Taboola - Adtech for OpenWeb - an online advertising alternative

Taboola is an advertising and marketing platform for the open web. Its operations are based on user analytics rather than standard tracking and user data collection, as is the case with large players in more or less closed environments like Amazon, Google, Facebook, etc.

Taboola’s motto, “Content you may like,” largely describes its business principle. In other words, ads that display “Recommended for you” or similar are often produced by Taboola or its competitor Outbrain.

Thus, the user is presented with things and content that they are likely interested in. This is the opposite of, for example, searching for a specific item via Google. It’s an inverse search engine, in a way.

Furthermore, the technology used is significant. It does not use cookies, which currently cause problems and are likely to be phased out or have their functionality significantly restricted in the future. Taboola’s operations are based on machine learning and will increasingly rely on deep learning:

Four years ago we evolved our technology from Machine Learning to Deep Learning. In simple terms, Machine Learning looks at known parameters to try to predict user behaviors and needs. While effective, it depends on us knowing exactly what the right parameters were to predict behaviors. Deep Learning is more advanced in that it figures out what the parameters are, making behavioral predictions much more accurate, self-learned, and independent of our intervention. We believe this puts us far ahead of our competitors and our significant experience makes it harder for them to catch up.

Clients and references

Globally, many media companies find it important to keep visitors on their pages. Content marketing is essential, and here Taboola’s algorithms help visitors find interesting content.

SPAC merger

Taboola is going public via a SPAC merger in Q2 or early Q3 of 2021. ION Acquisition Corp. (which trades under the ticker $IACA) will be the target of the merger. After the merger, the ticker will be $TBLA.

At the time of the binding agreement’s publication, Taboola was widely discussed, and its share price reached $17, maintaining a good level around $13 as a promising target. Due to the meltdown in growth stocks and especially SPACs, the share price is currently at NAV (Net Asset Value) level. However, the valuation at this level is favorable, and after the merger, many institutions can also buy once purchasing restrictions are lifted. De-SPAC (companies that have completed a SPAC merger) share price movements have been varied, so volatility is to be expected with this one too.

Investor material, January 2021.

Other recommended reading

Investopedia - Taboola: How “Content You May Like” Makes Money
https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/032515/taboola-how-content-you-may-makes-money.asp

A very good Seeking Alpha article explaining the operations, risks, and potential:
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4415134-taboola-out-of-favor-adtech-presents-good-buying-opportunity

Comments from CEO and founder Adam Singolda in connection with the Q1 report. Further clarifies the company’s operations:
https://sec.report/Document/0001140361-21-017575/

A few excerpts from the articles:

Business model - where the money comes from

How Content Marketing Business Works

  • The content contributors (advertisers) who wish to drive traffic to their sites and are willing to pay for it in the role of advertisers.
  • The publishers (bloggers/site owners) who put a Taboola widget on their site and get paid for displaying the links.
  • The interface (Taboola) which connects the contributors and publishers and facilitates the functioning of the marketplace.

Ad blockers are a risk; if ads are not displayed, revenue is lost. When produced through the server to the pages, they are more visible, and ad blockers do not catch them as easily.

Although Taboola is at risk of revenue loss from adblockers, unlike many other advertisers they do not make use of any third-party cookies. Third-party cookies are already blocked in some web browsers such as Safari and Firefox, and will soon be blocked in Chrome. This makes Taboola a little more resilient than some other adtech platforms. The rise of adblockers however will likely continue to be a threat to Taboola’s business model.

Ads appear in many places other than browsers. Online stores, games, applications, TVs, etc.

Over the next 10 years I see Taboola growing to power recommendations for anything, such as eCommerce, games, applications, and I see those recommendations everywhere, on every device. They will live on our connected TVs at home, recommending shows people love, as well as in people’s cars surfacing content they love, podcasts, and text-to-audio from the open web. – Adam Singolda, Founder and CEO of Taboola

Competitors

Outbrain operates in a very similar way. Together with Taboola, they have an 80% market share in, for example, the UK (source: previous Seeking Alpha article) in open web advertising.
Large online advertisers: Google, Facebook, etc. - These, however, are primarily within their own ecosystems. Google, of course, does a lot otherwise.
Smaller niche players.

image

Economy and business

At the time of listing, the valuation was $2612M, with revenue (ex-TAC) of $379M in 2020 and an estimated $445M in 2021.
Ex-TAC (Traffic Acquisition Cost) is the figure where the portion returned to advertisers has been deducted from gross revenue. Compare this to the business model where money flows are explained.

After the merger, $582M will remain in cash, which is intended to be used to accelerate growth.

Unlike many SPACs, Taboola is already profitable, has positive free cash flow, and its growth figures are robust. Based on investor materials, the valuation is favorable at an assumed price of $10:
2021E: P/S ~5 and P/E ~16
2022E: P/S ~4 and P/E ~14

Q1 2021 exceeded estimates, and Q2 and FY2021 forecasts have been raised, making the above figures even more favorable.

2021 Q1 report and new outlook:
https://sec.report/Document/0001140361-21-017574/

Disclaimer: At the time of writing, I hold a significant position in my portfolio - at least part of the position is intended for long-term holding.

18 Likes

Uhhh, here we have a real Kamux of internet advertising :slight_smile:

It’s been a long time since I’ve seen Taboola on my computer, but these “Sponsored by Taboola” links used to be on almost every news page at the bottom of the page after an article, leading to really interesting stories like “This stay-at-home mom makes 500 euros a day working from home” or “You won’t believe these shocking leaked photos of a celebrity” or “Three ways you’re brushing your teeth wrong.” Many sites have since gotten rid of these, as, not surprisingly, spamming third-party junk content is value-destroying. Maybe the quality has improved recently, but I can’t confirm this, as ad blockers block everything related to that company now and in the future.

Edit: I tried unblocking for a moment. The quality of those ads has indeed improved a lot from what they were at their worst, though I don’t really feel like clicking on them much :smiley:

13 Likes

A brilliant analogy, I’ll borrow this for re-titling the thread. But it’s also a hated industry, with a poor or at least weaker reputation from history. Ads are annoying and adblockers rightfully broaden their user base – as they have for me for years. Nevertheless, the business is growing and profitable, meaning money is still coming into the company from somewhere.

However, improvements have already been made to the quality of ads and content recommendations, and further developments are planned.
As mentioned in the SA article under risks. My own bolding here.

Taboola has a very mixed reputation online. Some people love it, others apparently hate it. Taboola has been accused of spreading fake news. Others claim that Taboola show junk ads or clickbait. Another aspect is that the company is Israeli and is to be listed on the US stock market. Israel is not without its controversies, which likely will do no favors for Taboola’s reputation. Because of Taboola’s mixed reputation investors may not place a high premium on Taboola’s stock.

Taboola plans to use some of the funding “to start a moderation team to keep fake news and harmful content off the open web.” If Taboola can better fend off fake news, then this could help improve their reputation.

And there are also better starting points for adblockers than for many other players. Cookies are not used or are minimized. In addition, server-side code helps to display links. Cookies will be phased out or their use significantly restricted. Apple has already started this, and I believe others will follow. Taboola thus already has a head start here.

Although Taboola is at risk of revenue loss from adblockers, unlike many other advertisers they do not make use of any third-party cookies. Third-party cookies are already blocked in some web browsers such as Safari and Firefox, and will soon be blocked in Chrome. This makes Taboola a little more resilient than some other adtech platforms. The rise of adblockers however will likely continue to be a threat to Taboola’s business model. I’m unaware of any plans by Taboola to counteract this threat.

Taboola has a slight technological advantage in combatting adblockers than other advertisers because Taboola runs a combination of client-side and server-side code. Adblockers work best at blocking ads generated by client-side code.

Ads are, of course, an essential part, but content marketing is another perspective. The image shows a section taken from the CNBC website, where both the ads and internal content links are Taboola’s work. This potentially keeps users on the pages longer, reading articles – and also seeing the ads that generate the money to create that content.

7 Likes

If I interpret that link correctly, this company was profitable in Q1 2021, but not, for example, a year ago in Q1 2020, and the company is essentially the same as it was then. Now, in Q1 2021, TAC (Traffic Acquisition Cost) has decreased while revenue has grown, and this has increased gross profit so much that the quarter barely turned a profit. This is certainly not a sustainable direction of development, however, as growing revenue increases TAC.

Based on this, it’s not really possible to say whether the company will be profitable after the SPAC or not. I would most likely estimate no, because using cash for growth investments almost never means that the lower income statement lines improve at the same time. The company directly refused to provide a forecast for anything other than adjusted EBITDA and revenue figures.

Free cash flow in Q1 2021 was clearly negative according to those materials, although it was positive in Q1 2020. Based on these, it’s really difficult to forecast anything. However, if cash is used for growth, the direction of free cash flow is firmly out of the company. Unlike most other SPACs, this one at least has a chance to be profitable.

I might change my mind if I saw longer-term data that would make me think otherwise. However, I can only find Q1 figures from this and last year, plus guidance for Q2 2021 and full-year 2021 for revenue and adjusted EBITDA.

4 Likes

Thanks @Helel, I specifically wanted a challenge around this, to see what all I might miss and what else I need to consider.

The investor material contains more detailed figures. Adjusted EBITDA is, of course, the only one here too.

I still need to look into that Q1 FCF more closely. It was already in the works, but I haven’t had time yet. But at least the background is an increase in server capacity for the development of more efficient algorithms.

FCF from the past couple of years and forecasts. The investments in 2021, $30M above normal, are mentioned here.

4 Likes

I don’t think that 2020 FCF table will hold. If positive operating cash flow covered capital expenditures like that, there would be no need to raise net cash with a SPAC in the first place. Generally speaking, I’m not very happy that only revenue growth is well-defined. Standard accounting is important so that people don’t have their own setups.

This is a pretty good case if things go as promised. But at this stage, you have to trust their word alone.

Alright, now perhaps more substance. I’ll read through those.

1 Like

More info from Taboola’s investor pages, balance sheets, etc., opened up in more detail

and the analyst day material, largely similar to the investor material

https://www.taboola.com/about/investors

In 2019, strategic investments were made with selected operators - whatever that means, the impact on cash and results can also be seen in more detailed figures.

4 Likes

SEC filings, CEO’s comments

Ethical responsibility

We want to behave as a good corporate citizen. We stress the need for strong safeguards in order to combat hate and fake news poisoning the open web. At Taboola, we know that humans must be involved in solving a human-created problem, since AI is just a tool, not a solution. Through Q1, our moderation team reviewed about half a million ads every week before they made it to the open web. Content moderation is a top priority for us, and our entire management team spends significant time strategizing on this matter.

So, moderation is already being done extensively. Part of the capital raised is intended to be allocated to developing this section.

Raising capital is not always the only goal. Of course, $151M goes to current Taboola owners, which is not insignificant. But a large share of 77% remains in their control. Networking, additional investments in growth, and potential acquisitions are also part of the picture.

We are pleased to have added two advertising and publishing veterans Deirdre Bigley and Lynda Clarizio to our Board. As part of our merger, Gilad Shany, the CEO of ION, our SPAC partner, will also be joining our Board. Details of these new Board members are the subject of a separate press release.

2 Likes

Partnership with Oracle

First similar cooperation on both sides

“Advertisers deserve clear proof that their investments are paying off,” said Adam Singolda, CEO and founder, Taboola. “As we continue to innovate around formats and placements, bringing sophistication to the way we measure is equally as important. Oracle Moat is a clear leader in measurement and having their advanced analytics living side-by-side to our own measurement gives advertisers complete transparency. Advertisers get a clear picture of how Taboola video ads are mapping to their goals, whether more views, completions, or conversions. We are proud to team up with Oracle Moat on this exciting integration.”

Partnership with Samsung in Brazil

The new service called Samsung News Feed brings news curation directly to the homepage of Samsung’s standard internet browser, Samsung Internet, offering a feed with news and content from well-known publishers such as: O Globo, Valor Econômico, Istoé, Época, Veja, Exame and R7 on Samsung cell phones.

2 Likes

And a bigger fish in the net in addition to the previous ones: BBC as a client

Taboola Feed, a seamlessly integrated feed that provides readers with personalised content for a more engaging experience, enabling monetisation of below-article placements, will be integrated into BBC.com - the home of BBC News and BBC Sport - in all markets outside the UK, where the publisher is commercially funded. Its aim is to drive revenue while keeping UX and the integrity of the brand intact, as well as to grow engagement and audiences across the site.

2 Likes

Let’s continue the monologue :sweat_smile:

Adam Singolda’s interview Redirecting...

Third-party cookies are gradually disappearing. Taboola uses first-party cookies, which recommendations—both content and ads—are based on. Server-side content, which ad blockers, for example, do not remove as easily, is also based on this.

Google, among others, is also removing third-party cookies from Chrome in 2022. Apple has already done this for iOS. The aim is to improve online security in general.


Types of cookies

Let’s run through definitions of first- and third-party cookies before taking a look at how they differ from one another.

First-party cookies

What are first-party cookies? A first-party cookie is created and stored by the website you are visiting directly. It allows site owners to collect customer analytics data, remember language settings, and carry out other useful functions that help provide a good user experience.

Third-party cookies

What is a third-party cookie? As the name implies, third-party cookies are created and placed by third parties other than the website you are visiting directly. Some common uses include:

  • Cross-site tracking: the practice of collecting browsing data from numerous sources (websites) that details your activity
  • Retargeting: using search activity to retarget visitors with visual or text ads based on the products and services for which they’ve shown interest
  • Ad-serving: making decisions regarding the ads that appear on a website, deciding when to serve these ads, and collecting data (and reporting said data including impressions and clicks) in an effort to educate advertisers on consumer insights and ad performance.

Here’s a table summarizing the key differences between first- and third-party cookies:

1st-party cookies 3rd-party cookies
Creation Originate from the main domain opened on users’ web browsers. Publishers set the cookies to their website using JavaScript code. Do not belong to the main domain opened on users’ browsers. They are loaded by third-party servers (such as ad servers) on publishers’ websites.
Accessibility Work on the main domain (publisher’s website) only. Accessible on any website that loads third-party server’s code.
Browser support Supported by all browsers. However, users are always free to block cookies from their browser settings. Historically supported by all browsers but many are now blocking them due to increasing privacy concerns. Also, in the case of incognito mode, browsers do not load third-party cookies.

Source: What is the difference between first- and third-party cookies?


And the impact of all this on advertising will be significant. Content marketing will play a big role:

Walled gardens have direct access to their audiences and the means for easily securing consent for first-party data. Because of this, walled gardens will be one of the few areas where brands and agencies can leverage first-party data.

In other words, large players (walled gardens) and their use of data in their own networks will strengthen. The open web, the general internet, on the other hand, is a free-for-all, where Taboola already has a strong foothold. This can be expected to strengthen further as the network’s operational structure changes, First mover advantage, etc. Competition will certainly increase, but there will also be enough pie to share.

1 Like

Cookies on the hook

1 Like

Merger day published 28.6.2021

https://sec.report/Document/0001140361-21-020082/nt10019597x18_425.htm

DEF14 filing not yet published and approved, which contains all the merger terms. However, it is expected to come fairly soon now that the date has been published.

Edit:
DEFM14A published
https://sec.report/Document/0001140361-21-020192/nt10019597x19_defm14a.htm

1 Like

Israel’s new Prime Minister Naftali Bennett has direct connections and apparently significant ownership in Taboola

It recently became known that an investment Bennett made in Payoneer 13 years ago, before entering Israeli politics, is expected to yield him millions of dollars. The Israeli fintech unicorn plans to carry out an IPO through a merger with a SPAC named FTAC Olympus Acquisition Corp., at a value of more than $3 billion. Bennett is believed to have invested several hundreds of thousands of shekels in the company in its early days. Bennett has a long standing relationship with the company’s founder and President Yuval Tal, introducing him to Keren Levy, Payoneer’s current COO, who previously worked at Cyota.

1 Like

With the merger, IACA’s current listing will change from NYSE to Nasdaq.
https://sec.report/Document/0001213900-21-033069/

A new agreement has been written again
https://seekingalpha.com/pr/18367592-taboola-signs-long-term-strategic-partnership-sliide-to-power-content-recommendations-for

Sliide is completely new to me, but it creates content for operators and phone manufacturers, among others.
They have acquired four US operators as clients, among others.
https://sliide.com/news/sliide-signs-fourth-operator-usa

1 Like

Merger approved, new ticker TBLA starting June 30.
:partying_face:

SEC filing
https://sec.report/Document/0001140361-21-022538/brhc10026321_425.htm

7% redemption of shares, $526M capital from the merger.

1 Like

Looks like the ticker is indeed changing today. I almost had a heart attack when I checked my portfolio and it showed an absurd loss for today. In my portfolio, these are still with the old ticker and a value of 0€. It will be interesting to see how the ticker change and the final confirmation of the merger affect the stock price.

Taboola competitor Outbrain to go public via traditional IPO
https://seekingalpha.com/news/3684042

One view on valuation already available, 130% upside, $23 target

My own estimates don’t go that high yet, but I’d gladly take it :sweat_smile:

1 Like

Taboola seems to be suffering from weak sentiment along with other deSPACs and the Russell 2000 index.
However, this changed, at least temporarily, when Taboola announced a significant acquisition. Hopefully, this will increase visibility and put the company on a more permanent upward trajectory.

Connexity is the target, an e-commerce platform for the open web market. It therefore perfectly aligns with Taboola, and the synergy benefits are potentially significant not only for customers but also for the visibility of advertisements and content, which also positively impacts the bottom line.

Connexity, like Taboola, is a profitable company, at least in terms of EBITDA. A quick look at the valuation shows it’s in line with Taboola’s figures, so no significant undervaluation was gained in this deal.

Connexity generated $158 million of revenue, $63 million of ex-TAC Gross profit and $28 million of Adjusted EBITDA in 2019, growing to $176 million of revenue, $78 million of ex-TAC Gross profit and $38 million of Adjusted EBITDA in 2020, driven by expansion of its merchant customer base, as well as the successful integration of Skimlinks’ market-leading commerce content technologies.

Taboola plans to finance the transaction with approximately $260 million from cash on hand, $300 million from committed debt financing and approximately $240 million through the issuance of ordinary shares to the seller. The exact number of ordinary shares issued will depend on the volume weighted average price of Taboola’s shares over the five business days ending three business days prior to the closing.

https://investors.taboola.com/news-releases/news-release-details/taboola-acquiring-connexity-bringing-personalized-e-commerce

Connexity’s clients include Walmart, Wayfair, Skechers, Macy’s, eBay, Otto

https://seekingalpha.com/news/3718495-taboola-buys-e-commerce-media-platform-connexity-for-800-million

Based on Friday’s 14% rise, the market at least liked it :sweat_smile:
And there’s still plenty of room to rise significantly to even reach some kind of fair value.

Edit: Let’s continue a bit more
This is at least partly what it’s about

customer success stories

Quite impressive figures achieved

And another edit2: the same story in blog format:

2 Likes

Needham Initiates Coverage On Taboola.com with Buy Rating, Announces Price Target of $13

These are currently following:

1 Like