The larger the share of GDP, the more it stings when they collapse, as was close to happening in Britain. Finland’s share is 56% of GDP. We would be in a terrible mess if those funds collapsed.
I repeat myself, pension liabilities would not disappear even if there were no funds. The key risk in pension funding is demographics; pension funds are practically mandatory if the population’s age structure is aging.
Market disruptions are a temporary phenomenon; demographics are a more permanent kind.
And those funds won’t collapse; they are not highly leveraged hedge funds.
I repeat myself, if the funds disappear, we’re in trouble, precisely because of those pension liabilities. As you said, they must exist, but what happens if they no longer exist or their assets significantly decrease?
In Britain, it was a matter of hours until 90% of funds were forced to liquidate holdings. I don’t know how much would have been required or if it would have led to a collapse, but I wouldn’t rule out that option.
In Finland, we were in a similar mood in the spring of 2020 – albeit for different reasons – when the stock markets collapsed, and the government had to ensure through legislative changes that pension companies would not be forced to sell their holdings and fuel the price decline. Some cried that this was not how things should be, and that pension companies must sell to secure capital. Well, luckily, forced sales were not carried out, as pension companies would have incurred tens of billions in losses without gaining anything, as valuations rose again just as quickly after the trough.
However, these two cases offer a perspective on the vulnerability of current pension funds in the face of temporary market disruptions in today’s world. In practice, states/central banks are forced to come to the rescue of the market, if for no other reason, then for the sake of pension companies. No one seems to have a better model for managing pension funds. Would it then be that they were entirely digital cash in some bank? A bank can go bankrupt. As physical cash in a bank vault? A stack of banknotes can burn. As gold in Fort Knox? There is not enough gold, or even if there were, physical gold is a much more volatile product in value than diversified securities.
Who could invent a solution?
Well, I think it’s a bit unnecessary to worry about the size of the funds being large in relation to GDP, when one should be worried if it were small. Size matters ![]()
Of course, if the funds have built up absolutely insane hedging schemes whose collateral requirements skyrocket in market disruptions, then… But somehow I doubt it.
The bigger they are the harder they fall.
You should read Alfi’s thread to get up to speed on these very hedging schemes.
To me, the only logical solution is to learn to live with short-term uncertainty. Pension funds are a long, very long-term instrument; one should be able to afford patience with them. When even us ordinary mortals have an investment horizon of years and these small bumps smooth out, then theirs is generations long.
Next time, we’ll arrange for Torsti to be there! He’s popular on every floor, but always has time for new and old friends ![]()
Well, how you take it, earlier that “distress” was endured through gritted teeth, things were not necessarily talked about even within the family, and often the bottle was resorted to - slightly exaggerated but not too much. My opinion is that challenges have always existed, but today it is more socially acceptable to go to therapy, and the availability of treatment has also grown. A lot of progress has also been made in the treatment and identification of mental health disorders. A good point is also that society has developed much more individual-centric + history has passed this introverted attitude down through generations. In more community-centric cultures, the need for therapy is also less.
In the most intense emotional scales of the markets, where strong optimism and pessimism prevail, skepticism is needed.
As you stated, are things really as bad as they now seem? Ultimately, it’s about the numerous possible scenarios, but what weight do you give to each scenario? Which scenario do you give the highest probability of occurring? Winners are found among those who successfully contravene the general market view, even in this situation.
Currently, there are many threats simultaneously on the surface, and in that sense, strong bearishness is quite justified. However, not all threats will ultimately materialize. If one takes a strong view, for example, with a large cash position, there is always the risk of not getting back in on time. The strongest bears have to bear that risk, but fortunately, bears are strong animals.
As an edit, my message started to ramble a bit towards the markets, even though your message was more about general life, but my comment also fits the market situation.
Phew, so that rumors don’t get out of hand, let’s make it clear right away that when I read the book back then, I borrowed it from the library, so it’s NOT on the shelf, on the floor, or in a pile. ![]()
This is my most important message so far this year.
Addition: A book-quarter (kirja-Vartti) has been wished for a while, I guess I’ll have to arrange one sometime. ![]()
Kirja-Vartti (Book-Quarter) is a great idea. Looking forward to it…
Something that has been on my mind for a while now is whether there has ever been a discussion about creating a thread for investment-related literature? And not just a random list of all books, but a book and a justification for why said work helps an investor develop. There could also be fictional literature, but its value to an investor should be justifiable.
Compared to fundamental analysis, TA can easily appear more impressive, especially to novice investors, because you can draw an infinite number of lines: if one doesn’t work, draw 10 others. If a moving average doesn’t work, look at others, and so on.
If something is “always right,” it stinks.
Of course, investors and traders can use whatever tools they like; I don’t judge (except for staring at the P/E ratio without any other background information
).
I wonder if it’s true, as I recall some economic expert saying, that economic growth periodically requires a war or some other major crisis; at least the last couple of years have “nicely” stirred things up.
I have to interject that it’s easy to present impressive TA-based analysis, but truly well-founded and actionable analysis is difficult to both identify and create. It requires, among other things, a deep understanding of the underlying asset being traded, a deep understanding of one’s own indicators (including where they are not useful!), and on top of that, (genuinely) good justifications for why the analysis is valid.
No, it doesn’t. ![]()
Wars destroy a lot of wealth, etc.
It boosts GDP if you break your home windows with a hammer and then call a professional (if you pay under the table, it won’t show in the GDP…) to fix them.
But has wealth actually been created?
No.
Crises or periods of crisis are, however, a structural part of the economy. Usually, things are always taken to an extreme.
Except that the money spent on repairing the glass is gone from some other GDP-boosting activity…
That’s kind of the point I was making. ![]()
How to invest in stocks during a bear market? Kauppalehti’s Markkinaraati (Market Panel) shares its opinion. ![]()
Markkinaraati’s (Market Panel’s) instructions for buying stocks in a bear market:
- Rely on your own investment plan.
- Consider your investment horizon and any potential changes to it.
- Utilize dollar-cost averaging.
- Diversify investments with index-level products rather than individual stock picking.
- Favor high-quality and stable companies. Beware of falling knives.
- Geographically, the United States currently appears significantly less risky than Europe.
“If the investment period is long, then hold on to your hat and look ahead. There’s no need to fear buying too much.”