USA thread (former name USA Presidential Elections 2024)

Some thoughts on the preliminary setup for the next US presidential election, about 2.5 years before the vote. All estimates are my own gut feelings. I have followed US politics keenly since 2000, but I don’t have any formal education in the field nor am I a recognized expert, so my speculations should be taken with a grain of salt. I try to check the facts, but mistakes can always happen, please do correct me if you find any.

Betting Markets

Let’s start with the perspective of the betting market, which often gives a good indication of probabilities in politics. Betfair is a betting exchange where the main market of the previous election (who gets more electoral votes in the election) overwhelmingly rose to become the highest-volume market in the company’s history, with a turnover of two billion. The day before the election, the consensus of Betfair and the betting world in general was that Biden had about a 60% chance of winning. At the same time, the planet’s toughest politics-focused data analysis (https://fivethirtyeight.com/) gave Biden a 90% chance. They included all possible polls state by state, weighted by reliability, and made necessary adjustments based on past election experiences (e.g., Trump supporters answer phone calls less often than the general population), simulating the election tens of thousands of times. There are always many variables in an election; what the weather is like in various parts of the critical states, where there is a flu outbreak, and so on. A sufficient number of simulations blends the noise into an expected value, which on their track record is, in my opinion, the best estimate of the candidates’ chances.

Now, how on earth is it possible that in a billion-dollar market, the odds differed so drastically from high-level data analysis? In my view, it was about the cult created by Trump over the previous five years, almost unique in the US, where tens of millions of core supporters saw him as a messianic figure who simply cannot lose. He is a leader chosen and blessed by God to make America great again. In election betting, such people had an endless amount of money in their pockets to keep Trump grossly overrated as a candidate right up until election eve. After election day, the phenomenon took on even more absurd proportions. Four days after the election, all media outlets, up to and including Fox, declared Biden the winner of the election. In some states, the vote counting was still ongoing, but objectively, Biden was by then at least a 99.9% sure winner. However, Betfair’s main market was still open, and tens of millions in cash poured in daily. At that point, a large mass of Trump supporters desperately wanted to bet on Trump at odds of 12. Day by day, Biden’s victory became more and more certain, but even a month after the election, the market was open and stubborn Trump money was pouring down the drain. The market didn’t even have a backdoor for Trump somehow seizing power, but rather it was about the electors who then officially voted Biden in as president in mid-December.

Based on this, betting odds should be approached with a bit of skepticism; the Trump cult lives on, and one might ask, what kind of people leave their money rotting in a betting market for 2.5 years when during that time they could be getting actual interest from, say, two-year government bonds, not to mention all the possibilities in other asset classes? Perhaps those who don’t think, but just bet on the candidate they fanboy over?

Odds now:

And here is Paf, which shares the same odds with several larger companies (which naturally adjust odds based on how the market is played):

Considering Trump’s chronic overvaluation, the top favorite right now might well be Florida Governor DeSantis. Trump is a close second ahead of Biden. If Sleepy Joe drops out of the race, Vice President Harris and California Governor Newsom are considered fairly neck-and-neck as the top Democratic candidates.

Stable Genius

When Donald Trump announced in June 2015 — exceptionally late by the standards of traditional, viable candidates — that he was running, he immediately shot to the clear lead in the polls for the Republican nomination. In the eyes of Republican supporters, he was the king of the American real estate world and the tough, presidential boss from The Apprentice who thinks for a moment, calls a team together, and makes a shrewd business decision.

Every self-respecting political analyst dismissed him as a joke candidate who would have zero chance at the nomination. The Republican elite and Fox News were openly hostile toward him. When he was pressed in the first primary debate in August '15 on whether he would support the Republican nominee if he wasn’t chosen himself, he refused to say, and was heavily booed by the Republican audience. There was a lot of booing in the fall of '15. Time and time again, Trump said something incomprehensibly outrageous, talking heads declared that this would surely be the death knell for his campaign, but his poll lead never wavered. Even under the shadow of the July '16 convention, there was a lot of tug-of-war within the party, and some party cliques wanted to change candidates a month before the election when the Washington Post published a tape where Trump talked about routinely groping women.Surprisingly, Trump won, and the party finally began to unite behind him. Fox News quickly embraced him. As president, he was at the center of endless turbulence, but the stock market rose, the economy was doing well, and he was fortunate enough to appoint two Supreme Court justices (and even a third right on the eve of the 2020 election). Within the party, all dissenting voices were silenced either voluntarily or at least through heavy harassment, and Trump finally reached his climax on February 4, 2020, when he delivered the annual State of the Union address. He had become synonymous with the Republican Party, and support was nearly unanimous and intensely passionate. All the scandals and the impeachment had been overcome, the economy was in stellar shape, and Trump was undoubtedly the heavy favorite on his way to a second term. Both Congress and the Senate were listening to the State of the Union, and the atmosphere at the time, created by the Republicans, was reminiscent of a revival meeting. It was a very prestigious event, but the Republicans broke out into a standing ovation shouting, ”Four more years!” Then came COVID-19, a problem whose management did not suit Trump’s strengths and which cost him his reelection.

Trump’s actions are driven by a small set of lessons burned into his spinal cord in his youth:

  • Speak with a simple, child-like vocabulary and use simple grammar. This is typical of populism and comes naturally to Trump. Although Finland has a high-quality basic education system, there are plenty of people here too who find it difficult to follow the speeches of politicians and A-studio experts. In the USA, the problem is much worse. It is hard to admit to oneself that one’s level of education is not enough to understand a normal politician, and the result is distress and anger. Everyone understands Trump’s speech.
  • Be almost limitlessly optimistic and trust your instincts. In the autumn of 2016, Clinton suspended her campaign for days to prepare with her team and sparring partners for the first debate, which in election years is the second most-watched TV program after the Super Bowl. Trump continued campaigning, mocking Clinton’s break, and did not prepare in any way. In some perverse way, I have to admire the fact that someone can walk completely out of the blue into a situation where the pressure is higher than on perhaps any other arena.
  • If someone attacks, do not defend yourself passively; strike back with full force. It’s hard to pick single examples of this because Trump does this all the time; it’s like breathing.
  • If you are in a long-term conflict, once it is resolved, declare yourself the winner no matter what the outcome. Trump has won all the lawsuits he has lost, all his bankruptcies were successes, he won the Republican primaries he lost, he got more legal votes in the 2016 election than Clinton, and ultimately, frankly, he won the 2020 presidential election. He is a winner; that is the core part of his brand. He always wins, he is the best at everything.

Finally, Trump is distinguished from others by one more hard-to-define X-factor. Why do people play slot machines and get a small rush of pleasure when they notice a message or notification on a social media channel, something unexpected? People are addicted to random rewards. Every time Trump starts talking, people get that dopamine spike because Trump can say anything. Something that immediately ends up in the news. He is completely unpredictable and irresistibly entertaining, which makes him magnetic. In the autumn of '16, a commentator pointed out that Clinton is leading in the polls, but 90% of the media attention is on Trump all the time. Throughout his term, Trump dominated the media airspace in an unprecedented way. He was divisively controversial, but undeniably the world’s most charismatic political superstar, something possible only in America.

After Biden took office, the media storm around Trump has quieted down. He is away from mainstream social media, bored according to leaks at Mar-a-Lago. Democrats are looking for a smoking gun regarding his actions on January 6th, but will hardly be able to physically prevent him from running for the presidency. All insider comments point to him entering the race. According to some sources, he would have liked to announce his candidacy already this summer, but aides are trying to prevent it at least until the midterms.

Florida’s Ideal Son-in-Law

Annoyingly, Donald Trump is not necessarily his place of residence’s most popular politician. Ron DeSantis is the 43-year-old first-term governor of Florida. He graduated as a lawyer from Yale and Harvard, enlisted in the army, served as a Navy lieutenant in Iraq in 2007, and entered Congress in 2012. There he quickly found like-minded individuals in the party’s right-wing Tea Party movement, and in early 2015 he co-founded the “Freedom Caucus,” a club of Republican members of Congress aimed at pulling the party further right. In late 2018, with Trump’s strong support, he ran for Governor of Florida. In his campaign ads, DeSantis was seen teaching his small child, dressed in a MAGA shirt, how to build a wall. In an interview, he was asked if there was any issue on which he disagreed with Trump. There was none. He won against his opponent after a recount by a 0.4% margin. Commentators saw this as fresh evidence of Trump’s growing kingmaker status in important swing states. DeSantis rose to the governorship distinctly as Trump’s protégé, an apprentice.As governor, DeSantis has naturally sought to pursue conservative politics. He favors tax cuts, welfare cuts, and the right to bear arms (he holds the best possible A+ rating from the National Rifle Association). He opposes abortion, the rights of sexual minorities, and COVID-19 restrictions. Specifically, his coronavirus battles with Biden last year catapulted him to become the country’s most prominent young Republican politician. He represents everything that the Republican elite, which has drifted far to the right over the course of the 2000s, could hope for: all the right stances, a stellar background, a presentable, glossy-magazine family, and a strong opposition to the evil federal government’s intentions to interfere in citizens’ affairs and their pursuit of freedom, even amidst a pandemic. He seems like a nearly complete package. Even for swing voters, he has something to latch onto; on environmental issues, his youth shows in the fact that he is not a pitch-black Republican. But does he dare challenge The Donald, and if he does, does he have a chance?

Let’s get this fucking party started

Just last autumn, DeSantis brushed off inquiries about a presidential run as nonsense, emphasizing that he was only focusing on his re-election in Florida. Since then, he has broken fundraising records for the gubernatorial race, which will take place this coming autumn. Money is pouring in so heavily that even though he is aiming for a landslide victory with an expensive campaign, he will hardly use much over half of all the funds raised. The money comes from both high-profile Republican donors and the grassroots level. In principle, funds raised for a state campaign should not be used at the federal level, but there are loopholes and recent precedents for this. DeSantis has not asked Trump for any endorsement for his re-election and no longer answers any questions about the presidency.

In the polls, DeSantis is still very far behind Trump. When Republicans are asked which of the two they would rather see as the party’s nominee, a typical result is Trump 50%, DeSantis 25%, don’t know, or similar 25%. The gap seems huge, but it’s worth remembering that Trump was president until recently, whereas DeSantis is his 43-year-old protégé, a first-term governor. In January 2024, he will be a 45-year-old second-term governor, while Trump will have aged to 77 by then. Even more significantly, Trump and DeSantis have, of course, never been seen on the same debate stage. Their currently completely different-tier profiles would level out the moment this happens for the first time, likely in August next year. DeSantis’s trend is already rising.

The most dangerous thing from Trump’s perspective is that his supporters genuinely like DeSantis. I haven’t seen much of a cross word about DeSantis on Trump-Twitter; instead, the mantra is the Trump-DeSantis 2024-2028 ticket, and DeSantis 2028-2036. Only in this way can the country’s affairs be cemented in order so that the Dems don’t ruin the legacy anytime soon.

As DeSantis has even appeared in presidential polls and started gaining some traction in them, Trump’s attitude towards his former protégé has turned chillier. According to Trump, DeSantis would be nothing without him. An impatient Trump can barely stand the war of attrition anymore and wants to seize the initiative by declaring his candidacy first.

I bet that when Trump announces his candidacy, likely right in Florida, he will frame the setup as if he were the incumbent president of the party seeking a re-election. At that point, the unwritten rule is that a president is not challenged. Trump will immediately demand the entire party fall in line behind him; you are either loyal or a traitor. There is no need for any kind of primary campaign; the candidate will be nailed down right now.

When can an announcement be expected? Perhaps the most likely and, according to Trump’s aides, safest option would be to wait at least past the midterms until December-January. If DeSantis continues to rise in the polls and talk about his candidacy grows, Trump might not be able to wait, rudely declaring his candidacy right in the middle of the midterm campaign, aiming to take over Florida’s airspace and branding both DeSantis’s and the party’s victory as his own doing.

It would, of course, be very dramatic to hear DeSantis’s statement on Trump’s candidacy. If Trump were to announce it in the middle of the midterm campaign, it would be fairly easy for DeSantis to state that he is now fully focused on his re-election. If Donald manages to wait until January, DeSantis will be forced to comment on the matter. The first, anticlimactic option is that he surprisingly comes out in direct support of Trump. They have some kind of deal whose secret addendum includes a guaranteed vice-presidential spot or something nice. This is possible, but I don’t consider it likely. If you want to reach the top in politics, especially in the US, you have to be at least to some extent narcissistic, even a psychopathic killer personality. A political animal that lives off power. An animal that sniffs the momentum vibrating in the air, and if it’s so thick you could cut it with a knife, you have to strike. A second chance might not come. DeSantis is on a major upward trajectory this round. As a hyper-intelligent man, he understands that Trump would likely ruin the movement during a second term, and DeSantis, especially as vice president, would go down with the ship.

So I believe DeSantis will enter the race, but he doesn’t want to announce it as early as Trump. It remains to be seen with what phrasing he will try to keep his candle under a bushel for a few more months, or if the statement will already contain a strong hint. Then if/when he officially enters the race, say next April, the campaign message, based on my guesswork, could be built on looking to the future. Biden has ruined the country in many ways; now it is time to roll up our sleeves and start fixing the damage with fresh, energetic hands and make America the country that the Founding Fathers envisioned once again. Between the lines, the message would be that no one wants to hear the old man’s Tourette-like mantra about stolen elections anymore. DeSantis won’t want to start criticizing Trump directly at the beginning; that would be too dangerous.Trump usually doesn’t have any particular strategy; he reacts to stimuli with his aforementioned toolkit. DeSantis’s candidacy in itself would be a severe blow to his prestige, an attack on his authority. Will the mudslinging start immediately despite the objections of his aides, and if so, how will Trump’s supporters react? Will they obediently turn against DeSantis at the Leader’s command, or will the base of the cult slowly start to crumble? Much like the coronavirus pandemic in February-March 2020, the question of the right approach against the dangerous DeSantis is a very complex problem that one should calmly analyze from various angles, have an open discussion, listen to, and trust the experts (in this case, the least dull pencil in the box of Trump’s political advisors who are still on board). This is hardly going to happen. Will the alpha gorilla leading the pack establish a working group if a young male bites it on the testicles while it’s sleeping?

If DeSantis starts getting the upper hand in early 2024, it will be interesting to see if Trump tries to destroy the entire party to the extent that he can. Are all internal Republican processes corrupted, is there a RINOs’ conspiracy against Trump? Terribly difficult to assess. In any case, an unprecedented circus is likely in store if both run. Right now it’s hard to see anyone else driving a wedge into the race, but of course big surprises have been seen before. In the summer of 2006, hardly anyone could foresee that a local politician from Chicago, Barack Obama running for the Senate for the first time—albeit having risen to national prominence with his speech at the Democratic National Convention two years earlier—would even be in the race, let alone win. In the summer of 2014, no one even thought of Trump as a joke candidate; he had flirted with it so often that he was already the boy who cried wolf. And in the summer of 2018, of course, no one knew that a pandemic would upend the landscape. Precisely for this reason, it came to mind to write such preliminary, likely comically proven wrong musings this early. In the fall of 2024, this will be a faint voice from the distant past, from a time when it wasn’t known at all what surprising twists awaited.

There was supposed to be some rambling about the Democrats’ setup here as well, but let’s leave that for some other time.

220 Likes

Thanks for the interesting background. I usually only wake up to the US presidential elections on the eve of the elections themselves. Then a lot of what has already happened goes unseen. I look forward to the next part of your article.

13 Likes

An incredibly good piece of writing. The fact that you even started with betting odds only improved its impact; I was already sold at “Stable genius.” Following this guy to make sure I don’t miss a Democratic-themed post.

6 Likes

Thanks to both of you, glad to hear you found it interesting.

Nothing is likely to happen in the Democratic race until Biden announces his intentions sometime next spring. Of course, it’s interesting to consider what his decision will be; most likely, he won’t run, and the race will start from there.

Regarding the Republican race, I came across this new sign of cooling relations between Fox (or rather, Murdoch) and Trump:

Laura Ingraham, alongside Tucker Carlson, is one of Fox News’s most prominent and sharp-tongued commentators, who, of course, was 100% behind Trump throughout his term. I’ve rarely seen her as cordial as when she welcomed DeSantis at the exact moment Trump’s rally had begun, at the 1:10 mark in that clip.

Another Murdoch-owned conservative media outlet, the New York Post, mercilessly slammed Trump a few days ago:

15 Likes

Great opening, @Kale-possu!

I’m a complete amateur when it comes to analyzing the US presidential race, but I just saw this:

https://twitter.com/MikaHentunen/status/1554163565334069250?s=20&t=fSjcPgxlYZJ8UQ16s_vpjQ

Is Trump losing face time to rivals even before officially announcing his candidacy?

16 Likes

Absolutely fantastic opening post!

On Unibet, the Republican candidate odds are now 2.00 for Trump and 2.75 for DeSantis.

4 Likes

I agree with others, that opening post was enjoyable to read, even though it’s not traditionally a topic that interests me. Now it has piqued my interest!

5 Likes

Democrats’ Early Prospects, Part 1/3: Historical Ramblings

The greatest achievement for a politically ambitious person born in the United States is, of course, the presidency. The office is most often sought to be held for as long as possible; usually, only the two-term rule, an electoral defeat, or an assassination has ended the job. Voluntary relinquishment has been rare and has generally been considered a sign of weakness.

Joe Biden will likely announce next spring that he will not seek a second term. The decision will be difficult for the tough-minded, Irish-American street fighter. Before Biden, the United States has had 45 presidents. How many of them have voluntarily stepped down from office?

The most recent “voluntary” renunciant is Richard Nixon, who resigned from office in the middle of his second term in 1974 due to the Watergate scandal. However, the voluntariness here is purely theoretical, as he resigned only after his own Republican party turned against him, thus facing certain impeachment in the Senate later on.

Before moving on to the actual renunciants, it should be noted that it wasn’t until the turn of the 1950s that the Constitution stipulated that a president can serve only two full terms. If he has come to the office from the vice presidency with less than two years remaining in the truncated term, he has the right to seek two more full terms thereafter.

However, the two-term principle has been a de facto rule from the beginning, based on the rumblings of the founding fathers. Both George Washington and Thomas Jefferson refrained from seeking a third term and emphasized that none of their successors should either. This was followed until World War II.

The most recent genuinely voluntary relinquishment is Lyndon B. Johnson’s decision not to run in the 1968 election. Johnson came to office from the vice presidency in November 1963, replacing the assassinated Kennedy, with one year and two months remaining in the term. He won in 1964 but, due to declining health, the botched Vietnam War, and dwindling support, he stepped down in '68.

Calvin Coolidge came to office from the vice presidency in 1923, replacing the suddenly deceased Warren G. Harding. He won in 1924 but chose not to seek re-election in the 1928 elections. He stated: “No one has been president for ten years, that’s a long time – too long!” (Only slightly later, FDR, under exceptional circumstances, served an unprecedented 12 years as president from 1933-1945, the only time someone broke the Washington-Jefferson line before the constitutional amendment. Roosevelt has not been criticized much for this; instead, he is considered one of the top 3 presidents in history, alongside Lincoln and Washington.)

Chester A. Arthur stepped in from the vice presidency in 1881, replacing the assassinated James A. Garfield, and due to declining health, did not seek re-election in 1884, especially as he would have had to face a Republican primary. However, the relinquishment also embarrassed Arthur, and so the poor devil somehow formally participated in the primary, but without campaigning at all.

Rutherford Birchard Hayes was elected president in 1877 and decided early on that one term was enough, and then it was time to retire home to Ohio. This is the most recent case exactly analogous to Biden’s potential situation.

James Buchanan served as president from 1857-1861 and did not seek re-election. His poor leadership embroiled the United States in the Civil War, and he has been considered the worst president in the country’s history, at least until very recently. He himself stated after his term: “History will vindicate my memory.”

Kids these days don’t remember that James Knox Polk, according to his original plan, served only one term from 1845-1849, won the Mexican-American War, and retired to Tennessee, where he died only a few months after his term ended.

Six genuine relinquishments (assuming I haven’t missed any cases), of which the withdrawals of Johnson and Coolidge in the 20th century, having served more than a full term, can be considered respectable, and the other four are ancient history from times when presidents often had to fight in primaries, something not seen in the 20th century. In all other cases, a first-term president has sought re-election, and in the 20th century, roughly 2/3 of those cases succeeded.

In summary, from history, it can be stated that if the United States currently had a first-term president elected within the normal age range of 45-70 years, we would not need to speculate about the Democratic primaries. It would be almost self-evident that next spring the president would launch their campaign, and no one would challenge them in the primaries. In betting, his odds for a second term would now be in the range of 1.4-1.7. A good rule of thumb is that if the economy is in relatively good shape in an election year, the public grants the president a second term.

The next part will review Biden’s term, approval ratings, health to the extent known, and current probabilities for the midterm elections. If Biden has not yet made up his mind, the midterm results may influence it. If Democrats lose both chambers and Biden announces his relinquishment, he would indeed be one of history’s lamest ducks for the next nearly two years, a miserable end to a splendid career. Furthermore, the Democratic primary campaign would be fought under peculiar stars.

54 Likes

Democrats’ Outlook, Part 2/3: Biden

The length of Joe Biden’s career in federal politics is virtually unmatched in the nation’s history. He was elected to the Senate in the fall of 1972 at just 29 years old, one of the youngest ever. He served as a senator continuously for 36 years until rising to become vice president for two terms following Obama’s victory. Down-to-earth and with Irish roots, Biden entered the Senate of relatively modest means and remained among the Senate’s “poorest” throughout his long career, consistently commuting over an hour by train. It was not until the Trump era that he began earning millions through speaking fees and book sales.

Biden’s senatorial career began under the shadow of a terrible tragedy when his wife and toddler daughter died in a car accident. He was ready to resign from the Senate immediately, but the Democratic whip at the time persuaded him to stay. During his first six-year term, Biden met and married his current wife, who Biden says restored his genuine interest in politics.

During his early Senate terms, Biden made a name for himself in several high-profile cases, grew into an accomplished speaker after largely overcoming a childhood stutter, appealed to people with his unpretentious style, and by the summer of 1987 emerged as a pragmatic centrist and the Democratic frontrunner for the upcoming primaries heading into the next year’s presidential election. That same fall, Biden was caught plagiarizing parts of his speeches from another politician of working-class background, emotionally emphasizing in those passages that he was the first in his family to make it to college. The media was somewhat starved for juicy campaign stories at the time, so they began digging more aggressively and uncovering various missteps by Biden: he had repeatedly exaggerated his academic record, plagiarized a Robert Kennedy speech and even a small section of JFK’s inaugural address, and, more seriously, had been guilty of plagiarism on a law school essay. The negative snowball started rolling, and eventually Biden withdrew his candidacy after having raised the largest campaign war chest among the Democratic contenders up to that point.

Beyond chronic minor infractions, Biden’s habit of improvising with mixed success while delivering scripted speeches has been considered a weakness. He has even called himself a “gaffe machine,” and the situation has certainly not improved with age.

After the 1987 humiliation, Biden weighed his chances in nearly every cycle, but did not run again until 2007. That time around, Biden never really got off the ground as Clinton and Obama ran away with the race in one of the most epic primary battles ever. Ultimately, the young Obama, who leaned toward the left wing of the Democrats at the time, offered the vice presidency to his near polar opposite. Obama took the spotlight as president with his charismatic brilliance, but Biden was a very active and remarkably strong vice president; particularly in the Senate, he gladly leveraged his experience and frequently wrestled with Republicans. A deep friendship blossomed between the two men over eight years, and as his final act as president, assuming it would mark the end of Biden’s career, Obama surprised him with the exceptionally rare, highest of honors: the Presidential Medal of Freedom with distinction.

Critics, including Vladimir Putin, saw things like this:

As a Candidate

Having had to bury a second child, Biden did not run in the 2016 primaries straight from the vice presidency, but announced in April 2019 that he would seek the nomination in the 2020 election. Even though the betting markets at the time had Biden as just one of a fairly evenly matched top four alongside Sanders, Warren, and Harris, Trump feared Biden—who was more conservative than his Dem rivals—the most right from the start. Trump’s anxiety went so far that in late summer 2019 he took it upon himself to pressure Zelenskyy to dig up dirt on Biden and his son Hunter, leading to Donald’s first impeachment.

Biden found himself in hot water at times during the fall 2019 primary debates, with his advanced age already showing clearly, and took a beating in the early states in January 2020. However, after pouring massive effort into appealing to Black voters, he scored a landslide victory in South Carolina and never let go of the momentum again. On Super Tuesday in early March, Biden knocked out his final challenger, Sanders, and as Trump stumbled through the pandemic, Biden’s numbers began rising in general election polls. For the critically important first fall debate, Trump chose the tactic of constantly interrupting Biden, aiming to throw the old man off his game and make him lose his temper. Biden was certainly annoyed, but he kept his composure and stayed sharp throughout the grueling ordeal, even getting Chris Wallace—Fox News’s only superstar journalist leaning liberal—to scold Trump along with him. That debate, which Biden surprisingly won, may have even decided the election.

The Beginning of the Presidency

Biden’s start as president was rocky, as Trump’s administration unprecedentedly offered virtually zero cooperation to ensure a smooth transition of power. However, Trump managed to botch the Senate for Democrats in the Georgia runoffs, which were originally seen as an almost 90% lock for a Republican majority. Trump forced both Republican candidates to back his Big Lie, alienating just enough swing voters that the Democrats swept both seats and secured a de facto majority with the Vice President breaking ties in a 50-50 Senate. This handed Biden majorities in both chambers, giving him a solid runway to push through his agenda for the first two years.

After promptly removing Trump’s red Diet Coke button from the 1,300-pound Resolute desk as his first order of business, Biden rolled up his sleeves and pushed through a $1.9 trillion COVID relief package into an economy where inflation was already smoldering under the hood. The package gave Biden strong approval ratings and public praise in his early months. The first major blow to Biden came with the chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan, and gradually accelerating inflation began eroding his approval numbers.

The Midterms

Biden turns 80 in November. His gait is stiff, his speech slurs more easily than before, reading the teleprompter goes with mixed success, he stumbles, and he lets gaffes slip. It sounds like far-right propaganda, but that is simply what it looks like. Already 75% of Democratic voters want someone else as the party’s next nominee. They are tired of watching Biden’s public appearances with their hearts in their throats, especially if those involve unscripted remarks—a scenario the White House goes to disturbing lengths to avoid.

Biden dreamed of the presidency for decades, and having finally reached the Oval Office in his twilight years, he has genuinely relished the role and kept all the reins firmly in hand, leaving Vice President Harris with a diminished profile. November will determine whether Biden can get anything done in the second half of his first term. Here is how the outlook currently stands in FiveThirtyEight’s simulations (a 50-50 Senate counts as a Democratic win here):

So, the House looks set to be lost, but Democrats are looking surprisingly strong in the Senate race—at least for now—partly due to poor Republican candidate selection in several states and the ultra-conservative judiciary’s “Operation Roe” they cultivated over recent years, which has provoked massive pushback among the middle-of-the-road public. The data clearly shows how Republican support dropped following the Supreme Court’s abortion ruling. Whether the issue remains top-of-mind for voters in November or whether the economy and inflation dominate the campaign season remains to be seen. The betting market diverges bafflingly sharply from FiveThirtyEight regarding the Senate, specifically concerning a true Democratic majority (at least 51 seats) (Unibet shown here as an example):

The balance is unlikely to shift that dramatically in three months, meaning the betting market must be assessing the current situation very differently from FiveThirtyEight. Just over two years ago, I thought political betting markets were an authority that everyone should, if not worship, at least hold in healthy respect, but the last presidential election certainly shattered that view when it comes to the US. I place far more trust in FiveThirtyEight, though it should be emphasized that it estimates what would happen if the election were held right now, whereas the betting market tries to anticipate how people will actually vote in November.

The Agony of Stepping Aside

The likely loss of the House alone will handicap the second half of Biden’s term, and losing the Senate would make passing any legislation an excruciating uphill battle. Immediately after the midterms, people will start pressing Biden on his future plans. By January, the rumor mill will be running hot, and by March, rampant speculation will drown out everything else if he has not made an announcement by then. Why so early, when the election is not until November 2024?! — Well, typically ahead of competitive primaries, as seen with Democrats last cycle, all serious contenders declare their candidacies in the spring of the pre-election year or even right at the start of it. Hillary Clinton launched her campaign for the 2008 race in January 2007, and for 2016 in April 2015. Obama jumped into the '08 race in February 2007, Sanders joined the 2016 race in April 2015 and the 2020 race in February 2019. Furthermore, current Vice President Harris launched her 2020 campaign in January 2019, raking in record-breaking grassroots donations in her first 24 hours.

Campaign fundraising must ramp up aggressively right after an announcement, the first primary debates can take place as early as mid-summer of the off-year, and by late summer the campaigns are firing on all cylinders with money burning at an insane rate. Several Democratic politicians are already quietly mapping out their moves, and impatience will begin bubbling to the surface right after New Year’s. By March, someone like Buttigieg might jump the gun even if Biden stays silent, which would be remarkably awkward.

Hayes, Buchanan, and Polk—those are the presidents prior to Biden who were newly elected and chose not to seek a second term. Men from an era of Santa Claus beards and mullets. Biden is a fighter who wants to pad his legacy even a notch further than reality warrants. The last thing he wants to do is concede that he is not up for another term. The public would immediately question whether admitting that means he is even fit to finish out his current term. Second-term presidents have traditionally been branded “lame ducks” in their latter halves, particularly since they usually no longer control Congress, or at least not both chambers. Attention has already started shifting toward the next presidential cycle, but a second term still commands a baseline level of respect for the old commander-in-chief.

At the very latest, his wife Jill will talk sense into the seasoned warrior, and Biden will do what is necessary for the party: announce well in advance, around February or March, that he will not seek reelection. After a few weeks of “careful deliberation,” Vice President Kamala Harris will launch her campaign, and Biden will endorse her—unless Harris views that more as a liability. Other contenders will emerge, and the field could end up wide open. There would be a real opening for a new, young Obama or Bill Clinton to come out of nowhere.

Posterity will look back on Biden quite favorably. With the last of his strength, he rid the country of Trump and restored America’s international standing. For that, along with a genuine empathy and approachability forged through personal tragedy, he truly earns his campaign team’s moniker: the Healer-in-Chief.

96 Likes

Is there any evidence for this? You describe well in the text the reasons why the implied probabilities of betting markets were not reliable in 2020, but doesn’t the exact same phenomenon always apply, e.g., in sports odds? Finns bet on Finland in ice hockey, and the house adjusts the odds to remain neutral. I don’t believe that 2020 actually differed that much from a normal election in terms of betting (aside from that irrational betting when the result was already clear). I don’t think enough data can even be collected from that to even be able to say that betting markets have accurately depicted the outcome.

1 Like

Yes, the betting markets have traditionally been correct. The 2020 election was partly an exception, as there was relatively more fun money (bets for Trump), while the so-called smart money was definitely in Biden’s camp.

2 Likes

Based on what? If we look back at even one election, 2016, the betting markets were “wrong” then too. Moreover, being wrong is a somewhat misleading concept when a variable in the [0,1] interval is forced into a binary outcome. A good example is the 538 forecast in 2016. They gave Trump a 30% chance on election day. Were they wrong? Many say so, but 30% is a quite high probability. More than two heads in a row. Overall, assessing correctness is difficult, especially in an election like this where one position is voted on once every 4 years. It would probably be a different matter in, for example, parliamentary elections where there are 200 seats to be distributed, but in those markets, the liquidity for a single seat bet would likely be so small that no effective pricing would probably occur.

Well… this is just my pet peeve that an indicator should be able to be examined with statistical tests before it can be taken seriously, but in betting, one can also take a de Finetti-like attitude to probability, which in itself is perfectly valid :slight_smile:

My thesis, paradoxically, and a little provocatively, but nonetheless genuinely, is
simply this:
PROBABILITY DOES NOT EXIST
The abandonment of superstitious beliefs about the existence of the Phlogiston,
the Cosmic Ether, Absolute Space and Time, . . . or Fairies and Witches was an
essential step along the road to scientific thinking. Probability, too, if regarded
as something endowed with some kind of objective existence, is no less a mis-
leading misconception, an illusory attempt to exteriorize or materialize our true
probabilistic beliefs. (p. x)

2 Likes

These are absolutely brilliant articles, proper journalistic level stuff! Hope you keep them coming :+1: :newspaper:

48 Likes

In fact, FiveThirtyEight’s estimates have significantly outperformed the betting market in both the 2016 and 2020 elections. In 2016, Trump’s odds of winning were approximately 5 before the election, meaning an expected value of 5 * 30% = 1.5. In the 2020 election, their estimate for Biden’s win was about 90%, and Biden’s odds were in the range of 1.6 - 1.7, meaning an expected value of 90% * 1.65 = 1.5. Of course, two elections as a sample size is very small, but I would say their analysis was very convincing.

6 Likes

And if both of Obama’s victories were included, the track record would improve even further. In the first term’s victory, I think only one state was wrong, and that was because the model had not been updated with the latest polls. Silver’s “signal to noise” is a highly praised work on making predictions. I haven’t gotten around to reading it myself.

3 Likes

That’s right. That’s exactly what I was thinking when, after the 2016 elections, people said they had failed, but a 30% probability is quite good, and that predicting very rare events is difficult for this reason, as the model is hard to iterate. There isn’t enough data to statistically say anything about the model’s functionality. However, I trust their model more than betting.

For those interested, here’s Andrew Gelman’s article on election forecasting.

1 Like

I don’t know if we’re going to digress, but how should one evaluate something like 538? The sample size is so small that if you only look at how the percentages are distributed between two candidates and who ultimately won, you don’t get much reliability. Would you get a better estimate if you took the situation, say, 6 months before the election (or some specific time) and looked at the odds for each state at that time, compared them to the betting market, and placed bets on those targets where there was the biggest difference in odds compared to the betting market, with a distribution such that a larger share of the pot corresponds to a larger difference in odds, and then looked at what the outcome would have been.

2 Likes

CPAC

This weekend, Dallas is hosting perhaps the most significant Republican conference, the Conservative Political Action Conference. The conference has been held since 1974, initially annually, and in recent years twice a year. Speakers always include the party’s elite, and it is considered an important proving ground for presidential hopefuls. The conference has been known since its inception for its presidential straw polls, which have indicated the mood of party activists. Mitt Romney has the most first-place finishes in the conference’s history. The radicalization of the party in recent years is reflected in the fact that Romney is no longer invited because, according to the organizers, “his safety cannot be guaranteed.” (Romney was almost the only high-profile critic of Trump during his presidency.)

In recent years, the star of the conference has, of course, been Trump, who is speaking again tonight. It will be interesting to hear any new hints about his candidacy and, more generally, the emphasis of his speech; how much weight will Trump give to explaining the “stolen election,” and how unreservedly enthusiastic a response will it elicit?

Another interesting piece of information is the poll result. Here are the polls from the last three conferences:

The sample size in the polls is admittedly small, and over-analysis should be avoided, but the results from early 2021 likely still show the shock of the Capitol riot, and in the latter, minds had already calmed down favorably for Trump. In this year’s first poll, DeSantis gained good momentum, and now we will see if that continues. For example, a 55-35 split would be a worrying development for Trump.

P.S. @Sauli_Vilen Thank you, such feedback from you warms my heart :slightly_smiling_face:

P.S.2: @Quante Good points, I agree that, for example, the day before the 2020 election, there was no such thing as “Biden’s probability of winning” because real elections are not repeatable events.

I don’t have any hard data on the political betting market’s ability to predict elections, but at least in large, internationally played markets, the market mechanism itself should filter out severe distortions. That’s why I said it often gives an indication, especially in elections where it’s difficult to form a good overall picture from polls. (The USA is just such a case.)

36 Likes

Huh huh, Trump 69.1%, DeSantis 23.7%. The gap almost returned to what it was at CPAC a year ago. At the conference, Fox asked Trump when he plans to announce his 2024 intentions. Trump:

“It’s certainly not a very long period, the time is coming. I think people are going to be very happy, our country has never been in a position like this, we’ve lost everything.”

Can a candidacy be expressed much more clearly than that?

Trump spoke uninterrupted for 1:45; I can’t watch such a long speech. Having watched some clips, the impression was that he was relaxed and in a good mood (perhaps partly due to the poll results?), and his speech was calmer and more normal than at rallies.

Fox asked DeSantis before the conference if he would support Trump if he ran. DeSantis:

”People have asked me about that, probably about a thousand different times. I’m basically, I’m keeping my eye on the ball here in Florida. I’m doing 2022, I’ve got a campaign coming up.”

In summary, Trump is definitely entering the race, from pole position. One cannot be sure about DeSantis, but his evasiveness certainly seems to suggest a candidacy.

21 Likes

Would it be a safe bet not to run as Trump’s vice president? That’s kind of what that comment sounds like.

How much would that vacant office boost DeSantis’s popularity? As Vice President, he would, on the other hand, expose himself greatly to being associated with Trump’s countless scandals that would follow from a presidential candidacy or presidency.

If I were DeSantis, I would also be really busy in Florida during the elections and would encourage Trump remotely.

3 Likes