainly doesn’t get any points from me. Fortunately, the gameplay looks much better and faster than in the gameplay reveal.

It strongly smells like a Q3 release based on IGN’s coverage.

18 Likes

As expected, the Resonant preview is being overshadowed by Crimson Desert (140k vs 230k views, both ~98% positive), but it still seems to be trending significantly better than Alan Wake 2’s IGN hands-on preview did back in the day.

Below are preview articles from a few gaming media outlets about Resonant, including the headline + closing statement. The comments are mostly (cautiously?) optimistic. However, this was a hands-off preview, meaning no one got to play it themselves, and in such cases, it’s obviously not wise for a journalist to praise or criticize it too much.

Ryan Mcaffrey, IGN

Control Resonant First-Look Preview – This Is No Soulslike. It’s Faster

What I came away with surprised me: I adored the first Control, but early indications are that I might like Resonant even more. Why? It’s not just that it’s markedly different and not just a same-y sequel, but it’s that its melee combat might scratch my Ninja Gaiden-style itch

Tamoor Hussain, Gamespot

Control Resonant Gameplay Preview: Doing The Unexpected With The Familiar (Web)

At times it does kind of play like Bayonetta, it is similar to the setup of InFamous, and The Gap is basically Alan Wake 2’s Mind Place. We can put all that into a box and say we know what Control Resonant is. But if Remedy has taught us anything, it’s that you might know what’s in the box and it might not surprise you, but maybe the box itself might do something you don’t expect.

Michael McWhertor, Polygyon

Why Control Resonant is an action-RPG — and not fully open world

Based on each new look at Control Resonant, it appears that Remedy is building a very different game compared to the first Control. While the aesthetic, atmosphere, and dark humor of the first seem to still be present in Control Resonant, it will likely appeal to a different type of player, one who likes fiddling with skills, stats, and a variety of combat styles. It’s refreshing to see Remedy swerve with its sequel, welcoming a potential new audience into its impressive, surreal sci-fi thriller world.

Robin Valentine, PC Gamer

Control Resonant is far more of an RPG than I expected, complete with talent trees, stats screens, and build-crafting that wouldn’t feel out of place in a Diablo game

The big question mark for me, however, is how all this actually feels in the hands. At a glance Control Resonant looks like a take on Devil May Cry’s frenzied action-combat, but the more I see of it the more I think it seems stiff and stilted compared to that series. But if the RPG systems are truly as extensive as they look, and feel satisfying to master and tinker with, then perfectly smooth action may not be necessary. We never expected Mass Effect to be as tight a third-person shooter as Gears of War, after all.
–
Hopefully it won’t be too much longer before I’m able to go hands-on and get a more decisive sense of the game. In the meantime I’m cautiously optimistic.
–
I can understand fears that Remedy has bitten off more than it can chew here, with such a radical shift in style and genre. But this is a studio that loves building wild new combat systems for each of its games, from the time-manipulating gunplay of Quantum Break to the telekinetic chaos of Control to the survival horror of Alan Wake 2. The specifics of Control Resonant may be unexpected, but it certainly isn’t surprising to see the studio take yet another bold, creative swing with the game’s action.

Olly Smith, Gamingbible

Control Resonant Is An Action Masterpiece For Total Sickos, Like Me

As a huge Remedy fanboy, it’s safe to say that Control Resonant is shapeshifting up to be one of my most anticipated games of the year. I’m confident in Remedy’s slight alteration in genre, using more character action elements to deliver an experience that feels wholly different from its predecessor, while still retaining familiar elements which make it a Control game.

Release window getting confirmed?

Control Resonant is following the marketing pace of Alan Wake 2 quite closely so far, from the Gameplay Reveal to the hands-off previews—meaning a gap of about 3 weeks between them. With AW2, the hands-off preview after SGF was pretty much 4 months before the planned launch (Oct 17). Based on this, late June could still be possible. Alternatively, August. In September, there’s Phantom Blade (PC) and Wolverine (PS5), and historically, big AAA games aren’t released in July. Whatever the release window, SGF will likely be the most natural place to hold hands-on previews for a wider group of journalists.

Milestone Alan Wake 2 (2023) Control Resonant (2026)
First Gameplay Reveal May 24 (PS Showcase) Feb 12 (State of Play)
Hands-Off Previews June 10 (~3 weeks later) March 4 (~3 weeks later)
Hands-On Previews Sept 27 (1 month before) Est: After SGF?
Launch Oct 17/27 Est: Late June/Early Aug?

This month will likely clarify whether the release will be in June or August (or later). Potential events this March include only the Future Games Show next week alongside GDC on March 12, and possibly an Xbox Partner Preview/Developer Direct. FGS is perhaps too small, and there are no guarantees regarding an Xbox event. If there’s no new news this month, then August seems almost certain.

However, with current information, it’s hard to see Resonant’s release falling outside the June–August 2026 window.

26 Likes

As a new feature in Remedy’s marketing, Dev Diaries are also being released at least on the PlayStation channel. This is a good additional effort, and it’s important to remember that the main goal here is not to find new customers for Resonant, but to move those already aware of Resonant further down the sales funnel toward becoming potential buyers.

16 Likes

Some Control Resonant content has been released recently. New gameplay from multiple sources, for example https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZwFXB2Z7hzo.

Today, NVIDIA released Path Tracing & DLSS 4.5 content https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NNd4ZxUze3E. I have to say, while the content looks truly excellent graphically, I got chills from the music in that video :smiley: Really cool-sounding stuff.

You can really see from everything that the drive is on a completely different level now that they are back to their core work, I’m looking forward to it.

26 Likes

Trailers, previews, and such have been coming out at such a fast pace lately that you can’t help but wonder if we might see a Q2 launch after all. There is still quite a long time until August-September. How would they fill all those months until then, now that there is such good buzz? Even the hands-off preview event held for a large group of media outlets seems quite early if the game isn’t coming out until after the summer. Future Games Show has been posting Resonant content on X to such an extent that it seems likely we’ll see something in that show as well.

The latest trailer also featured the Mac App Store logo at the end as a new addition. Plus, it will be on GeForce Now right at launch.

11 Likes

Great insights from @Hasty. I was planning to write about the same thing. Good to see that the Nvidia partnership is flourishing. Speculating optimistically, hopefully the accelerating marketing activity (three videos in six days) anticipates a preorder/reveal date trailer soon?

  • 4.3. Hands-off Previews e.g., IGN
  • 6.3. Beyond the Oldest House: Development Diary - video
  • 10.3. Nvidia Geforce/Path Tracing Trailer

And those marketing efforts don’t seem entirely fruitless, as Steam wishlists (Gamalytic) jumped from 630k to 670k in a few days, while Steam wishlist rankings are improving at a steady pace. Currently 55th (cf. 68th mentioned in Atte’s report 1 month ago).

If current pricing is reflected against Atte’s scenario analysis, then if I interpret it correctly, at the current price, roughly 1.3–1.4M copies are expected from Resonant’s 2026 (and all future AAA game releases) sales during the first ~6 months.

In other words, the expectation is that all future AAA games (excl. MPR) will sell at roughly the same pace or slightly slower than Alan Wake 2. When factoring in storefront limitations (EGS, lack of physical copies), significantly weaker sales success is expected for future games than for Alan Wake 2.

In the graph below, Remedy’s announced sales milestones are shown with solid lines, and Atte’s forecasts with dashed lines.


Hopefully, we’ll get updated sales milestones in the annual report; data for everything except Control is starting to be over a year old.

On the other hand, because Control Resonant is a very binary risk and a roll of the dice for the entire company’s future, I think it is also very justified to factor a risk discount into the valuation, even if one believes in moderate success for Resonant in the base case.

In the early stages of the investment case in 2017–2018, I recall @Mikael_Rautanen describing the company’s risk-reward ratio as asymmetric in his analyses, even though the company was releasing a completely new IP in a weak position relative to the publisher. The analysis was correct, and the asymmetric return potential was realized when the valuation nearly decupled as a result of Control and the gaming industry bubble. We all know which direction the share price has taken since then.

Today, the company owns the IPs and publishing rights for its two game series, and at the same time, the pricing has been pushed to 5-year lows. EV today ~€165M.

Even though gaming industry valuations have fallen, for example, last year Krafton bought Eleventh Hour Games, which relied on a single game, Last Epoch, and generated about $42M USD in revenue in 2024. Granted, Last Epoch was a decent release selling a couple of million copies, and the M&A negotiation position is much better compared to if, for example, Control Resonant were to flop. In principle, however, it is hard to see Remedy being sold for less than EHG’s M&A prices. At prices below €80–90M, I believe it is more profitable for the company to continue its co-publishing activities focused on outsourcing or low self-financing shares for its games than to sell the studio. In that case, the valuation could, of course, justifiably drop deep into the single digits.

The company’s position in the value chain is the best it has ever been, and the releases of Control Resonant (and Max Payne) are closer than ever. Resonant’s wishlists and the visibility of trailers/previews are likely the best the company has ever had. I don’t know if it’s too early for the more optimistic investors to start talking about an asymmetric risk-reward ratio again? I don’t dare declare this myself yet, but if the valuation continues to decline and preorder data and further wishlist developments are encouraging, I might dare to stand behind such a term again myself.

22 Likes

https://x.com/i/status/2031761604967026710

As I recall, they commented on Twitter earlier that they had been involved in organizing a hands-off preview held for the press. Now there are also clear hints that something is coming, and as Hasty mentioned, FGS is on Thursday.

Let’s hope we finally get that release date now.

12 Likes

Kasurinen is promising over on Discord that we will hear more about the game again soon.

16 Likes

A few scattered observations following up on the Discord tease from Kasurinen picked up by Hasty.


Observation 1

Nvidia has apparently been splashing cash to market Path Tracing, DLSS 4.5, and Mega Geometry, among others, with Control: Resonant and 007: First Light as their spearheads. The videos are approaching three million views in just a couple of days.


Observation 2:

The next updated version of Sony’s own PSSR upscaler is coming to both Control: Ultimate Edition and Alan Wake 2 (AMD hardware, Sony software).


Observation 3:

The first concrete example I’ve seen of community building/marketing for Resonant in China.

You can read more about the massive importance of China and markets outside the stagnating EU/US for the growth of the gaming industry and PC market here: Pelialan päivän polttavat, uutiset ja yhtiöt - #1338 käyttäjältä Akee

If Resonant reaches a significant China/Asia/South America audience at launch, this could be a major hype and marketing factor in today’s “Live or die by the CCU” internet discussions. This is regardless of the fact that local publishing terms or prices might not be comparable to the traditional Western market.

31 Likes

Last major update for Firebreak

18 Likes

https://x.com/i/status/2034222464075518335

Resonant’s marketing continues with the following steps. Tomorrow, March 19th, the May (?) issue of Edge Magazine will be released. AW2 was also the main theme in the same magazine in August 2023 when the October issue came out. (10th August 2023 <br> EDGE's New October 2023 Edition Features <i>Alan Wake 2</i> Cover [UPDATED] ~ The Sudden Stop)

There are again indications here that the game might possibly be released in June.

Discussion about the upcoming issue on Resetera:

20 Likes

This also reminded me of a fourth observation I forgot to write about. They switched to the “coming soon” wording on social media last week, which they hadn’t used before. It would feel like a bit of a premature term if the release were still about 6 months away in the fall?

It’s not worth marketing anything this week, as the Crimson Desert release is taking up all the spotlight. From next week onwards, there would be bandwidth again for further marketing/news. And on the other hand, if we don’t hear any news in the coming weeks, the release window will inevitably be narrowed down to a later date.


20 Likes