I wasn’t in a hurry, but I wanted to grow my portfolio quickly
Leverage is a good friend in positive sentiment. Now, it wouldn’t even cross my mind to use leverage, and on the other hand, I might not ever need to again anyway. Maybe I’ll join Oksaharju’s team.
I also belong to the camp where the goal is to gradually grow my portfolio without really looking at the stock prices, but rather to keep buying more shares of quality companies. Many people on this forum seem to be more traders, so am I in the minority with this slow style?
Well, don’t use the loan gurus, they have lived most of their lives during a time when all interest rates were significantly higher than now. Currently, you can get a secured loan at around one percent or margin accounts (e.g., Degiro) with an interest rate of less than 1.5%. These margin accounts don’t even need to be paid back; you can just carry them on interest. Such “never take a loan” advice is useless because it doesn’t take interest rates or anything else into account. In the US, people trade “calls and puts” with loans. That’s a long way from even lightly leveraging a dividend portfolio like a REIT (Real Estate Investment Trust) or Sampo.
There is no loan in the stock portfolio. Cash accounts for about 15%. However, two apartments (own + investment) have loans amounting to about 65% of their value. The idea is that if there were a major market correction, I would put the cash to work and take out more loans from the bank against the apartments. Nordea values apartments at 75% as collateral, and in this case, an additional 10 percentage points of loan would mean almost €50,000 more to invest in the portfolio. And it naturally grows all the time as the loans are amortized.
In general, I have also noticed that owning apartments provides a certain security, as it is then possible to take out secured loans from the bank against them if buying opportunities arise on the stock market. This, of course, assumes that the loan amounts remain reasonable in normal circumstances. I sat on a large cash position for too long, missing out on the massive returns of recent years (about 50% of investment assets in cash), this was before buying the apartments. The Nordnet (Nordnet) limit is in place, but perhaps I would primarily use it only as a temporary solution during a market correction while waiting for a bank loan.
I’ve already touched on the cash side, but I’ve had to withdraw money for general expenses, so I’m a few thousand in the red.
In practice, the entire portfolio was built with loans back in the day. First, consumer loans in the aftermath of the financial crisis, and then more affordable loans. I definitely can’t recommend it, but in 2009 you could get stocks at ridiculously low prices, which in a way, a broke person like me had to take advantage of.
I’ve been wondering…I have Sampo, etc. and other large, quality companies in my portfolio…wouldn’t 1.5% investment loan already pay for itself with dividends? Am I calculating something wrong?
During the COVID-19 dip, I took out as much debt as I could (using my stock portfolio and detached house as collateral), at its worst, the leverage was well over 100% of my free capital. The risk was incredibly high, and I don’t recommend such actions to anyone. However, at that moment, my thought was that if the world doesn’t end with this pandemic, this is the first once in a lifetime buying opportunity in my investing career when blood is truly flowing in the streets. Even though the best buying conditions passed too quickly, the bet didn’t go completely wrong, as my own capital has approximately sextupled from the absolute lows of March 2020.
Currently, debt is about 15% of the market value of the portfolios. I have gradually reduced it as the market has risen and the valuation multiples of the portfolio companies have increased. Despite the markets being at all-time highs, I intend to continue to hold some form of leverage in my portfolio, at least as long as I believe I can achieve a better return from the markets compared to the interest paid on debt. 10-15% is probably a suitable level to ensure good night’s sleep.
I have a so-called long-term portfolio consisting of value/dividend companies that I buy steadily using financial leverage. The trading/speculation portfolios are separate, and I would never invest borrowed money in them, nor do I invest more money in individual stocks in these portfolios than I can afford to lose.
Used wisely, debt is, in my opinion, a good servant to improve the return on equity, provided the investment target is also sensible. Many people leverage investment properties, but investing in stocks with debt is somehow seen as incredibly risky. If one considers, for example, Sampo, one of the most stable companies in the Helsinki Stock Exchange (whose dividend-adjusted share price has increased 20-fold in the last 20 years), if someone had offered an investment loan at 1% interest in 2000, in hindsight, I would not have hesitated for a moment to take out as much debt as possible and invest the money in Sampo to make it grow.
That’s what I meant, because I also have a long-term portfolio with quality companies. If half of them went under, Finland would have to be in a state of war. Of course, sleep and peace of mind are more important than just growing the portfolio. I’m currently thinking about leveraging 10-15 percent. Another question is, do you think it would be better to use up the cash reserve before taking on borrowed money?
Great to hear more of these successful stories. Many people later wonder why they didn’t go all in with both hands and leverage from the corona dip. The fact is that a great many people have become wealthy during this period, which is a tremendous success for those who took and tolerated the risk.
No leverage at all. At the beginning of the year, I considered debt leverage during the rising market frenzy, but my stomach and mind couldn’t handle navigating a leveraged portfolio. My goal is to curb constant back-and-forth impulsive actions, which debt leverage would not help me achieve. Cash currently makes up 55% of my portfolio.
This is the core of what I meant… I bought a bit more during the COVID dip (should have gone all in, though) and after that, I’ve been steadily buying quality companies. I’ve been less impulsive, as you shouldn’t buy big all at once and then contemplate selling.
During the COVID-19 downturn, I mainly lamented the lost returns, and I was genuinely glad I wasn’t leveraged. Even in those dark moments, it never crossed my mind to take on leverage.
If you consider your own home and investment properties as part of your portfolio, the leverage is almost 50%. I haven’t planned on using leverage for any securities or funds. I do realize that the current situation with real estate loans is not risk-free, and therefore not completely stress-free either. A good night’s sleep is more important than any returns.
For now, I don’t see any use for securities leverage. The portfolio is already large enough that historical returns provide a comfortable retirement security. This year, I haven’t put new money in; in fact, somewhat against my guidelines, I’ve taken money out. There isn’t much sense in that, as I’m only 34 and my investment horizon is long. However, a similar portfolio meltdown as in the COVID-19 crisis in March 2020 would sting a bit.
I’m not aiming for FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early) or specific euro-denominated targets. So, I’m not in a hurry. The portfolio provides security, which volatile leverage would jeopardize. I work less than 20 hours a week and my salary is enough to get by. This leaves time for hobbies and family.
During the coronavirus dip, I bought small slices totaling 20,000 euros and made a couple of dumb sales. I also had cash, but somehow panic struck me, thinking what if these just keep falling, what if what if what if, and I didn’t buy more May I ask, since you’re 34, why don’t you just steadily buy quality companies for the next 20 years… I believe you could build a pretty big portfolio without sales and tactics… if you invest in quality companies?
Debt leverage is currently around 35% compared to equity. The credit line was opened around the bottom of the COVID-19 dip, and leverage has been gradually increased along the way. It feels incredible that equity has almost ten-folded since the bottom of the COVID-19 dip. Additional equity has, of course, been added monthly from earned income, and there’s also a significant amount of unrealized taxes waiting. Now I’ve grown accustomed to the portfolio easily fluctuating by more than my monthly salary on a normal stock market day.
The funds are intended for purchasing a home in the coming years. As long as the expected return is greater than the cost of credit, I view leverage quite calmly. You have to be willing to lose a lot to win big.
Do you include your detached house in that equity?
My investment portfolio’s equity has quadrupled since March 2020. This calculation does not include the apartment. Its value has risen perhaps 10% due to the general price increase. If you include it in the equity, then of course the growth multipliers drop.
I had been planning for a long time that I needed to be ready if the opportunity arose.
I actually operated with very moderate risk. I didn’t go anywhere near all-in with debt levels, nor did I take out loans against stocks. I like to leave the game open enough for all options and not bet entirely on just one scenario. Still, during the COVID-19 pandemic, I’ve seen almost 10 years’ worth of stock market returns on my invested capital. During the summer, I have once again increased my non-stock buffers for the future.
For most of my debt, the unencumbered portion of my detached house served as collateral, whose value does not directly correlate with the stock market. Therefore, the risk was not as great compared to if the debt had been solely dependent on the value of the stocks.
__
‘Back-of-a-cigarette-packet’ calculations (figures are approximate, and the interest rate on the debt naturally changes the end result):
Successful end situation after x time:
Portfolio return 250% => Market value 420000 - remaining debt 50000 - loan interest/handling fees 5000 = Equity 365000
vs. without leverage
Equity 60000 + Portfolio return 250% = Equity 210000
__
Conversely, leveraging a bear market can lead an investor to go ‘bust’, as Pyysing puts it. With the same figures, a ~55% drop would be enough for the equity to melt into negative territory (if the investor were to freeze and do nothing with their portfolio):
Equity 60000 - Portfolio return 55% = Equity 27000
__
In summary, using debt can at best significantly improve equity returns and at worst destroy them completely. The most important thing, in my opinion, is to relate one’s risk level to the current market situation. The COVID dip was an entirely exceptional situation where almost all stocks were practically free for a short while. In the current market, where new all-time highs are being hit almost every day, I would be very cautious about taking out any new loans against stocks.