Nokian Panimo - on a mission to make thirst a pleasure

Kauppalehti writes:

"Nokian Panimo’s news on Tuesday morning was thus pleasing – not so much because of the investment case, as the time for its evaluation is only later – but because organizing a public offering requires courage in a situation where there has been no experience of such an offering succeeding for a couple of years.

The situation has long been completely different from, for example, autumn 2021, when a person who closely followed IPO processes quipped to me that anyone could now go to the street and collect a few million for an offering.

Nokian Panimo has not yet disclosed the size of its offering, but it is unlikely to be very large, as the company itself is of a moderate size."

I will follow with interest and perhaps participate. Small investors have recently taken quite a beating in various brewery ventures, which might dampen enthusiasm. On the other hand, perhaps they invested in those more for support. Nokian Panimo has a history and track record of profitable business, so I believe interest will be quite reasonably good, provided the pricing is at a reasonable level.

18 Likes

Inderes’ interview was good, somehow the focus seemed to be on long drinks, and the competitive situation there is also challenging. What added value/competitive advantage does the company bring to long drinks?

And another thing:

It’s not quite clear: Uutuudet 2024 - Nokian panimo.._gaMTg4OTk4OTg4OS4xNzM5OTIxNTU4*_ga_VMBLV3LVKL*MTczOTkyMTU1OC4xLjEuMTczOTkyMTU4OC4wLjAuMA..

Sun’n Blueberry Blast

Blueberries as if picked from a hummock. The best aromas of the forest’s tastiest blueberry canned into a refreshing thirst quencher. Authentic things sweetened with sugar. Bilberry or blueberry, a blueberry is a blueberry.

??? So is cultivated blueberry juice the same as wild bilberry juice? It’s not clear.

2 Likes

My guess is that most participants in the offering are aiming for the general meeting’s “real dividend,” meaning free taps would be open after the meeting and black sausage as a chaser. So the offering will easily go through.

9 Likes

The company is still unlisted, and they surely have large individual owners as well as management committed through ownership. So they don’t think about profit distribution solely from the perspective of a small investor trading for fun. If one is committed to owning Panimo shares due to their position, promises of future appreciation might be a bit empty. That’s why, in my opinion, a dividend is perfectly OK. A dividend can also be thought of as a form of management compensation.

30 percent of earnings is a rather low payout ratio and also encourages management to direct investments towards truly profitable targets in the future.

In my opinion, the logic you mentioned is also a bit foolish, that the company takes out a loan even if it also has cash in its own coffers. However, it’s worth remembering that the company has many different types of owners, and a dividend plays a different role for all of them.

15 Likes

Great interview, but it grated a bit when he mentioned that the company already has 2000 small investors and some would like a marketplace to trade their shares. It will be interesting to see if there are any selling restrictions on old shares or if everyone is immediately given the opportunity to Exit. Especially if the valuation of this ‘sausage stand’ is thrown somewhere around 20 million, the ride could be tough.

The company’s performance has been impressive, but it should be noted that significant growth always requires large investments, and on the other hand, they still want to remain a microbrewery, so the equation is a bit peculiar.

I already have Olvi in my portfolio, so this will likely remain only on my watchlist.

–

The BBQ festival Grill & Chill will be held again this year in the Nokia Brewery area on June 13-14, 2025, so if anyone wants to get to know the company better over good food, it’s worth putting the date in your calendar now.

9 Likes

The majority of Nokia Brewery’s shareholders are specifically small investors, and there are only a few main owners (who have thus ended up on the list). Several “old Privanet companies” have the same problem: there are many owners, but the shares cannot be traded. With the listing, this problem will be resolved, which is a good thing.

If one wants to examine comparables, here are the annual reports of Laitila, i.e., the largest small brewery: Toimintakertomukset – Laitilan Wirvoitusjuomatehdas

6 Likes

I am not yet an owner, but I will become one. From an investment perspective, the company has a clear positive feature: the main owner is an Evli-based banker, meaning the company is developed with finances first. Well, after this, I will naturally get too few shares when I consider this. Marimekko also improved its operations with a banking-based approach. Undoubtedly, increasing market share is a big job, but at least the company is managed based on money, not sentiment.

4 Likes

When analyzing a brewery, it’s good to also look into the popularity of its products :smile: The two largest breweries are very evenly matched (source: Untapped).
image

image

P.S. Perhaps there were 2 bankers with an Evli background, https://www.porssitieto.fi/osake/lisaa/pup.shtml.

5 Likes

Edit: someone just beat me to the forum with Untappd. All other domestic ones I tested mostly had over three points. No wonder the products aren’t very familiar to me. Well, maybe volume products are always a bit more generic.

Volume products never have super high ratings. Take Heineken for example (2.95).

The recipe for business success is more like = a good enough tasting or ok beer + a suitable price + good coverage in retail stores.

P.S. I have also tasted through the brewery’s entire non-alcoholic selection, and there are 3-5 very good (potential) products to be found there.

9 Likes

If Untappd were to evaluate value for money, I bet the scores would be higher. But when the metric is just quality, you can’t work wonders with reasonable production costs.

According to THL, from 2007 to 2023, total alcohol consumption in Finland has decreased by more than a quarter, and the trend seems to continue. The million-dollar question is, how can that growth be kept above 10 percent annually…?

Good question! The goal is the company’s own, and they are probably also counting a lot on non-alcoholic and sun’s lemonades. And there’s market share to be gained, which the upcoming cider launch certainly also aims for.

4 Likes

Both Olvi and others have invested heavily in so-called other products. I’m not saying that Nokia specifically couldn’t succeed in this segment, but this field is open to all players.

3 Likes

It just has to muscle its way in by taking market share, 2% might even grow, but I wouldn’t even bet on that.

1 Like

I would personally think that there is indeed a good market niche to be found between the cheapest of the cheap Pirkka beer and expensive specialty beers gathering dust on the shelves. The arrival of stronger beers in stores has also created a tremendous amount of new opportunities for the sector.

Statistics are certainly not encouraging regarding beer consumption either, but the strongest decline seems to be in spirits.

Nokia Brewery also clearly communicated that it is a microbrewery and intends to remain one in the future. The goal is therefore not to climb into the top three in market share.

9 Likes

Based on my own experience, younger adults have stopped buying cases of Koff and Karjala (illustrative example) and have switched to a smaller quantity of better beers. A very small portion buys five-star beers costing €10/bottle. Most drink a few 0.5-liter cans per weekend, e.g., products from Nokian Panimo. Edit: meaning volume decreases, but euros can still increase, especially for a brewery making slightly higher-quality products like this.

9 Likes

Can anyone say what this could be due to? In November, authorization was given for a share issue of 100,000 shares per board member, and it was decided that the price must be at least the mathematical value of the share. At the corresponding general meeting, it was decided that shares could be bought for the company at a price of €0.7. It would have gone cheap if one had sold to the company earlier.

That’s exactly what happened to me too; the boxes of Koff and Karjala were left at the store. For growth, the statistics are still quite stark; according to them, the market share of small breweries in the Finnish beer market has been around 5% in recent years (there are about 120 small breweries). As CoktailJet said, one has to work hard for market share.

1 Like

I dare say that investment target is not for you. Although it is certainly bold to try to form opinions on behalf of others. But all the same, this week’s communication was clear enough that, for example, no acquisitions will be made and they want to remain a microbrewery in the future.

Traditionally, Finns are scammed by microbreweries, both their products and their share issues. The Pyynikki scam is surely still fresh in many minds. Now, however, an alternative is coming to that field, where it is quite realistic to expect a return on invested capital and that the management will not completely fleece the investor. But it’s hard to see any story in Nokian Panimo where the company would achieve fivefold revenue in ten years or be on the same map in market share with the three largest.

Of course, who ever knows about these things. The company can always end up as part of a larger entity, or other unforeseen turns of events may simply occur.

1 Like