Nokia vs SkyDance/Paramount käsittely alkanut UKssa voi olla isoja rahoja tai pieniä puroja, vaikuttaa koko streaming palveluntarjoaja maailmaan (Netflix, disney, prime jne)
IAMista ei näe kuin otsikon alla AI pitkä jaarittelu
Nokia vs. Skydance: Global RAND rate trial – what you need to know
Yhteenveto
Trial underway – 20 November 2026 UK High Court
This is a significant patent-licensing case for the global video-streaming industry. It could establish a benchmark for how streaming companies pay technology patent owners for the use of video compression and encoding technology.
The central question is: how much should Paramount/Skydance and Warner Bros. Discovery pay Nokia for using its patented video-streaming technologies worldwide?
The trial began at the UK High Court on 18 November 2026 and is scheduled to run for approximately 20 days, until 11 December.
JUVE Patent
+1
1. Who is involved?
Nokia – Patent owner
Nokia developed and owns patents relating to video encoding, decoding and multimedia technologies. It wants streaming providers to pay royalties for using its patented inventions.
Paramount Skydance – Streaming provider
The company behind Paramount+, with the dispute concerning its use of Nokia’s video technology.
Warner Bros. Discovery – Streaming provider
The other major defendant, whose streaming operations include Max and other video services.
An important corporate development: Paramount has acquired Warner Bros. and renamed itself Paramount Skydance Corporation. However, the UK proceedings continue to refer to Paramount and Warner Bros. Discovery as separate parties, with separate legal teams.
JUVE Patent
+1
2. What exactly is Nokia claiming?
The dispute concerns Nokia’s Video Portfolio, including patents associated with:
- H.264 / AVC: A widely used video compression standard.
- H.265 / HEVC: A more advanced compression standard, enabling high-quality video with more efficient bandwidth usage.
- Other multimedia patents: Additional patents covering video-related technologies, including non-standard-essential patents.
These technologies are used to encode, decode, compress and deliver video content efficiently.
The important distinction is that Nokia is not simply claiming that Paramount or Warner Bros. has copied a piece of software. It is seeking royalties for the use of patented technologies incorporated into the video-streaming ecosystem.
Bailii
+2
3. What does RAND mean?
RAND stands for Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory.
It is closely related to the more commonly used FRAND terminology (Fair, Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory).
In practical terms:
- Patent owners must make licensing available on fair and reasonable terms where the relevant RAND commitment applies.
- Licensees must pay appropriate royalties for the use of covered patents.
- The royalty should reflect the value of the patented technology, rather than simply the commercial bargaining power of the patent owner.
- Comparable licensing agreements and market benchmarks can be important evidence.
The court is being asked to establish a global licence rather than resolve individual country-by-country royalty disputes.
4. The biggest issue: how much money is at stake?
This is where the case becomes particularly interesting.
The two sides have very different approaches to calculating the royalty.
Party
Position
Nokia
Relies on three comparable licensing agreements to support a substantially higher valuation.
Paramount and Warner Bros.
Rely primarily on video patent-pool benchmarks to support a much lower valuation.
According to the November 2026 reporting by JUVE Patent:
- The streaming companies’ approach indicates approximately $250,000–$300,000 for the final licence, before certain retrospective royalties and interest.
- Nokia’s comparable-agreement approach implies a figure approximately 1,000 times higher.
- Nokia’s overall claim is understood to be in the hundreds of millions of US dollars.
These are competing valuation positions, not a final royalty determination. The exact commercial terms of the comparable agreements are confidential.
JUVE Patent
+1
Why this difference matters
$250k–$300k
Approximate streaming companies’ proposed benchmark
~1,000×
Approximate difference between the competing valuation methodologies
The comparison is indicative, not a final court-approved rate.
5. What will the judge actually decide?
There are four particularly important questions.
A. What is a reasonable global royalty?
The judge must assess the competing licensing methodologies and determine the appropriate royalty for Nokia’s video portfolio.
B. Should royalties be calculated on indirect subscribers?
This is a particularly important issue.
Should Paramount and Warner Bros. pay royalties only for their direct subscribers, or should subscribers accessing content through third-party channel partners and distribution arrangements also count?
This could materially affect the royalty calculation.
C. Should Nokia receive retrospective royalties?
Nokia is also seeking payments relating to historical use of its technology.
The parties disagree about how far back royalties should apply, including potential claims reaching back to 2011.
D. How should the global licence be structured?
The court needs to establish licensing terms that work across different territories and streaming operations, rather than simply deciding a royalty for one country.
JUVE Patent
+1
6. What has happened before the trial?
An important development occurred in March–June 2026.
The parties agreed to a mechanism under which:
- Nokia would accept a single global RAND determination by the UK court.
- Parallel patent litigation would be withdrawn or discontinued.
- Paramount and Warner Bros. would make interim payments to Nokia.
- The court would determine the final global licence terms at trial.
In June 2026, the High Court ordered interim payments.
Importantly, the exact payment figures were redacted in the public judgment. The interim payments are not the final royalty rate, and the arrangement provides for adjustments and refunds if the final determination requires them.
Bailii
+2
7. Why should the wider industry care?
This case could have implications far beyond the two companies.
Industry participant
Potential implications
Netflix
Potential relevance to future video patent licensing negotiations
Disney+
Exposure to similar video codec licensing arguments
Amazon Prime Video
Potential implications for streaming distribution and licensing costs
Other streaming platforms
Greater clarity about how streaming patent royalties are calculated
Patent owners
Potentially important precedent for monetising video technology
Telecommunications industry
Further developments in global SEP licensing and RAND rate-setting
One particularly important aspect is that this is a major attempt to establish a global royalty for video technology used by streaming service providers, rather than the more familiar device manufacturers.
It could therefore influence negotiations between patent owners and content distributors worldwide. However, the judgment will not automatically impose a royalty on every streaming company.
JUVE Patent
+1
8. What should we watch between now and December?
-
18 November – 11 December 2026: Trial
Evidence, expert testimony and arguments on royalty valuation.
-
Patent-pool versus comparable-licence evidence
Which valuation methodology the judge finds persuasive.
-
Subscriber calculations
Whether indirect subscribers and channel-partner distribution are included.
-
Historical royalties
Whether royalties are payable for periods before Nokia approached the streaming companies.
-
Final judgment
The eventual global RAND royalty and licence structure. The precise judgment date has not yet been established in the sources reviewed.
9. My assessment: the five most important takeaways
1. This is a landmark licensing dispute. It could help establish how video-streaming companies compensate patent owners for codec and multimedia technology.
2. The valuation gap is enormous. The parties’ competing approaches differ by approximately three orders of magnitude.
3. The subscriber question is commercially significant. The treatment of indirect subscribers could materially change the royalty base.
4. Historical royalties could be substantial. The period for which royalties are payable may be as important as the future royalty rate.
5. The outcome could influence future negotiations across the streaming industry. Other major streaming platforms and patent owners will be watching closely.
10. Key documents and further reading
These are useful sources if you want to follow the legal and commercial developments:
- JUVE Patent – Showdown at the UK High Court, 18 November 2026 – Current trial coverage.
- UK High Court – Interim RAND payment judgment, June 2026 – Important judicial reasoning.
- WilmerHale – FRAND Quarterly, November 2026 – Analysis of the competing valuation methodologies.
- Nokia – Patent licensing progress in 2026 – Nokia’s own perspective.
One final point worth emphasising: The trial is not about whether streaming services can use H.264 or H.265. It is about the commercial price and licensing conditions for using Nokia’s patented technology.
The most consequential outcome may be the methodology the court adopts, because that could shape negotiations throughout the global video-streaming and patent-licensing markets.
