Financial sector as an investment

Morgan Stanley posted excellent results this quarter, and all of its business areas apparently performed well. Wealth management saw a significant inflow of new client assets, and investment banking and trading operated at a record pace.

The company’s management praised the consistent and successful execution of its strategy and strong growth across the globe.

Morgan Stanley clearly benefits from the market recovery and client confidence.

https://x.com/earnings_guy/status/1978422247137161382



Company’s own materials

image
image

4 Likes

Strange things are happening in forest funds right now. S-Pankki Metsä’s return for the last 12 months is -14%, and comments on the forest market are quite negative (https://www.s-pankki.fi/fi/saastaminen-ja-sijoittaminen/rahastot/s-pankki-metsa-a/).

Meanwhile, OP Metsä’s return for the last 12 months is 11%, and comments were positive at least for Q2 (Q3 comments not yet published / https://www.op.fi/henkiloasiakkaat/saastot-ja-sijoitukset/rahastot/kaikki-rahastot/op-metsanomistaja).

It’s absolutely impossible for me to understand how the return difference between funds investing in forests in the same target market can be 25% in a year? This can no longer be explained by any small technical trickery or delay; there’s a blatant difference in valuations here. It seems S-Pankki has seen some capital outflow early in the year, so have they possibly been forced to sell some assets, and would this explain such a drastic valuation difference? In any case, it’s wild stuff and highlights the problem with alternative funds, where the fund company itself also acts as the valuer.

58 Likes

Björn Wahlroos interviewed by EFN Ekonomikanalen. The interview is in Swedish, but English subtitles are available from the menu if needed. Duration 1h 25min. Topics include banks, insurance companies, and financial markets, as well as politics in the Nordic countries and Europe, the forest industry, etc. The Nvidia and Nokia deal and Nalle’s (Björn Wahlroos’s nickname) current portfolio diversification are also discussed.

10 Likes

Last week, among other things, a real estate transaction came to light, where UB Forest Fund was the buyer. Out of pure interest, I looked into what kind of plot it was, as it can be easily found with its property ID. It was a 45-hectare plot in central Finland, and based on satellite imagery, one-third of the plot is pure bog, one-third is stunted bog-mixed forest, and one-third is somewhat growth-capable-looking young coniferous/mixed forest.

I don’t know the purchase price of that particular plot, but seeing it, I couldn’t help but think how some “gel-haired” person sitting in an Espoo office is buying forests just to put cash somewhere. :smiley: However, it’s pointless to expect huge timber sales revenues from that plot.

From Luke’s website, I looked at the development of stumpage prices for trees over the last year:

According to this, the price of sawlogs has fallen by about five percent across the board during the year, and the price of pulpwood by over 15%. Based on this, the highest price peak for timber might already be behind us.

These forest funds were discussed already at the beginning of the year, and my view has remained pretty much unchanged. OP-Metsä, which still presents huge return percentages, has made most of its returns through Tornator and revaluations of forests, and in my opinion, this cannot continue indefinitely. There are no buyers for the forests owned by the funds at the valuation levels of the funds, should they need to be converted into cash due to redemptions.

In my opinion, it’s only a matter of time before these funds also close their doors, similar to housing funds. In housing funds, the first redeemers still managed to save themselves before the closure.

35 Likes

Tässä on Sale’s comments on domestic investment funds’ performance in October. :slight_smile:

According to the Fund Report published by Finnish Investment Research, domestic investment funds received net subscriptions of over one billion euros in October. Sales were strong in both equities and fixed income, and sales were also broadly distributed among operators. For the entire year, net subscriptions are almost four billion in positive territory, and the whole year is shaping up to be good in terms of new sales. Value changes were also clearly positive in October, and driven by these, fund assets swelled to 199 billion (9/25 193 bn). With high probability, November will see the celebration of the 200 billion euro milestone being broken in domestic fund assets.

5 Likes

Yesterday, an acquisition took place in the industry when Osuuskunta KPY acquired private equity investor Sentica. Tunnettu pääomasijoitusyhtiö vaihtaa omistajaa – Näin KPY aikoo hyödyntää kauppaa | Kauppalehti

With some experience in the sector, I dare say that this arrangement was not on any sector player’s radar. On paper, the logic of the arrangement remains a bit obscure to me, as I don’t immediately see what KPY brings to the table here. The idea is probably that KPY can accelerate fund sales, but I don’t quite understand how. :thinking:

For Sentica, this smells purely like an exit. Sentica receives KPY shares in the arrangement, which indeed strengthens earlier rumors of KPY’s potential listing. It’s hard to see Sentica wanting KPY shares without knowing that they will become liquid at some point.

22 Likes

You’re probably right about that :laughing: More than half of the people left/were sent away from Sentica already a year or two ago when the new fund didn’t materialize. So, in that sense, this was probably a way to get the last benefit out of the name. That listing plan is indeed very likely; otherwise, a share exchange would hardly have been acceptable.

3 Likes

According to KPY’s updated strategy, in the future, own balance sheet investments will be made in Sentica’s funds. Could selling funds be easier when KPY acts as a co-investor?

2 Likes

Certainly, KPY will be an anchor owner in the funds, and this might facilitate sales when the owner itself has a lot of “skin in the game”.

4 Likes

When liquid turns illiquid, the saga continues! Kauppalehti also spotted that Ålandsbanken slammed its “open” wind power fund shut in July. Tuhansien suomalaisten rahat jumissa 240 miljoonan tuulivoimarahastossa | Kauppalehti

He states that the connection between the Wind Power Fund and the electricity market is explained by the fact that when electricity prices are high, investor sentiment in energy funds is better, and the transaction market for potential sales of wind farms becomes more active. According to Känkänen, higher electricity prices would improve the liquidity situation of the wind power fund.

This comment is, in my opinion, even a bit amusing. I somewhat doubt that customers were told during sales situations that if electricity prices are low, they won’t be able to withdraw money from the fund. :man_shrugging:

The fund owns only 5 assets, one of which is 100%.

image

Selling those assets in the current market is really difficult (electricity prices are too low), and furthermore, those minority holdings complicate sales even more (fewer interested buyers for minority stakes). If the electricity market does not recover, this might have to postpone redemptions for a very long time.

As I’ve said before, I consider it quite likely that some forest fund will postpone redemptions next. :evergreen_tree:

36 Likes

There are also several projects in the development phase, as stated in the fund report:

The fund and the Finnish
renewable energy company Myrsky Energia Oy entered into a collaboration
regarding the development and ownership of certain wind
power projects in 2021. This collaboration ended in June 2025, and as part
of the termination of the collaboration, the parties agreed on an arrangement
where the ownership of six wind power projects was transferred entirely to the fund.
All six projects are in the zoning phase, and they are intended
to reach construction readiness within the next few years. Myrsky will continue
as the project developer for the transferred projects for a transition period, after which
the fund will continue project development with a new cooperation partner
of its choice.

Talouselämä also reported on this Myrsky Energia collaboration in August (paywall):

The 15 million euro dividends raised from those project companies went into the pockets of Korpi Capital and another Myrsky Energia shareholder. The wind power fund demanded large damages from Myrsky’s owners, but the dispute was settled quietly in June of this year. I have no information about any compensation the fund may have received.

However, a new partner has now been found for these projects:

Ålandsbanken Wind Power Special Investment Fund initiates project development cooperation with ABO Energy

6 Likes

In open-ended funds, there is a generally overlooked risk: what if the fund is committed to project developments and capital starts flowing out. In residential property funds, this risk was absolutely insane during those crazy years when everyone was building frantically, trusting that their own equity would remain and debt would be available. I don’t know what on earth would have happened if cash flows had turned away from open-ended residential property funds a couple of years earlier and banks’ loan taps had dried up. :detective:

12 Likes

Can someone smarter reason why these “special” funds from brick-and-mortar banks are so popular? Still, even though they have already been closed for redemptions. I don’t know on an absolute level how big they are, but significant sums of money are stuck in them for private individuals.

With just a minute of searching, Nordnet offers all kinds of investment options for wind power, forests, and real estate. In all of these, the costs are significantly lower than bank funds, diversification is greater, and I would bet the liquidity is also considerably better. Quite certainly, there are all kinds of offerings elsewhere too. If I myself were investing, for example, €50,000 in wind power, I would want to own much more than just a few wind farms in Finland.

Or are the largest private clients of these funds elderly people just above the guardianship threshold, who trust the bank like a believer trusts their god? From them, the bank then extracts everything it dares to ask for.

Is it easier to sell when the customer can concretely go and see the wind turbines or properties they own? Does there need to be something physical, when even securities are no longer in tangible paper form?

4 Likes

They are sold to bank customers with a diversification story. To customers who know nothing about Nordnet and who do not choose their own investments but rely on the bank’s recommendations. And there are many more such investors in Finland than those who dig up comparisons from Nordnet or even know that this could be done.

11 Likes

I can’t help but bring up my own, surprisingly much-noticed article on open-ended real estate funds:

What caused the gold rush?

Before we delve into the fix, let’s consider for a moment why open-ended real estate funds have been so popular. The era of zero interest rates caused a massive real estate boom in Finland (also seen as a bubble in the housing market), and real estate investing became a hobby for everyone. The zero interest rate era led to a situation where risk-free interest became an unproductive risk, and real estate investments came to fill this void of interest-bearing investments (for both institutions and private investors). When the return curves of these open-ended funds were drawn as if with a ruler, risk categories were very low, and the products were still in liquid form, they sold like free buckets at an opening. Naturally, the industry also had a huge desire to respond to the demand, as the fee levels of open-ended real estate funds are truly attractive compared to traditional asset management.

This same explanation, spiced with the diversification angle raised by @Lisko1, applies to all alternative investments (forest, wind, real estate, etc.).

15 Likes

I have been led to understand that Ålandsbanken’s fund is in any case entirely banker-driven, and unlike, for example, Taaleri Energia, it has no concrete expertise in developing or managing wind farms. In that case, one is even more completely at the mercy of the market.

The same can also be highlighted in housing funds, for example. Some funds (companies) themselves control essential parts of the value chain. For example, they own entire buildings and can make investment decisions themselves and consciously manage assets. And generally, they are market participants on a completely different level. And others just engage in speculative investing in fund form, meaning they try

4 Likes

@Alex_af_Heurlin1 good article on real estate valuations based on the YLVA case :abacus: :department_store: What has bothered me about the whole YLVA case is that the media has constantly talked about a “fire sale price” or “selling below fair value”. Yes, the properties were sold below book value, but that is different from fair value. The market still seems to have a strong misconception that there is some magical fair price for properties, which is clearly higher than current prices. No one says when and how this fair price will be reached, but it supposedly exists and is relied upon. This is why, for example, funds have also postponed redemptions, because they don’t want to sell properties below this mystical fair price. :man_mage:

However, the unfortunate fact is that this “exceptional situation” advertised by managers has lasted for almost three years, interest rates have stabilized, and real estate transactions are recovering. In my opinion, talking about some mystical fair value in this situation is completely foolish. The fact is that this current price is the fair price and the current market situation is the new normal. Acknowledging this hurts, because properties were often bought in the zero-interest rate euphoria of a wild market, and now the values are something completely different. After 10 years of zero-interest rate punch, the hangover is severe. However, this is the prevailing market reality. For example, in YLVA’s case, the properties have been for sale for a long time and have certainly been offered to all interested parties. That was the best price obtained. If real estate news is to be believed, an auction was even held for this (Keva voittanut tarjouskilpailun Ylvan kiinteistöistä, kaupassa kanssasijoittajina Mrec IM ja HGR - Kiinteistouutiset).

Feel free to object if the perspective is too black and white! :black_large_square: :white_large_square:

49 Likes

That was also a forced sale. Ylva genuinely had no option but to sell, and the buyers knew that. By definition, that is not fair value, even though it was the best price that could be obtained in this situation and with this timetable.

From the media, I have understood that there genuinely were no other buyers for the entire portfolio. For individual properties, there might have been, in which case (perhaps?) a better price could have been obtained if there had been an opportunity and time to play that card.

Still, in the big picture, I agree, the book value is definitely not fair value, and that value is probably not very far from the true market price.

8 Likes

For the weekend, let’s share Fundco’s Saku Sairanen’s critical blog post about PE funds and private investors. Evergreenit ja pienten sijoittajien vedätys - Fundco

Essentially, in the text, Saku warns about an ongoing trend where PE funds are sold to private investors with high return promises. The fee structure of these products is fundamentally very high, and there is undeniably a big risk that the winners are ultimately the managers, not the end investors.

Also here is my podcast from just over a month ago with Saku on the same topic:

20 Likes

Related to this, I came across a Kauppalehti article from a couple of weeks ago, in which Sauli

8 Likes