Auto1 Group, digital car trading without stores, Europe's No. 1

Hello everyone! As a long-term Kamux investor, my interest in Q3 focused on Auto1 Group, which held its IPO in Q1 2021.

segments: Auto1 Group = sells to dealers
AUTOHERO = sells directly to consumers.

Auto1 Group buys cars from consumers, etc. (Q3 approx. 160,000 cars) and sells cars to dealers across Europe.

The purpose of the IPO, however, was to start growing its own consumer brand (AUTOHERO), and just under ONE BILLION euros were raised in the IPO.

Auto1 Group operates with its AUTOHERO brand in 9 different countries:

FY 2021 revenue guidance is 4.5 - 4.6 Billion euros. The company is making a loss and has Softbank as a financier and owner, among others, so I assume it will be a growth engine for some time. The company’s own goal is to be Europe’s largest and most profitable used car seller.

For the Autohero brand, the company actively markets, and this has yielded results as Autohero is growing rapidly, and Q3 Autohero sales were already 11.3k cars; I expect the growth to continue very rapidly!

Autohero offers free home delivery, a 21-day return policy, and a one-year warranty on its cars.

The strategy includes its own processing centers, which have only recently started to be acquired (Germany 2 units (150+300+ jobs), Poland Warsaw (275 jobs), and Spain Toledo (250 jobs)). Total 975+ (552 filled in Q3).

Autohero is heavily in an investment phase, and GPU/car is 365 euros/car (merchant 772 €/car). With the help of the processing centers, the company estimates it will achieve an additional 500-700 euros / car in gross profit. The company has several other ideas to improve AUTOHERO’s profitability (e.g., in-house financing, insurance, etc.).

The capacity of the first 4 processing centers is 90k cars / year, and there are already 552 jobs there at the end of Q3 (total announced for these 4 centers is 975+, with over 300 people mentioned for Berlin). So, according to this, the current capacity could already be over 45k cars/year.

In 2022, the plan is to increase the number and capacity of processing centers and geographical reach to, I believe, an annual capacity of 150-250k cars (2023+ 400k+).

The IPO price was 38 euros, and the 2021 targets at that time have been exceeded, and the centers’ capacity is allocated for 90k, yet the share price has fallen below 20 euros…?!

Valuation: approx. 4.2 billion and revenue guidance 4.5-4.6 billion! EV/Sales below 1 and almost a billion in cash, much less debt. The cash position is strong, so that probably forgives a bit (even though money is being spent on glass trucks, marketing, and centers).

For example, Kamux, which is profitable, has an EV/Sales of approx. 0.5.

Management purchases of approx. 4 million at just under 25 euros / share (so someone in management is also down 20-25% on their last purchase… as am I, and all IPO participants are surely already almost -50% if they have held?)

What do you think, is Auto1 Group starting to be attractively priced, and can it achieve its goals and become the largest (it already is!) and most profitable (it is not now) used car dealer in Europe?

Why has the share price fallen 50% from the IPO, and are we starting to be in an attractive range?

11 Likes

@Arimatti_Alhanko @LakeBoodom A thread has been opened for Auto1 Group!

The share price has fallen sharply since the Q3 results. Are we starting to be on interesting ground? We might soon catch up with Kamux in terms of EV/sales valuation if Kamux doesn’t pick up the pace.

8 Likes

At least we’re much closer to Kamux’s multiples than in February 2021 :grinning_face:

Thanks for opening the thread. I talked with Auto1 management after the IPO but haven’t actively followed their actions since then.

If I remember correctly, their goal is to create a European Carvana, meaning that in the long run, they would fully manage their own logistics and have drivers on the company’s payroll instead of using third-party services. This has been Carvana’s big advantage. They can move cars from one place to another and to consumers very quickly.

5 Likes

Yep, they’ve ordered hundreds of glass trucks, and I assume they’re handling the logistics themselves. The trucks are quite impressive and help build the brand. They’re also taking the processing centers into their own hands and have mentioned, for example, offering their own long-term insurance and financing, plus add-ons like tires, etc. They’re probably building this in phases.

Autohero’s long-term target GPU would thus be 3000 EUR/car (currently 365 EUR in Q3 2021).

From the processing centers, according to the plan, they’re aiming for 500-700€/car. Centers are currently being leased and staff hired. Indeed, I saw that at the end of Q3, 552 people were working in these centers (Poland and Spain recently announced). Current capacity is 90k cars/year = 90000 (cars) * 500-700€ = 45 million - 63 million €.

In 2022, the goal is to increase capacity to 150-250k cars/year, which would already generate significant savings.

For rented spaces, I don’t remember exactly if it was the current capacity or what, but perhaps 2 million/quarter in rent for a certain amount. Of course, these savings will come in phases as they get the operation running, but the idea is clear.

1 Like

Good opening for the thread. I haven’t looked into Autohero in depth myself, but I have a few thoughts, perhaps on a more general level.

In the short term, companies like this that are in a strong investment phase and thus unprofitable are unlikely to be very good investment targets—that is, if one is looking for quick returns. Then, when considering the longer term, which in my opinion needs to be at least five years, even 10 years ahead, I would start with two questions:

  1. Highly fragmented industries tend to consolidate. Do you believe the same will happen in the used car trade?

  2. Digitalization causes significant disruption in every industry—“software will eat the world.” It’s clear that digitalization will also change this industry—in some ways, it already has, as trading has already moved more online.

As @Arimatti_Alhanko noted, Autohero clearly seems like a large-scale project aiming to create Europe’s “Carvana.” However, Carvana’s market share in the US is still only 1%, so there’s plenty of room for growth to become a clearly dominant player, and investments are still ongoing, with profitability not yet in sight in the near future. Autohero’s investors—especially Softbank, as @Digidistruptio mentioned—are looking for exactly these kinds of targets that are believed to become the number one player in a highly fragmented industry. In Europe, Cazoo might also have a similar approach.

Softbank knows that this is a long project and will cost a lot. Autohero’s business model is very investment-heavy at the beginning—especially these “inspection centers”—but the hypothesis is that, in an Amazon-like fashion, huge investments in infrastructure will pay off in the future. As such, this is a relatively binary investment target, meaning all or nothing. Kamux’s model, for example, is entirely different, proceeding relatively moderately and also caring about short-term profitability. In this case, the investor must take a strong view, especially regarding the long game—do they believe that 1-2 very large players operating purely on a digital model will emerge in Europe, and that Autohero will be among them? And will the owners’ (Softbank etc.) confidence also be sufficient, as this requires being in a strong investment mode for years to come? On the other hand, if successful, the company’s position will be very strong, even monopolistic, because few entities in that market situation would want to embark on the same building project. Creating a two-sided marketplace is truly challenging. One can draw a comparison to Amazon in some way here.

In summary, I would say that Autohero is currently an investment target where both the bear and bull cases sound very reasonable; it’s easy to see reasons why it could succeed or why it could fail. For my part, at this stage, it falls into the “observe and follow” category :slightly_smiling_face: Sentiment is also against these “story cases” right now, although it’s possible that the markets are overreacting and good buying opportunities will emerge :man_shrugging:

4 Likes

Here, the IPO participants have already paid significantly on behalf of the new owners. I have a position, but this has been a poor investment for me so far.

The sentiment is indeed terrible for this kind of thing at the moment.

In addition, increased car prices also boost revenue, which could turn downwards at some point, making growth not look so rapid for a while.

If the price were somewhere around 15 euros/share, we would probably be in Kamux valuations… especially with cash.
I mean, with revenue multipliers.

2 Likes

According to Auto1 Group’s guidance, Q4 revenue should be approximately 1.3-1.4 billion.

EV/Sales for FY 2021, at today’s price, would be about 0.8, and there’s a good amount of net cash.

@Arimatti_Alhanko, Arimatti, could you find out how much the net cash is for me?

1 Like

750M euros seems to be the cash and some liquid bonds or similar:

I don’t know how much the inventory size varies, but overshoots in inventory size in one direction or another should probably be considered. Although the inventory itself is more or less liquid assets, a large part of the cash is also earmarked for inventory growth, and not just to absorb “burn-rate”.

So it’s hard to say whether P or EV is better for auto1, or perhaps some variation.

Debts (whatever they include) are 430M euros, meaning net cash of 320M euros (?):

2 Likes

Preliminary Q4 sales figures released:

https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/auto1-group-se-q4-2021-060006893.html

3 Likes

This might have been somewhat influenced by the updated guidance:

Q3 guidance: a total of approx. 600k units. This is not far off.
Q3 purchases totaled over 160k units.
Now, according to this, 180.6k units.

So, perhaps growth will continue next quarter?

2 Likes

Auto1 says that its brand recognition increased the most in Europe, etc.
https://irpages2.eqs.com/websites/auto1/English/6500/news-details.html?newsID=2195447

The year-end looked strong and might have exceeded guidance.
https://ir.auto1-group.com/websites/auto1/English/1/home.html

Cash position still around 721 million.

In my opinion, it looks good, even though profitability is not yet fully targeted, but profitability is improving while expanding and opening own centers.

Autohero is growing rapidly.

Edit. The share price is naturally falling?…

3 Likes

Interesting thread related to Auto1:

https://twitter.com/value_invest12/status/1507003483257548802?s=21

1 Like

AUTO1 Group SE / Key word(s): Financing
06.04.2022 / 07:30
The issuer is solely responsible for the content of this announcement.

AUTO1 Group SE: AUTO1 Group closes inaugural consumer loan asset backed securitisation

  • Inaugural EUR 150 million asset backed securitisation to re-finance car loans offered to Autohero customers

- Important milestone in building the best embedded financing experience in the used car market

Berlin, 06 April 2022 - AUTO1 Group, Europe’s leading platform for buying and selling used cars online, today announces that it has closed its inaugural EUR 150 million asset backed securitisation (“ABS”), refinancing car loans extended to Autohero customers, with Citigroup as Senior Note Purchaser.

Autohero, already the largest online-shop for used cars in the EU, is offering embedded, fully digital car financing options currently to its customers in Germany and Austria. By closely integrating the car purchase and car financing into a single digital transaction, Autohero is building the best car buying experience.

The ABS transaction re-finances both existing consumer loans, further improving AUTO1 Group’s strong cash position, as well as future consumer loans. The ABS initially covers car loans originated in Germany and Austria as direct sales financing but is structured to be upsized and cover additional markets going forward. With this ABS, AUTO1 Group has access to scalable and low cost capital to accelerate the growth of its embedded financing offer for Autohero customers. The ability to issue its own consumer car loans and access the ABS market are important differentiators for AUTO1 Group, allowing it to digitise the EUR 100 billion European car finance market.

Markus Boser, CFO of AUTO1 Group: “Embedded, fully digital financing is a key growth driver for our Autohero business. This consumer loan ABS, alongside the recently announced upsizing of our inventory ABS, allows us to rapidly grow Autohero while reducing our cash investments. This transaction, and the trust of our banking partners it represents, is also a significant validation of our embedded finance offering and vision. Offering our own fully digital financing products, as well as efficiently re-financing them, sets us apart from our competitors and will become an important part of our vision, Building Europe’s largest and most profitable car dealer.”

@Arimatti_Alhanko have you been following Auto1 Group, it seems to have bottomed out. Of course, you’re now running a fund that focuses on Nordic stocks, right?

Does Auto1 G sell forward to City the customers who have taken out financing?

Above is the Q1 report. A positive note is the strong rise in Autohero’s GPU (Gross Profit per Unit) this quarter. Growth is good otherwise, but losses are also being incurred. Guidance was kept unchanged.



Instructions unchanged.

Autohero GPU on the rise, which is positive and necessary.

1 Like

Q2 luvut ulkona:

2022

DGAP-News: AUTO1 Group SE / Key word(s): Miscellaneous
AUTO1 Group SE: AUTO1 Group sells 166,100 units in Q2 2022
13.07.2022 / 07:31
The issuer is solely responsible for the content of this announcement.

AUTO1 Group SE: AUTO1 Group sells 166,100 units in Q2 2022

Berlin, 13 July 2022 – Today, AUTO1 Group publishes Q2 2022 unit sales and purchases.

In Q2 2022, AUTO1 sold 166,100 units in total, of which the Retail segment Autohero delivered more than 15,750 cars. The company expects gross profit per unit (“GPU”) for the Retail segment of more than EUR 980 for Q2. The Merchant segment sold 150,350 vehicles and segment GPU is expected to be more than EUR 720 in the second quarter.

1 Like

AUTO1 Group SE: AUTO1 Group reports strong Q2 growth and increases revenue guidance for 2022

Autohero crosses IPO target of EUR 1,000 GPU twelve months early

  • AUTO1 Group Q2 2022 revenue up 63.1% YoY at EUR 1.74 billion, gross profit up 27.3% YoY to EUR 126.4 million
  • Autohero quintuples its gross profit, grows units 87% and more than doubles revenue YoY, while improving its strong customer satisfaction levels
  • AUTO1 Group’s Merchant business continues its solid growth track record, with units up 12.0% YoY at 150,377 units and revenue up 54.3% YoY to EUR 1.47 billion
  • AUTO1 Group is well funded with over EUR 640 million of cash and no corporate debt to achieve its goal of adjusted EBITDA profitability by Q4 2023
  • AUTO1 Group increases revenue guidance for 2022

Berlin, August 3, 2022 – AUTO1 Group, Europe’s largest trader of used cars, today announced its financial results for the second quarter of 2022. Following a powerful start to the year, AUTO1 continues to deliver strong growth across all key metrics driven by the ongoing success of its digital business model.

AUTO1 Group outgrew the used car market by 37%, demonstrating the power of its platform and its ability to take market share. The Group increased the number of cars sold to 166,147 (Q2 2021: 142,715) and increased revenues by 63.1% year-on-year to EUR 1.74 billion (Q2 2021: EUR 1.07 billion), with gross profit up 27.3% year-on-year to EUR 126.4 million (Q2 2021: EUR 99.3 million).

AUTO1’s Merchant business continued on its solid strong path, registering a 12.0% year-on-year increase to 150,377 units (Q2 2021: 134,300 units) and further strengthening its position as the central player in the EU used car market. Revenues and gross profit in the merchant segment rose to EUR 1.47 billion (Q2 2021: EUR 951.0 million) and EUR 110.1 million (Q2 2021: EUR 96.2 million), which corresponds to an increase of 54.3% and 14.4% respectively.

AUTO1 Group maintains very strong liquidity with cash on balance sheet of EUR 640 million and unutilised commitments under its ABS lines of EUR 375 million. AUTO1 Group is well funded to achieve its goal of Adjusted EBITDA profitability by Q4 2023.

Christian Bertermann, CEO and Co-founder of AUTO1 Group: "Following our strong start into 2022, the second quarter has again been very successful for us. With our unique business model, we are creating outstanding customer experiences and are well on track in building the largest and most profitable car dealer in the EU. We have reached an important milestone in improving Autohero’s profitability by achieving our EUR 1,000 GPU target one year early. We are pleased to increase our revenue guidance for 2022 and are making good progress to our goal of adjusted EBITDA profitability by Q4 2023.”

Financial Outlook

AUTO1 Group increases its revenue guidance from EUR 5.7 to 6.8 billion to a range between EUR 6.0 and 7.0 billion. The gross profit range of EUR 470-580 million with an adjusted EBITDA margin between -2.0% and -3.0% remain unchanged.

AUTO1 Group - Key Figures:

Q2 2021 Q2 2022 Change Q2 YoY
Group KPIs
Units Sold (#) 142,715 166,147 16.4%
Revenue (in million EUR) 1,065.1 1,737.2 63.1%
Gross profit (in million EUR) 99.3 126.4 27.3%
GPU (EUR) 696 761 9.4%
Merchant KPIs
Units Sold (#) 134,300 150,377 12.0%
Revenue (in million EUR) 951.0 1,467.3 54.3%
Gross profit (in million EUR) 96.2 110.1 14.4%
GPU (EUR) 717 732 2.2%
Retail KPIs
Units Sold (#) 8,415 15,770 87.4%
Revenue (in million EUR) 114.1 269.9 136.5%
Gross profit (in million EUR) 3.1 16.3 434.4%
GPU (EUR) 363 1035.0 185.4%

The Group’s comprehensive 2022 Q2 financial results can be found in the company’s quarterly results presentation in the Investor Relations section of the AUTO1 Group homepage. The H1 2022 financial report will be published on 13 September.

3 Likes

Positive report. Despite a challenging market, the full-year revenue guidance was slightly raised, and the GPU (gross profit per unit/car) target was achieved ahead of schedule.

2 Likes