The chess world is experiencing its biggest scandal in decades. The Sinquefield Cup, the most lucrative tournament of the year, is currently being played in the United States. Ten of the strongest possible players are invited to play each other once over 1.5 weeks in games with long time controls. The prize pool is $350k. Most often, all players are in the worldâs top 15. This was supposed to be the case this year too. However, one top player had to cancel at the last minute due to coronavirus issues, so 19-year-old American player Hans Niemann, whose world ranking was about 50, was brought in on short notice. Just 1.5 years ago, it was around 700. Such a rise is not unheard of, but remarkably rare.
Niemann is a socially awkward guy, quite arrogant, and, in his own words, totally dedicated to chess. He was naturally considered the underdog of the tournament, whom everyone would try to beat. Among top players, about 2/3 of games end in a draw, so the margins are small.
Surprisingly, Niemann achieved a win and a draw in his first games. In the third game, he had the black pieces against world champion Magnus Carlsen. Carlsen is widely considered the greatest player of all time, roughly on par with Garry Kasparov. A typical scenario for Carlsen is to play, say, 80 long time control games a year and lose only 1-2 of them. A typical loss scenario is when Carlsen has black against another top player who executes everything perfectly from the opening preparations. Before the Niemann game, Carlsen had a 53-game unbeaten streak, most games against other top players. At his best, he played over a hundred games in a row without losing once.
In the game, Carlsen played a rather rare variation in the opening, aiming to take Niemann out of his theoretical preparation. However, Niemann played the most precise moves and gained a slight advantage after the opening phase, even though the player with black pieces is usually at a slight disadvantage when moving into the middlegame, as white always starts in chess. Carlsen played somewhat toothlessly, and Niemann slowly increased his advantage, eventually winning elegantly in the endgame. Carlsen stormed out, and Niemann stayed to give a passionately long and quite arrogant interview and game analysis, where he stated that he had been incredibly lucky to have looked at precisely this very rare sub-variation of the Nimzo-Indian Defense that morning before the game.
The next day, just as the round was about to begin, a bomb dropped: Carlsen wrote on Twitter that he was withdrawing from the tournament. He linked a clip from a Jose Mourinho interview in which Mourinho says after a game that he cannot speak now because he would otherwise be in âbig trouble.â It is almost unheard of for a top player to withdraw from a tournament for reasons other than health. It was Carlsenâs first time; Kasparov never withdrew during his long career.
At the same time, everyone saw that the anti-cheating measures in the tournament had become stricter than usual. In chess, cheating practically means that a player can access computer analyses during the game. As late as the 90s, Kasparov competed evenly against the worldâs best computer, but since then, machines have developed overwhelmingly. Now, anyone can download a chess program for free from Google or Appleâs app store that would crush Carlsen. Machines with powerful engines would beat Carlsen a hundred out of a hundred times. In recent years, neural networks have made chess engines not only powerful but also monsters that play very beautiful chess.
When players enter the hall at a professional tournament, they are scanned from head to toe with a device that detects electronic devices. The environment where players can move during games is completely sanitized. Cheating in such a live tournament has not been considered possible. Online, the problem is of a different magnitude.
With Carlsen not showing up, hinting that he didnât dare speak for fear of a lawsuit, and security arrangements simultaneously tightening, the conclusion seemed rather clear: Carlsen believes Niemann has found some way to cheat in this tournament. It was quickly unearthed that Niemann had previously been caught cheating in online chess. The worldâs biggest chess streamer, American Hikaru Nakamura, commented that Niemannâs post-game analyses showed a weaker understanding than the moves played in the actual games. Neither Nakamura nor anyone else had any evidence or even a theory as to how Niemann could have cheated.
The next day, Niemann gave a very emotional interview in which he stated that he had lived his dream as a world champion slayer for one day until he was crucified without any evidence. He admitted to cheating twice in online chess during his career, expressing deep regret and having learned from his mistakes. He vehemently denied ever cheating in over-the-board chess during his career. He also revealed that chess.com, the worldâs largest chess website, has now completely banned him due to this controversy, based solely on speculation.
Niemannâs powerfully strong defense speech instantly turned chess social media to his side. Chess.com, Nakamura, and Carlsenâwho remained silentâbegan to receive backlash. Any news or tweet from chess.com was filled with #freehans hashtags and sarcastic comments. This continued for about 24 hours, after which the site had enough and published an exceptional Tweet stating that, according to its investigations, Niemannâs cheating on the site had been much more extensive than Niemann implied in the interview, and that the site had requested clarification from Niemann. This shifted the wind somewhat on social media.
Then, on the channel of another big Twitch streamer, Grandmaster Eric Hansen, a fan asked Hansen how one could cheat in live chess. Hansen said he had no idea how it could succeed in such a top tournament. The fan asked, probably jokingly, if a computer could be hidden in the rectum. Hansen quipped that, indeed, a small ball placed in the rectum might bypass security arrangements, and it might still have a sensor that could indicate chess moves by vibrating. Any information can be transmitted with ones and zeros, Morse code, and who knows what else, naturally including chess moves. The vibrations would be based on communication from an assistant following the game with a computer via the internet.
This went viral, and currently, five days after Carlsenâs withdrawal, Elon Musk is debating on Twitter whether Niemann cheated with âanal beadsâ (anuskuulat). Carlsen is still silent, and therefore, it is still not known for certain why he even withdrew.