Has anyone considered creating Seligson’s Global 25 Top Brands fund yourself by picking the stocks and mimicking the strategy one-to-one? Well, I have.
Withholding taxes:
- Finland has tax treaties, but many countries do not follow them. If a country does not follow the treaty and instead charges too much in withholding tax, Nordnet or the tax authorities do not automatically account for them; instead, the customer must apply for them personally. Otherwise, they end up first paying too much withholding tax to the source country and then more to the Finnish tax authorities. Below is an example of this regarding Switzerland.
– Matti Meikäläinen (John Doe) lives in Finland and is a taxpayer in Finland. Matti holds shares in the Swiss company Nestlé S.A. In 2014, Nestlé pays Matti a gross dividend of 100 euros. Exceptionally, 35 euros (35%) in Swiss withholding tax is withheld from the dividend paid to Matti. In Finland, 15.5 euros is added to Matti’s taxable capital income from the Nestlé S.A. dividend, because 100 euros * (25.5 – 10)% = 15.5 euros. Of the tax payable on dividend income, the Finnish tax authorities do not credit the 35%, but only the 10% specified in the tax treaty. Matti therefore has to pay 35 euros first to Switzerland and another 15.5 euros to Finland, so the total tax on a 100 euro dividend is 50.5 euros. - France charges 25% according to my sources. I double-checked it from two different websites. In my opinion, the 15% taxation of “portfolio dividends” in the new 2023 tax treaty does not apply to the direct holdings of a private investor. The fund receives French dividends with exactly 0% tax because investment funds in France receive dividends tax-free, and according to EU law, other EU area funds must then be treated the same way. The French state began to follow the law after the matter was brought to court via a class action lawsuit and won.
- Sweden charges 15% and thus follows the treaty. However, the fund receives Swedish dividends with 0% tax, but a small-scale investor has to pay.
- The USA charges 15% and follows the treaty. The Brands fund and the private investor have the same treatment here.
- Italy charges 27% and a private investor cannot easily get back the extra 13% charged, but the Brands fund does, albeit after years of struggle.
- Germany charges 26.5%, but you can get it back to the 15% specified in the tax treaty by applying for it yourself. But do you really, as a private investor, have the energy to apply for withholding taxes from every country? It’s a terrible bureaucratic process. It probably doesn’t even work digitally; instead, applications and evidence must be sent on paper to several countries.
- In the UK, the fund and the private investor are on equal footing; both pay 0% withholding tax.
- To clarify further, if a country does not follow the tax treaty, the Finnish tax authorities will. For example: the USA follows it and only charges 15%, in which case the Finnish tax authorities charge the rest so that the total dividend tax of 25.5-28% (or whatever it exactly is) is fulfilled. If a country does not follow the treaty—e.g., Switzerland, Germany, France, and surely many others—you first pay up to a third of the dividend in tax to a foreign country and then the portion according to the tax treaty to Finland.
Investment account type and capital gains taxes
- In a standard book-entry account (arvo-osuustili), withholding taxes exceeding the Finnish dividend tax percentage are recognized and credited in domestic taxation when the country in question follows the tax treaty, such as the USA or Sweden. However, for shares purchased for an equity savings account (osakesäästötili) or investment insurance (sijoitusvakuutus), withholding tax is not credited accordingly.
- An equity savings account customer can apply for over-withheld taxes back from the company’s home country, but this remains the investor’s own responsibility. Reimbursed withholding taxes are also taxed as yield when withdrawn from the equity savings account, meaning capital gains tax is charged on them.
- In investment insurance, over-withheld taxes on foreign shares cannot be reclaimed.
- If you want to follow Seligson’s rebalancing strategy, capital gains from sales will be generated in a book-entry account (AOT), which increases costs and hits the compound interest effect. Every euro lost to taxation loses yield over decades of accumulation. With an equity savings account (OST) or insurance, you can trade tax-free, but you take a hit with withholding taxes. In insurance, there is additionally a management fee for the investment insurance, which is 0.35% up to 100,000 euros. For the portion exceeding that, the management fee is 0.15%, and the OST has a maximum limit. The cost benefits of stock picking compared to the fund are further diluted.
Other observations:
- I also note that it might not even be possible to buy all the fund’s stocks from Nordnet, at least not directly from the exchange yourself. Perhaps by calling a broker? Furthermore, as the fund contains USD, EUR, SEK, GBP, and CHF currencies, a larger amount of money will certainly be spent on currency conversions at Nordnet than what Seligson itself pays for currency conversions. In a book-entry account (AOT) at Nordnet, you can get a small discount if you use currency accounts, but in an equity savings account (OST) and insurance contract, it seems to be 0.25% for every purchase.
Conclusions:
- Taking the above points into account, I have calculated that by investing directly in Brands’ stocks yourself, the total costs are higher than by investing in the fund.*
- As a result of all this calculation, picking Brands stocks directly is not sensible, even if you were an iron-willed robot who does not succumb, for example, to leaving out firms you consider bad from the strategy and can mimic the fund year after year without, for instance, starting to pick something else “nice” from outside the fund.
** I will break down the total cost calculations here **
Stock picker’s costs:
- Brands’ dividend yield (2.5%) * dividend tax rate (25.5%) = 0.6375%. (Note! Calculated with the lowest dividend tax rate; if you receive large dividends, the rate is 28.9%, making the cost 0.7225%.)
- If the investor does not reclaim OVERPAID withholding taxes from all of Brands’ countries, but Brands does, it results in an additional cost of 0.194% for the small investor. To get this figure, I first determined what percentage of Brands is currently in which country’s stocks, then determined the average dividend yield of each of those countries’ stocks over the last few years, and then calculated the share of the over-withheld amount compared to total assets.
- Then there is a 0.08% transaction cost, but without private banking, it is much more. At level 4, it is 0.25% in Sweden, 0.30% in England, 0.30% in the USA, and 0.30% in Germany. For Switzerland and Italy, I cannot find the cost because Nordnet does not offer them. However, I use a 0.08% cost, assuming the investor is at the private banking level and uses Nordnet specifically as their broker.
- Then slippage, i.e., the difference between the buy and sell price, should also be added. However, I will ignore it.
- Currency exchange fee. I generously use a 0.075% fee as the currency exchange cost if a currency account is active. Otherwise, it is 0.25%.
- I do not calculate capital gains taxes from sales profits.
- I do not take into account interest tax credits for investment loans.
---->>> Individual investor’s costs at minimum: 0.6375 + 0.194 + 0.08 + 0.075 = 0.9865%.
Brands’ costs:
- Brands’ dividend yield (2.5%) * dividend tax rate (15%) = 0.375%. Brands receives Swedish and French dividends tax-free. Together, their share of the portfolio is 15%. Thus, the previously calculated withholding tax percentage can be reduced to 0.375% * 0.85 = 0.31875%.
- Management fee 0.59%
- Transaction costs 0.04%
---->>> Brands’ total costs: 0.31875 + 0.59% + 0.04% = 0.94875%.
Brands therefore ends up being cheaper despite its high management fee than managing individual stocks. Additionally, it is very easy to perform monthly saving, as each monthly savings amount is distributed for free among 25 companies. With Seligson, you can also sell the investment lots with the least profit first during retirement. In Nordnet, of course, you can too, if you set up multiple book-entry accounts (AOT).