Basware stock thread

The offer document has been published, here are the current dates for the progress of the process :point_down:

1 Like

“In light of this, I don’t see a competing offer as very likely from this direction either.”

Would a competing offer have already been published by now (since the current tender offer was announced), if one were forthcoming?

1 Like

I glanced at Tikkurila’s sale; I guess this can also happen:

  • Before Christmas, PPG offered €25, with redemptions starting on January 15, 2021.
  • Then Hempel contacted Tikkurila, which led PPG to raise its offer to €27.75 on January 5, 2021, and then the redemption offer began on January 15, 2021.
  • However, on January 18, Akzo Nobel topped the offer at €31.25.
  • Then, on February 4, 2021, PPG increased it to €34.
  • Later, in October 2021, trading ceased on the stock exchange after an arbitration court confirmed PPG’s right of redemption.
  • In the Ahlström case, a higher price than the offer consideration was mandated for compulsorily redeemed shares.

Tradeshift was offering €46.5 a few years ago but couldn’t secure the financing.
Basse’s valuation is clearly below Coupa’s.
But the market sentiment has weakened, and interest rates are rising. Not good for valuations based on more distant future cash flows.
On the other hand, this sector is the future, with a lot of the market yet to be divided. However, the analyst estimates that there isn’t really a clear buyer (at a suitable price).

In summary, the game is still open in principle, although it might already be decided


1 Like

The Tikkurila case actually came to mind, but I wasn’t involved in it, nor have I (yet) bothered to go through the whole scenario. But that’s a good example, so thanks for that!

One could, of course, think that a competing takeover bid would have been good to announce before the current takeover bid officially began, as was the case with Tikkurila. But nothing yet


The deadline for the tender offer is next week
 Help a beginner out, what happens if I don’t accept it? Or is it better to just say yes?

  1. You can sell the shares directly on the stock exchange now (if the price is the same, this is a good option).
  2. You can accept the tender offer → you will receive the money when the process is complete.
  3. If you do not accept the tender offer, your shares will be redeemed later (this will probably take a few months at most?).

This is what I know to be true, at least in situations where the deal goes through and the buyer acquires a large enough percentage of shares to redeem them directly under the law.

1 Like

If you accept, your hands are tied, and if the ownership is small, it probably doesn’t really matter, though you never know.

If you don’t accept, it’s possible to sell to the market. On the other hand, it might take even longer if the limit is exceeded and you wait for redemption.

1 Like

The UK authority has not completed the regulatory approval for the acquisition, and “Bidco” is extending the redemption offer from June 7th to June 21st.
It’s likely due to bureaucratic slowness rather than any reason stemming from an actual investigation, as this is merely a change of ownership and not a business merger between companies or similar

Perhaps the share price picked up as a result of this news?

As for my part, the remaining shares were sold today; the last sell orders triggered at EUR 39.75. This company’s stock market journey has been quite a rollercoaster during the last 4 years I’ve owned it.

https://news.cision.com/fi/basware/r/sapphire-bidco-oy-jatkaa-ostotarjouksen-tarjousaikaa-21-6-2022-asti-yhdistyneen- kuningaskunnan-viran,c3580595

2 Likes

@Antti_Luiro

Hello, in my opinion, the offer price does not match my view of future potential, especially since the profit has finally turned in the right direction even on the bottom line, and cloud revenue is increasingly showing real growth, which has been hidden under declining license sales for several years. This has now changed as license revenues have already dropped to a mere nominal level. In addition, compared to its peers, Basware looks particularly affordable.

In my opinion, you have commented on the matter very sparingly. To me, it directly shows a lack of strong opinion. “Decent/reasonable price” is not a very impressive view, in my opinion. And it also feels that for these reasons, many investors are willing to accept the offer even if they don’t necessarily consider the offer very good (throwing in the towel). On the other hand, I understand that one may not want to “criticize” the client’s board, but then one cannot speak of a completely independent analysis.

I also received the letter below, sent by Basware but signed by the buyer’s representative, just before the previous deadline. This “ACT BEFORE THEN” was an insult to investors, in my opinion. To me, it strongly smells like small investors are being taken for a ride, and for this reason, I sincerely hope for a view on why you consider this a decent offer.

I don’t think it is, and therefore I do not accept it, and I hope that many others will not accept it either, so that the buyer understands that the price is not enough.

P.S. I also tagged you in a Twitter thread I made, but I didn’t get a reply. I hope to get one now.


2 Likes

Hi @Eemeli_Vierimaa! Apologies for the slow response, social media has received less attention than usual in recent weeks :slight_smile:

We comment on the attractiveness of the tender offer more broadly in the report published on April 21, which has also been referenced in recent comments on the progress of the tender offer. Here is the section of the report dealing with broader valuation :point_down:

If you have any more specific questions, I’ll be happy to answer them when I return from vacation in just over a week :+1:

1 Like

Thanks for the reply.

Good points, though. I disagree about the discount relative to comparable companies, especially when talking about an offer.

I see a very opportunistic consortium that has surely made very precise calculations to ensure this is an excellent deal for them.

I hope it falls through (or rather, they increase the offer), even if it causes some turbulence. So I don’t approve.

1 Like

Of course, the buyers have certainly seen an attractive opportunity to make moves here. There are two perspectives on valuation: short-term (12 months) and longer-term (5 years+).

In the short term, I don’t believe Basware’s operational figures yet support the takeover bid’s valuation, as I see it will still take time for the company’s growth and profitability to strengthen. Revenue multiples, in turn, are typically strongly linked to these figures in the sector.

In the longer term, which is certainly on the buyers’ minds, growth and profitability have the prerequisites to strengthen and, correspondingly, raise the justified valuation level. From this perspective, it is possible to create attractive forward-looking scenarios at the current valuation, but I don’t see sufficient drivers for pricing these scenarios in the short term.

3 Likes

As an addition to the previous point. I still see a completely possible scenario where the offer doesn’t materialize (the owners see the offer as too low compared to the long-term potential). In this scenario, it could also be justified for a long-term owner to lighten their ownership at the current valuation and re-enter at a lower price, provided that our expectation of a clearly lower valuation without an offer materializes. Basware’s share valuation was only about 20 euros/share before the offer, and the general valuation levels of companies in the sector have only decreased since then.

Of course, it’s good to remember that this is just one option and perspective among many, as our perspectives always are :slight_smile: today at 4 PM was the last day of the extended offer period, let’s see what kind of announcement comes out about it.

2 Likes

Tomorrow is going to be an interesting day. Contrary to Inderes’ view, I sat on the biggest position in my portfolio without reducing it (either), accepting the IP offer only now (reluctantly). If the tender offer doesn’t go through, a price drop is a given, and I will personally face a fairly significant “loss”
 Well, let’s see what happens


1 Like

The wise men had a strong reduce recommendation, yeah. I also held but already sold everything on the stock exchange.

Buyers of Basware at 95.6%
So the deal will go through

3 Likes

It looks very likely - here’s a comment to follow up: :point_down:

3 Likes

A week ago, I received a notice by mail regarding Sapphire’s application for arbitration. The application for the appointment of a trustee (section IV.4) is requested to be handled urgently so that trading on the stock exchange can be suspended as soon as possible.

What happens to a stock bought on the exchange today in the redemption process? Will they be redeemed along with the others once the paperwork is complete?

I’d also like an answer to this
 will the remaining shares be forcibly redeemed at a little over €40, and is it possible to make a profit by selling them for under €40 on the stock exchange?

If I don’t respond to the letter at all, will I apparently be paid €40.1 for them?

Let’s redeem it at the price determined by the arbitration court, if this isn’t appealed. The price could, in principle, be even €45, but in this case, it’s unlikely to increase.