How much leverage do you have in your portfolio?

The matter isn’t so straightforward as to whether it’s ever worth it or not. And is debt taken against a home also leverage in this discussion? In practice, it certainly is, but as a significantly less volatile asset, it’s better collateral than stocks.

In my opinion, it’s entirely case-specific whether it’s sensible, and one needs to know what they are doing. The same goes for investing in general. It’s good to listen to what wise men say, but at some point, you should learn to ride without training wheels. :slightly_smiling_face: In other words, use your own gray matter.

2 Likes

Good points, and actually my summary wasn’t entirely accurate in the sense that “to no one” was his initial overstatement, which softened in the quote at the end to mean that if one has experienced the full spectrum of market sentiment with a decent equity allocation and still wants a little leverage, then it’s safer. So, if one has experienced 2008-2009 with significant equity exposure, one knows better how to react to real market fear.

I agree that volatility is an opportunity, not a threat, especially for a debt-free portfolio. But if one is more heavily leveraged and the portfolio itself is the collateral, then one is indeed somewhat at the mercy of volatility, aren’t they?

2 Likes

Yes, of course, risk is directed at the portfolio through volatility. I meant for myself that I don’t see volatility as a risk to my own psyche. I expressed myself poorly.

4 Likes

About a year ago, I asked my bank for the price of an investment loan. With the introduction of the OST (equity savings account), stock trading or speculation felt easier somehow, and tracking the tax implications annually was nonexistent.

A €50k bullet loan for five years surprisingly came with an interest rate of just under 1% (of course, collateral had to be in order).

That €50k bullet loan is now, from October 2020 to today, just under €90k. So, the leverage is quite high in this particular “game portfolio.” However, in my case, I must state and emphasize that this “cash” is expendable.

But still, from time to time, I wonder how this can even be so “easy” mathematically. I mean, that I would succeed in five years with an expected return of less than 1%.

3 Likes

Normally I have no debt at all. I even paid off my mortgage in 3 years at the expense of my investment portfolio.

Now, on Friday, I took one trade position that pushed the portfolio 2.3% into leverage. I’ll exit that in days or weeks.

I only recently started using Nordnet’s credit limit. It’s €25,000 against a share account worth over €200,000. I do intend to always stay safely on the gold level and mostly at zero, so in practice, the limit will hardly ever be more than €15,000 active, and even that only for short trades.

In my opinion, using debt leverage should not be the default. I understand it for real estate investors, and one shouldn’t handle a mortgage like I did, but it’s good to avoid other debt. It’s funny to read, or in my case listen to, Jack Schwager’s Market Wizards books, where many of the interviewed individuals burned one or more trading accounts early in their careers. Across the pond, derivatives and heavily leveraged margin accounts seem to be the norm.

The use of debt should be proportional to one’s goals and level of expertise. I am content with relatively little and know that I will achieve financial independence in time without debt, as long as I continue with the current model and save over half of my salary. By using debt, I would mainly jeopardize that goal, as I am already so close that achieving the goal wouldn’t even speed up much by using debt. Of course, if I had used it earlier, I might already be at the goal. I am also not convinced that my investing would have been at a level that would justify the use of debt.

I would also consider the market situation. Now, in my opinion, is the wrong time to consider increasing leverage. In a crisis situation, where a little bit of everything is trampled along with the market, there are opportunities for the brave to get rich, and the use of leverage should mainly be limited to such situations.

11 Likes

Currently, only about 1.5% in the stock portfolio.

In terms of total assets, the gearing is around 25%.

I’ve had a large loan for over 10 years now, and I’ve been increasing it as it diminishes due to repayments and appreciation relative to hypothetical paper wealth. Of course, it will increase if/when interest rates rise because asset prices will fall simultaneously. That’s why I’ve planned to keep the overall gearing below 40%. I’m not significantly increasing it anytime soon, maybe if there’s a major correction.

3 Likes

My debt is 80% of my portfolio’s value. For the next ten years, I’ll slowly pay down the loan once a month, and after ten years, half of the loan will be paid off. Then I’ll probably pay off the rest with accumulated investment returns and start living the life of a free man. Of course, in ten years, the situation will be re-evaluated, and it might not be worth paying off the loan then; who could predict that? But now I can get such cheap 10-year fixed-rate loans that it would feel crazy to be debt-free. Central banks are spitting out money at such a pace that the current price of a detached house will probably be the same as the price of a grocery bag in 10 years.

12 Likes

I’ll digress a bit more… if one decides to utilize borrowed money for investing, I believe it’s very sensible to consider acquiring a owner-occupied home and then start investing in stocks by dollar-cost averaging. Then, they would pay rent to themselves and gain leverage for investing. Leverage not collateralized by stocks. When in debt, it’s also truly worthwhile to focus on diversification and reduce risk further that way. Investing in a home also improves diversification compared to solely investing in stocks.

But I’m not saying that everyone should do this. For me, the risk-return is reasonable. Everyone should consider what the best plan is for them. For another person, there might be too much risk here or some other reason why it doesn’t work or appeal.

1 Like

In reality, you need to make a return of just over 5% in five years. Of this, 30% goes to the tax authorities, so the required return for five years is 7.3%. In recent years, this has been achievable even in a month, but the crucial factor is the portfolio value at the time of payment.

For example, if a 50k portfolio doubles in the next 4 years but drops by -60% in the last year, you’ll have to pay €10,000 out of your own pocket. A poorly timed decline significantly affects the outcome.

So that this doesn’t go completely off-topic and interfere with others’ affairs, back to the actual subject of the thread:

I don’t use leverage, except for a student loan, which I’ve used for living expenses so I haven’t had to touch my savings. The loan is roughly 1/6 of my portfolio. Additionally, Superluotto (Super Credit) is activated and waiting for a downturn. I certainly have a high threshold for investing with credit when the real situation arises.

3 Likes

Good message and a good challenge to my own calculations.

As a small investor, I personally wouldn’t touch a paper where the expected return would be around 7% in five years (not annually), when inflation alone could already erode the whole thing.

In my case, I could pay off the whole bullet loan now and still be nicely in the black, even after taxes. And I don’t think it would be a big problem to renew that loan in five years.

Perhaps my point here was that the risk-reward ratio at the current price of money is, in my opinion, quite good.

Hobbies usually tend to cost some money… Although you might even net something from this :wink:

2 Likes

I have less than €700 in debt from shopping, but €0.00 in my portfolio. I just don’t dare.

This is the core of the matter. One’s own contemplation is needed to identify that there are no gaps in one’s investment plan that would force one to sell shares when they are at their cheapest. It is better to weave a plan so that instead of selling, one can buy shares when they are cheap. Risk management is number 1, especially when in debt.

5 Likes

I’m thinking about paying off the loan once I’ve reached my “Lifetime equity allocation.” This can be approached in two ways, or a hybrid of them.

  1. A person is 35 years old. Wants to “retire” at 55. 20 earning years left. Ability to save €10k/year. In my opinion, and according to scientific studies, they should take out a loan for the entire €200k of future salaries and invest it in stocks today. This way, the person radically reduces the “last decade” risk.

  2. The person’s calculated “retirement” portfolio is €350k. Currently at €100k, the person keeps a suitable loan in the portfolio all the time, relative to their risk tolerance, such as 20-30%. Monthly, more stocks are bought and more loans are added to maintain the ratio. Once the “Lifetime equity” allocation is reached, the loan begins to be paid off monthly. When the loan is paid off, or alongside it, saving in bonds begins.

I intend to go with a hybrid model due to not being able to get a large enough loan with a fixed interest rate so that I wouldn’t have to fear a “margin call.” I have calculated the euro amount of my lifetime equity allocation and after a certain date, I plan to only start repaying the loan and saving an amount equivalent to 1 year’s expenses in bonds.

Why only 1 year’s expenses? Reason: Government wallet. In principle, in this promised land of social benefits, such a thing wouldn’t even be necessary.

1 Like

0%. I owe you from the bottom of my heart.

5 Likes

In the same article, Oldenburg also says the following:
"Going through zero does not lead to good results in investing (and 10% debt leverage does not even significantly improve your returns). "

I dare to disagree with the statement highlighted in italics. In my case, with a portfolio size of 2 million euros, the ~5% additional return of 10,000 euros per year achieved with 10%, i.e., 200,000 euros of debt leverage, is significant. Not to mention a longer period and the effect of compound interest. In addition, 10% debt leverage avoids forced sales even if the portfolio value drops by 70%.

21 Likes

Student loans have been used as leverage in my portfolio to kickstart my career. Currently, student loans account for about 25% of the portfolio’s value, but cash makes up 20%. I plan to take out maximum loans for both studying and investing in the future. Repaying the student loan is not yet relevant, and interest rates are low, so I intend to keep it for as long as possible. When you add the student loan compensation, it would feel foolish not to take it. The goal is also to apply for more credit (limiitti) at Nordnet on top of the current 10% available. Currently, I do not intend to use this credit until there is a downturn or a particularly attractive case comes along. However, I want to ensure I have the firepower if needed, and as a young person, I can still take a bit more controlled risk.

1 Like

Good points and thanks for the responses so far. Here one can also see what kind of investment style each person has. I myself am more of a dividend investor in stable, quality companies. I try to increase the number of shares (7-10) in a few companies, and I don’t really stare at the portfolio value. I have noticed that investing is much more enjoyable when you don’t have to constantly watch the share prices, but rather aim to grow the portfolio in terms of the number of shares month by month. Debt leverage might not work with this style of mine, because the primary goal is not to sell shares but to live off their dividend income at some point. Any thoughts on growing this dividend portfolio/investing with debt?

3 Likes

A 300k€ household with about 50k€ left to pay to the bank. An investment portfolio of 200k€, against which there is an investment loan of about 50k€, so 250k€ gross. I’m paying off the mortgage ahead of schedule, with no rush to pay off the investment loan, as the real interest rate is below zero when considering the 100% tax deductibility of interest. A perfectly fine situation.

40k€ mortgage from which I’ll get ~150k€ from my own share when selling. Investment portfolio a bit over 50k€. So, we’re going cautiously. The plan is to sell the apartment at some point, and for the next one, only put in the down payment, increasing debt for the apartment but not against the portfolio. And that surplus of less than ~100k€ is intended to be put into as safe dividend stocks as possible, as the current portfolio is almost entirely growth stocks. So, managed debt in an apartment in a locality where you “always” get your money back is my own tactic.

4 Likes

Increasing risk should indeed lead to higher expected returns, but that doesn’t mean the risk-adjusted expected return has increased. For those with strong nerves and who have seen the full spectrum of market sentiment, leverage against their portfolio might be suitable; for example, Pyysing usually has leverage (though not currently, as far as I remember).

Buffett and Munger have sometimes stated that they could have achieved greater returns by taking on more risk, but throughout their careers, they have steadily progressed with the mindset that they are not in a hurry. They have wanted to minimize the risks of going bust or at least becoming severely distressed.

2 Likes