Suomen Hoivatilat as an investment

Lampen makes some pretty good points in themselves, and you’re right, those euros would best go towards growth. However, Hoivatilat has had large rights issues before, into which institutions have poured millions. They have different rules about what they can invest in, and for some, cash flow may be a requirement when choosing investment targets. It’s also better for Hoivatilat that they were able to spin off directed issues at a lower price.

1 Like

A fairly reasonable H1, strong growth seems to continue, thus having a slightly negative impact on profitability.

An interesting excerpt from the morning report. It remains to be seen whether the positive trend in NAV growth will affect Inderes’ target price tomorrow…

The company’s project pipeline continued to grow, and at the end of the period, the company had projects valued at EUR 126 million (Q1’18: EUR 103 million) based on acquisition cost. With these projects, the company’s growth prospects for 2018-2019 appear to be very good already.

Edit: According to Karjula, 11 daycare and care homes have been completed since the H1 review period.

Edit2: According to Karjula, “in the near future, we will be able to announce the first school projects”.

Edit3: 18 sites were completed during the review period, and the resulting increase in volume will be seen in H2.

1 Like

Inderes’ Q&A provides an answer to the interest rate question regarding Hoivatilat: Korkojen nousun ja pitkien vuokrasopimuksien vaikutus Suomen Hoivatiloihin - Inderes

2 Likes

This stock has probably stayed put for a year even though good news has been pouring in all year. Would now be the time to start rising? At least the company has implemented its own strategy without any setbacks, so one would think it will break through when the time comes.. It’s good to stay on this ride. :slight_smile:

1 Like

There’s a good reason it’s staying put, as the results are largely based on the accounting appreciation of properties rather than cash flows. This is practically doing the same thing Orava did back in the day. Of course, this business operates on a slightly more stable and sensible foundation, and added value is gained through more than just recording higher property values.

If substantial growth stops, then this will be expensive. Also, one cannot grow endlessly in this industry.

1 Like

It’s wrong to compare Hoivatilat to Orava. I also thought so before, but I read this Inderes answer, and it changed my mind. Hoivatilat vs. Orava - Inderes explains quite well why Hoivatilat’s valuations are more credible than Orava’s. An external appraiser and newer properties that it builds itself.

EDIT: But yeah, they do have a lot in common. However, Hoivatilat’s growth is more stable, and now they are even going to Sweden to seek more growth. In my opinion, this strategy is still a valid investment.

4 Likes

“Hoivatilat’s (Care Facilities) real estate portfolio was valued at the end of last year with a net yield requirement of 6.5%. At the beginning of this year, care property transactions in the market for properties similar to Hoivatilat’s have been made with a yield requirement of approximately 5.3%, which means that Hoivatilat’s properties should be valued about 23% higher than what the company itself reports.”

Based on this, Inderes sees value precisely in valuing properties higher. If we assume that Hoivatilat does not actively trade its properties, then this is completely the wrong approach in the long run. The most sensible way would be to think specifically about cash flows and rental income. If the yield requirement is lowered and the value of properties is written up, it means an increase in profits, but turnover and cash flows still stagnate. If you are not selling the properties, it is completely irrelevant whether you get a 6% return on a 100 euro property or if the yield requirement is lowered to 3 percent and the value is recorded at 200 euros.

If an increase in the value of properties is seen through a decrease in the yield requirement, it still only means that the returns on new properties will be significantly lower than before. This is not a good thing at all, even if the profits are made to look nicer. The cash flow from future properties will only be weaker.

4 Likes

Asset prices are based on yield requirements, meaning that as the yield requirement decreases, the market price rises, and as the yield requirement increases, it falls. To my knowledge, lease agreements are not made based on a percentage derived from the property’s market price, but rather are market-based. In small towns, residential apartment rental yield percentages are higher than in large cities. This is because the market perceives owning an apartment in a small town as risky, with the population concentrating in growth centers.

1 Like

You bought a bond 10 years ago, which was worth one hundred at the time. It yielded 10 percent. Interest rates dropped because the ECB bought everything it could get its hands on from the market like crazy. 5 years ago, you could have gotten 120 if you had sold it, but when the coupon expires, you still only get what you invested, which is one hundred. Doesn’t the same apply to Hoivatilat? Anyone can build a shack next to it for one hundred, because this is not about the center of Turku or Utsjoki, but about the yield, which has dropped because competition has intensified over the years. When the coupon/rental deal expires, the lease agreement must be renewed, but this time at a lower price, or metaphorically, the bond must be renewed with a significantly lower yield.

Now you’re mixing apples and oranges. A bond has a nominal value and a market price. The nominal value is based on the agreement for debt repayment. The market value, on the other hand, is what investors are willing to pay for that particular paper. Real estate only has a market price. The yield percentage is a ratio obtained by dividing the expected return by the market price. In the case of a bond, the coupon interest is the interest paid by the debtor divided by the nominal value of the bond. The market interest rate is the interest yield of the bond divided by the market price of the bond.

In the case of care facilities, the required return decreases because there are large amounts of money in the market looking for investment targets due to the ECB’s bond purchase program and the zero policy rate. In other words, people are willing to pay a higher price for almost any yielding asset. You could probably build a competing care facility next door, but the value of plots and the prices of construction companies are what they are.

Yes, they are.

New lease agreements are made at market price. After this, the property’s value is determined by the yield requirement. If the yield requirement is q and the rent received is A, then the property is valued at A/q. So the yield requirement gives the property a value, but it does not determine the rent. The property’s value changes if the yield requirement or rent changes, and the property’s value depends on these two components.

See the previous answer. So the property’s value does not change if the yield requirement remains the same and the rent remains the same. A new lease agreement is made with a worse yield requirement than the previous one, but the rent and value remain the same. In this case, there is no need to write down the value, but that value was already adjusted to match the new lease agreement when the yield requirement was previously lowered to 5 percent.

1 Like

I’m sorry if I’ve expressed myself a bit unclearly, but at least we’ll get a bit more discussion on this forum, as it’s quite quiet here. :sleeping: We need disagreements to get some action going. :crazy_face:

The fair values of completed investment properties mostly increased due to a decrease in market yield requirements. - Hoivatilat semi-annual review

This is excel money, you know… I am, therefore, worried that this excel money will start to drain from the balance sheet as lease agreements expire. These companies can’t necessarily be sold at the price at which their values have been increased, especially if lease prices are decreasing and there are only, say, 2 years left on the lease. A 100K asset increased to 200K is no longer worth 200K, because anyone can now build at least a 150K care facility, no matter how clumsy they are, and the tenant will move there if the rent isn’t dropped, which reverses the yield requirement. So, will this excel money then be removed from the balance sheet? The balance sheet currently has quite a lot of this yield requirement excel money.

According to Inderes’ forecasts, EPRA, which is the real money that the business generates (OravaVaara, however, puts renovation costs on the balance sheet and fudges a bit, but more on that later), and not excel money, would be 12.5 million euros in 2020, and the market value is currently 205 million. The real returns would therefore be only 6% of the market value, and thus very modest, as not much value can be given to those concrete elements, especially if they are pumped full of yield requirements.

For Technopolis, in contrast, EPRA is forecast to be 88 million in 2020, and the market value is currently 621 million, which means a return of over 14%, so these valuations seem a bit questionable.

I don’t think these “yield requirement”\excel-money fairy tales can turn all water into wine.

The question is, therefore, when will the air start to leak out of Hoivatilat?

My average price for Hoivatilat is 3.54 euros, so I’m not terribly worried about my own shares, but this yield requirement abracadabra business does puzzle me a bit, as it only lasts until the end of the lease agreement, unless the tenant is foolish, and I don’t believe that for companies like Attendo and others.

1 Like

You’re assuming things a bit too directly. You can’t build a comparable property for 150k, because you can’t build it from scratch. For example, land and construction costs are rising so much that a new, similar property will have roughly the same value as it does on Hoivatilat’s balance sheet. Of course, there might be exceptions, and Hoivatilat might get excess returns with certain contracts, but on average, they are market-priced. Additionally, the demand for care properties is so strong that rents are unlikely to start falling.

The problem, therefore, arises if yield requirements are raised again. For example, if interest rates rose to five percent, the values of care properties would collapse. The change in the yield requirement is the biggest concern.

As I’ve noted before, rental income and cash flows are the most essential things, because property values can fluctuate strongly, but rental income is quite stable and growing.

One more addition: If a similar property to Hoivatilat’s can be built for 150k on the market, then it is also 150k on Hoivatilat’s balance sheet, because Hoivatilat’s property valuation is based on the market’s yield requirement.

3 Likes

You are absolutely right in your views. The company’s strategy does not currently include real estate sales, but I do not consider it impossible that they could come in the coming years. The company has also sold its properties during its history, most recently in 2015. Sales could theoretically be sensible if the company could accelerate its development business and achieve a higher return on capital through them. Sales would have at least two positive aspects. Firstly, the care property market is currently liquid, and the company could probably sell, for example, a real estate portfolio of EUR 50 million with a typical “portfolio premium” in the industry (in the industry, you get a higher price if you sell a large number of properties in a bundle, which differs from, for example, the housing market). In this case, it could achieve a significant sales profit, even over 20%, in relation to its current balance sheet value. I also believe that the markets would then realize that Hoivatilat’s real estate portfolio is priced very conservatively, and this could be reflected positively in the share value. In addition, in our forecast, the company needs more capital from 2020 onwards if it wants to maintain its current growth rate. By selling part of its portfolio, the company would not have to make a share issue, and dilution fears for the stock might disappear. Overall, sales could very well increase shareholder value, even if transaction costs and taxes would have to be paid.

8 Likes

{“content”:“Technopolist fellow travelers: What do fellow travelers and analyst @Jesse_Kinnunen think, how potential a buy are Hoivatilat at its current valuation / considering its growth story stage?”,“target_locale”:“en”}

3 Likes

That kind of speculation is pretty pointless. There’s no meaningful way to assess it, and you shouldn’t give it any weight when evaluating the soundness of an investment.

1 Like

This is difficult to estimate precisely in advance. Hoivatilat is not a pure real estate investment company, but rather a developer and real estate developer. The real estate investment market is red-hot in Finland right now, and in my opinion, this has been the most important driver behind Sponda’s and Technopolis’ acquisition offers. Hoivatilat’s properties would, in my opinion, certainly all sell immediately to, for example, care property funds, but would someone be willing to pay extra for all of Hoivatilat instead of just the properties? Hoivatilat’s EPRA NAV per share, which is the valuation level at which Technopolis’ offer was made and which is therefore the value of only the company’s properties, is 7.9 euros in our forecast for 2019. At the time of writing, Hoivatilat’s share is exactly at this level of 7.9 euros. I don’t directly believe that most of Hoivatilat’s owners would be willing to sell their shares at this value of just the properties; a higher valuation level would be needed. For example, I consider Citycon a more potential acquisition target. I agree with the previous commentator that it is not necessarily worth giving great value to the acquisition option when considering investment targets, because there is so much uncertainty associated with the realization of an acquisition. Generally, a good investment target is also a good acquisition target, and investors should focus on evaluating the fundamentals and inherent rationality of the investment target itself.

11 Likes

BOOM https://www.inderes.fi/fi/tiedotteet/suomen-hoivatilat-oyj-hoivatilat-myy-kiinteistojaan-ja-tasmentaa-tilikautta-2018-koskevaa

7 Likes

Upcoming SRV (Finnish construction company) and the stock price will halve soon :smiley:

Hoivatilat (Finnish real estate company) has completely new potential if they start selling properties in this market situation. However, this seems to remain an isolated case, so this will only slightly push the stock price up :smiley:

"This was, in my opinion, a rather strange choice for the TOP3 list. I don’t see any catalyst within a few months that would resolve the undervaluation (if one even perceives such an undervaluation). The company delivered results that met expectations, or even slightly fell short. When looking at the bigger picture, it has a fairly precise path outlined, for example, regarding the rather rapid development of its NAV per share. So, if it doesn’t deviate significantly from this path, shouldn’t one assume that the market is already pricing in all this observed and future “certain” development? As it has seemed to do for a longer time. No earnings surprise, so no long-term share price reaction either.

So what is the driver for the share price now, especially when this inclusion doesn’t counter any overblown downward reaction, and these real estate companies often tend to “be forgotten” and their share prices droop between earnings releases. Betting on the announcement of school projects or a bearish view on the rest of the stock market are the few reasons that come to mind. On the other hand, it might be that there wasn’t a better option for the list. Who will experience an “aha!” moment regarding Hoivatilat in the coming months without any clear trigger?"

5 Likes