Fortum - Accelerator of the Clean Energy Transition

Chief Financial Officer Tiina Tuomela was talking about her company as an investment target at the Stock Investor’s Week. : )

4 Likes
10 Likes

What would a breakthrough in fusion mean for Fortum?

2 Likes

Hardly anything in our lifetime, if there are less than 30 years left to live.

22 minutes is still a long way from a commercially viable and reliable product, and once that is achieved, the construction time will certainly be many times longer compared to a traditional nuclear power plant.

4 Likes

The article is behind a paywall. It would be nice to get a summary of the article and the author’s own thoughts.

(EDIT: Thanks for the summary a couple of posts below.)

5 Likes

A lot, but this article you linked doesn’t actually contain any breakthrough yet. A large expensive device consumed 2MW of thermal energy for 22 minutes and maintained plasma with it. So it did not produce energy.

Interesting for engineers trying to solve the practical problems of fusion power - in this case, how to control the plasma so that it does not damage the equipment.

Tell me when the device produces energy instead of consuming it and can do so without major repairs after each experiment…

4 Likes

From a commercial perspective, it’s better to follow thorium reactors and their development. Thorium practically has no significant nuclear waste problem, and there’s even more of the substance than uranium. If I remember correctly, there’s already one operating in China. The technology isn’t new, but because by-products of uranium reactors were desired for nuclear weapons, it gained ground in the last century.

1 Like

The article in question is Kauppalehti’s report on Fortum’s current video presentation during Investor’s Week. I thought the article was open to everyone when I posted it, but apparently it’s behind a paywall now. The video itself was posted earlier in the thread by @Sijoittaja-alokas.

In Fortum’s CFO’s video interview, perhaps the main point is that investments significantly expanding energy production capacity are not currently profitable due to electricity prices. Regardless of the production method. However, the inevitably progressing electrification is highlighted, and Fortum has the readiness to quickly expand its own energy production, e.g., with wind and solar power, and pumped-hydro storage plants are under development. Nuclear energy is worth building only if it receives support (or if electricity prices rise). In small modular reactors (SMR), the technology is not yet certain, meaning nuclear power as a whole is primarily a matter for the 2030s. Of course, the renewal of existing nuclear power plants is coming in both Finland and Sweden.

“Author’s own thoughts”:slight_smile: Today, the Financial Times wrote an article about a chronic shortage in aluminum production and rising prices. Fortum is currently investigating an industry plant to be established in Kokkola, which would increase Finland’s electricity demand by almost 10% compared to current consumption. On 31.10.2025, a data center report will be published, which will likely solidify their further construction (although news about new constructions is almost weekly already). Similar developments are happening in the other main market, Sweden. Etc. And if, on top of this, global affairs calm down and the economy recovers, the pieces for an upturn in the electricity sector would start to fall into place.

I view Fortum’s current situation like a real estate investment. Fortum’s share price does not reflect (perhaps not even close to) the value of its energy plants. Even if the company or its stock doesn’t skyrocket, there’s hardly any fear of a dive once the global adventures are over. The combination of hidden value, stability, dividend, and the upside potential in the electricity sector suits a long-term holder quite well:)

21 Likes

China Activates World’s First Thorium Reactor — U.S. Tech Inside:

China Activates World’s First Thorium Reactor — U.S. Tech Inside – Engineerine

4 Likes

As others have noted, nothing.

No “breakthrough” is coming, nor is it really even being sought. Fusion research is a systematically progressing set of large and smaller international projects, whose ultimate goal is an industrial-scale (=commercial) reactor. Progress is continuous development, has been for decades, and depending on the metric, is actually fast.

In practice, all tokamak research is related to the ITER experimental reactor being built in France and some sub-area of it (including that one). Its purpose is to combine all information obtained from small experimental reactors and test it on the scale of a real reactor. ITER should start up in the early 2030s according to the current schedule. It is still a purely scientific experimental reactor.

Depending on ITER’s results, an industrial reactor will be designed and implemented next. From that, one can then calculate how long it will take to replicate the technology. We are talking about the end of this century before fusion would produce even some quantities of energy.

In addition to magnetic fusion (tokamak and other closely related solutions), so-called laser fusion is also being studied, which is based on compressing fuel with powerful lasers. However, its primary purpose has been nuclear weapon simulations.

Among the most challenging questions for magnetic fusion are still materials, the confinement of fusion plasma, and the removal of impurities from the plasma. It has not yet been planned in detail how energy will practically be extracted, i.e., how a fusion reactor would boil water.

For the most part, however, the problems are engineering problems.

PS: So, the news itself is not that extraordinary. It is significant because they have managed to confine plasma for such a long time in a tokamak-type reactor.

9 Likes

In addition to being able to build a functional industrial-scale power plant, it should also be able to produce energy at a competitive price. Old and proven nuclear power is currently unable to do this, and I, for one, wonder what will become of fusion power. Wind, solar, and developing electricity storage will largely determine the market price in the future, a price that would need to be beaten.

4 Likes

I spoke again with the portfolio managers of UB’s renewable fund. As usual, I also asked for their gut feeling about the market situation. Tapio interestingly pointed out that the transformer business would be strong related to data centers. And transformers are not ordered unless the construction of the data center is certain.

9 Likes

The Swedish government unleashes a nuclear power initiative. Tens of billions in loans below the general interest rate, a separate risk reserve fund, and a guaranteed electricity price for builders are on offer.

This package is considered sufficient for 2500 MW of new nuclear power capacity.

What will Fortum do?

45 Likes

Since not everyone necessarily actively follows the coffee room discussions, I dare to quote this message also in the Fortum thread. @Juha_Kinnunen, whom I had imagined to be somewhat reluctant towards Fortum as an investment, turned out to be a Fortum-Bull with a 10-year outlook :slightly_smiling_face:. The stock is probably fully priced looking 12 months ahead, but in the long run, the situation might be different. Juha also beautifully takes into account the beauty of dividend investing in his comment :smiley:

31 Likes

Against this backdrop, the recent removal of Fortum from the model portfolio feels a bit odd and not very consistent.

11 Likes

Didn’t you just sell all your Fortum shares, are you back in again now?

Here’s the difference: a person can, as an individual, hold any view they wish and disagree about future electricity prices, and buy Fortum for their own portfolio. But when stocks are chosen for these model portfolios, the figures are entered into Excel, and if futures indicate that electricity will be cheap in the future, then it’s assumed to be so, and no significant profit is expected.

I personally have a strong position in Fortum in my portfolio and stock savings account, and I always buy more when the time is right, because I also believe electricity prices will significantly increase in the Nordics in the future, regardless of what futures say.

8 Likes

Agreed. I believe that electricity price estimates are way off the mark. The reason is rising consumption, which will certainly cause price rallies and raise the price level. And even if prices in Finland rise significantly, they are cheap by European standards, and electricity-intensive investments continue to flow here.

Fortum should focus even more on wind and solar energy in the future. The interest in nuclear power is puzzling, as it provides electricity steadily but at a high production cost. By diversifying wind and solar power plants to other regions besides Western Finland (Eastern/Southeastern Finland and Lapland), production can be made more consistent. Furthermore, electricity production should be clean and close to consumption sites.

1 Like

The biggest problem with those, however, is still that when they are needed most, the least is obtained. That’s why nuclear power is currently the only correct solution.

Wind and solar can indeed complement them. But believe me, this year too we will reach a point where there is no wind, no sun, but it is actually really cold.

16 Likes

Hardly any more homes will be heated than this😀 The increase in electricity consumption will go to industrial use, and in a normal situation, it’s run flat out summers and winters 24/7. In a weak production situation, the pace can be slowed down. Regional decentralization balances production.