Let’s have a discussion about investment loans, taking them out/comparing them, and similar topics.
How many of you use leverage in investing? And for what kind of investments is leverage used? In real estate investing, the use of leverage seems to be more the rule than the exception, but what about on the stock side or in other asset classes? Quite a few seem to use Nordnet’s credit, at least occasionally, but investment loans from other banks are not encountered very often.
And what kind of investment loan terms do people have? What are the margins like, what kind of repayment plans, and from which banks do the best offers come?
I myself have used Nordnet’s credit to a small extent, but I’ve been thinking for a while about utilizing slightly bolder leverage. I would use leverage for stock investments, where the investment perspective is mainly very long-term buy & hold.
Great topic and timely for me too. I thought I’d test what conditions I could get 50,000 for a stock savings account. I put in an application through Lendo today and at least the first offers have been killer with a 10+% actual annual interest rate. Let’s see it through, but I’ll probably have to walk to my local bank next to negotiate face-to-face. So advice / other people’s experiences would be valuable for this thread as well.
You can get a good and affordable loan from a bank if you have collateral. Without collateral, the loan becomes expensive. Stocks are also accepted as collateral, but that freezes the investment account (and probably also the share savings account). The collateral value of shares is 70% in most banks, and 50% for foreign shares. So, collateral, collateral, collateral… Without these, nothing happens in banks.
I myself have not taken an investment loan for anything other than my own business. But instead, I do sometimes take payment holidays if I’d rather invest in the stock market than pay off the loan.
You can get a loan with an OK interest rate if you have collateral or use instruments that qualify as collateral. For example, the collateral value of certain products is 50%-80%…
Does not qualify as collateral.
Can I use credit on a share savings account?
You can use credit in your investments also on a share savings account, but the credit must originate from a credit agreement tied to a stock and fund portfolio, i.e., a brokerage account. This means that holdings in a share savings account cannot be used as collateral for a trading credit, but the collateral will be the holdings in the brokerage account to which the credit agreement has been activated. In this case, the interest on the trading credit will also be charged from the brokerage account, not from the share savings account. The restrictions on trading credit are due to legislation related to share savings accounts. -Nordnet
I have the same amount in mortgage loans as in stock investments. In practice, my portfolio is 100% leveraged. The interest rates on the loans are currently 0.088% and 0.517%. It’s unlikely to get cheaper investment loans anywhere. My plan is to apply for an interest-only period for as long as possible, once the market decline that everyone is predicting actually begins.
I’ll be submitting some loan applications to different banks soon, so we’ll see what kind of offers come in. I’ll list them here for discussion.
If anyone has recently inquired about offers or even taken out an investment loan (specifically with the purchase of stocks in mind), please share your margins and loan terms.
Even private individuals will start applying the new IFRS standard. Lessors will suddenly have loans when the thirty-year leasing liabilities continue for another half a century
P.S. If you don’t have an apartment or other fixed collateral, don’t even bother going to the bank
What an interesting opening. For years, I’ve been dreaming of getting a bullet loan agreement for an investment loan, hoping that a bigger downturn would eventually begin. Then I could start acquiring equities with a bit more leverage. The problem with holding a vast amount of cash is that it lowers the percentage return of the portfolio. With Nordnet, a reasonable interest rate remains if the loan amount is negligible. Of course, a super loan (suoperluotto) is currently in use despite that.
Now that I’ve sold off my investment property portfolio over the past couple of years, I’m particularly interested in loans that don’t require any properties as collateral. A “loan portfolio” could certainly be pledged there, as long as it doesn’t overly restrict trading those shares. One would think that if you sell a share, the cash collateral value would be 100% :D, and the shares could then be, say, 70%. So, if I applied for a €100,000 loan and transferred a few tens of thousands of euros alongside it, I could get a bit steeper leverage in the event of a possible economic crisis.
I have a home loan and an investment loan.
Home loan margin 0.55 and investment loan 1.2% - minus 12-month Euribor. Bonuses for insurance etc. from both.
The company has cash and plenty of room to take on debt if things got really bleak…
If your apartment is already collateral for another loan and has been for a while, you should check its collateral value. If it has increased, you can easily get more collateral for the loan. You don’t always need collateral for the entire loan if you have a good banking relationship.
When investing with borrowed money, you need to be careful. Volatility then becomes a real risk. If you have €100,000 in debt invested in stocks with a 50% collateral value, you first need €50,000 of your own money as collateral. If stock prices start to fall, the bank will issue a margin call, meaning that the stocks taken as collateral no longer cover the loan. The options here are either to be forced to sell the stocks at a loss or to transfer more collateral to cover the loan.
I think those who bought Nordea at €10 with borrowed money in the hope of dividend yield got burned when the price dropped to around €5.20. On paper, a 5% dividend yield should cover a 1% loan interest rate, but the matter is more complicated. There will be no dividend income when the stocks have to be sold, and after the loan repayment, there is no equity left.
Stocks are so expensive anyway now that I wouldn’t dare to gamble with debt.
3.5% interest without collateral sounds almost cheap. If you want to leverage your portfolio significantly, I believe you should have a home or some other fixed asset as collateral so that the interest rate preferably stays below 1%. A portfolio itself as collateral is a rather risky business.
Short-term investing is no “walk in the park,” so returning to the very beginning of the topic, I certainly don’t recommend investing with debt to just anyone. Especially if you’ve only been investing for the first 0-5 years. It can backfire one way or another. Surprisingly and quickly. So it’s wise to have at least a plan-b and plan-c in addition to plan-a.
Regarding collateral, both an apartment and a stock portfolio can, in principle, decrease in value. The volatility of stocks is taken into account by calculating their collateral value at a lower percentage. And even apartments can have value surprises. They are not entirely protected from volatility either. Prices have just been rising for a long time now, at least in growth centers.
I still remember my late father’s comment from the 80s that apartment prices had never fallen. And the early 90s proved the exception to this rule. I’m really not a – more of a reasonably optimistic – but this always comes to mind when someone says that such-and-such can’t happen. So remember plans a, b, and c
I considered taking out an investment loan in passing during the summer of 2018. Nordnet’s Super Loan was mainly under investigation. This then fell through as the Super Loan’s low interest rate conditions required a rather uniform diversification. I prefer to take a strong stance on a company and, on the other hand, I don’t want to think about portfolio diversification based on the price of an investment loan. On the other hand, I considered my own character and concluded that in this matter, I choose the path of lower risk and lower returns. Additionally, acquiring my own home has finally become timely, and I want to start arranging its financing from a clean slate as I don’t have any other loans.
Surely, an investment loan suits many and brings better returns. However, I aim to minimize the amount of debt in my life through investing, so it’s possible that in the future, I’ll just hold more cash.
Maybe I would take out that loan if my own cash started to run low as courses dropped, and the courses were just on their way down a lot compared to my own view, and I still had a stable income but not enough money at that moment.
Then I could buy even lower.
I use leverage constantly and the results have been better than before I used leverage. Now the leverage is at a very low level compared to the size of the portfolio.