With dividends or without? Dividend thread

This is a pretty poor list as several are missing.

chars chars

1 Like

Now comes such a fundamental amateur reflection, but I dare to think of this as text.

Has anyone considered or already tried to profit specifically from dividend dip fluctuations? Statistically, dividend dips are closed within 3 months.

What if one were to broadly buy dividend payers “appropriately” before prices might have risen in a dividend frenzy, and then more during the dividend dip? Selling these after the assumed 3 months, or when the price has corrected sufficiently. One would get the dividend amount from the company’s cash and a price increase from the dip purchase. Nothing is certain, of course, but with broad diversification (e.g., 20 lines) and based on assumed stable industries, the risk would be reasonable.

This also doesn’t heavily consider the absolute cheapness or expensiveness of prices when exploiting a local fluctuation. The problem would likely be at least the costs, which double compared to holding.

What causes the total sum of upcoming dividends in Nordnet’s dividend section to fluctuate? If I check it one day, around 16k in dividends are expected in 2026, on another day over 19k, but then the total sum can drop again? Currency exchange rate fluctuations shouldn’t affect it that much, I think.

I’m not sure, but could it be that the same dividend is shown for a while in both upcoming and received dividends (and then removed)? Currencies probably add their own little twist to that.

1 Like

This has been the case, for example, with Terveystalo today. The crediting of Aktia’s dividends took a really long time again.

Yes, that seems to be the case
 it disappears from future dividends only the next day


Follow-up question: Apparently, not all dividends to be paid by companies this year are included in Nordnet’s dividend calculation, as I didn’t notice Posti’s dividend in the upcoming dividends. Maybe information is missing from some others too??

M. Right, the dividend to be paid has probably not yet been finally approved at the meeting


In this thread, we are supposed to argue about whether chasing dividends makes any sense at all (it doesn’t). A better thread for selecting dividend stocks is probably this one:

5 Likes

I probably don’t understand the question. If a strategy is based on management always distributing profits in way A even though they could also distribute them in way B at any time, then the strategy is naturally flawed. But in this case, I still don’t quite understand: if you hoped for dividends and instead get share buybacks, which are more tax-efficient, this is only a good thing. In other words: if Orion buys back its own shares at too high a price, we just sell an amount equivalent to the buybacks, get our dividends, and paid fewer taxes. Otherwise, we’re in the same situation.

(And once again, the usual disclaimers about fees and fractional shares that could tip this one way or another, which I don’t feel like discussing right now either. Everyone can apply them to their own situation using their broker’s information. This applies to all the messages I write here.)

4 Likes

A peculiar suggestion for a buy and hold strategy, which was the exact starting point of my question in the Orion thread.

Well, I’m not going to argue about this here; I just wanted to shed some light in that other thread to show that conclusions aren’t the same for all strategies. The day the buyback party realizes they will never actually get their hands on those “higher” returns seems like it will never come.

Signed, a forever holder who got their money out of Orion long ago with net dividends, using one-time trading fees

1 Like

I mean that to me, that’s kind of a similar problem to having a strategy where you only buy companies whose names start with the letter R. That is, the strategy is flawed, not how the company chose its name (or how it distributes its profits).

And combined with this profit distribution: if you want those dividends, and once or twice in 30 years a situation happens where that dividend company does buybacks and considers the price clearly too high, nothing needs to change even if you “have” to sell some of them, while getting that tax advantage.

So I feel like people are manufacturing a problem here.

But the original question was what thoughts there are if the share price feels too high. The answer to that is therefore: “sell, if the share price feels too high (taking the tax impact into consideration).” The company doesn’t need to worry about that.

5 Likes

Surprisingly strong results have, however, popped up in my portfolio from some quirk of fate with that strategy you consider wrong. I would have gotten even more if more shares had left the market for the same amount of money. By the way, I didn’t ask or say anything about dividends, which you brought into the mix on your own initiative, but rather about share buybacks at a certain price.

My follow-up question was, what if you aren’t selling anything at all? Does the price at which buybacks are executed still not matter?

And before you suggest selling as a remedy for the third time, since we are not selling.

And as a final remark: My entire point was that your comment/suggestion about selling doesn’t look the same to everyone, since strategies vary. One person has huge theoretical fairytale gains, while another has only solid, concrete gains.

1 Like

\n[quote="Qwerty123, post:903, topic:353"]\nAnyway, I didn’t ask or talk about dividends at all\n\n[/quote]\n\nWell, in your first message in the Orion thread, you talked about dividends. But maybe I misunderstood something. Or did you mean that you want to buy a stock that never distributes profits in any way? Doesn’t pay dividends, and doesn’t buy back its own shares? And Orion would be an example of this? Well, then jokes are in short supply. In that case, the same rule otherwise applies: if a company wastes its money, the investor sells. So still, not selling is just a bad strategy that is worth changing. Or choosing companies for your portfolio that don’t distribute their profits.\n\n[quote="Qwerty123, post:903, topic:353"]\nMy follow-up question was, what if you are not selling anything at all?\n\n[/quote]\n\nTo this, I believe I already answered quite clearly:\n\nIf you set bad conditions for yourself in investing, that’s entirely your own fault, not the company’s or management’s. So if you set a condition for yourself to only buy companies whose names start with the letter R, it is not the fault of a company whose name starts with the letter K.

3 Likes

Well, you misunderstood to some extent. Of course, the ultimate root cause for my position is the dividends, but this was solely about share buybacks as a way of distributing profits in that specific case. Don’t mix dividends into this, there’s no need for that. Think of it as there being a reason why the stock is not being sold. So, are you still of the opinion that when you’re not selling the stock, the price at which the buyback is made doesn’t matter? This and only this is the point.

Please, however, leave out that condescendingly served “R-word” babble. It was already in two messages, so I have to ask. It’s unnecessarily uncultured.

Whoa, European Championship bronze!!! Go Finland! :))))

1 Like

[quote="Qwerty123, post:903, topic:353"]\nMy follow-up question was, what if you are not selling anything at all?\n[/quote]\n\nThen you don’t get cash as a profit distribution from the share buyback, but your ownership stake increases, meaning you own a larger relative slice of the company.\n\nIf you want cash from a company whose only form of profit distribution is share buybacks, you have to sell shares. If you sell in the same proportion as what the company buys, your relative ownership stake in the company remains unchanged and you get cash. If you sell in a smaller proportion, you get cash and your relative ownership increases, but not as much as in the scenario where you wouldn’t sell at all.\n\nLet’s take an example familiar to many: Nordea. Over a period of a good 5 years, the bank has bought back and cancelled about 15% of all its shares, meaning that if you have owned the same amount of Nordea shares since, say, 2020, you now own a 15% larger slice of the company even if you haven’t bought more.\n\nTo reiterate regarding Orion’s program, it is management remuneration and not a profit distribution. In due course, new shares will likely be distributed to the management, and the shares bought now will be cancelled accordingly, so the apparent purpose is just to offset the dilutive effect of share-based incentives.

7 Likes

All of this is true, yes. However, you left out the impact of the purchase price that is being discussed here. We were mostly going through what significance share buybacks have on a general level.

The Nordea example works too. Let’s exaggerate a bit to bring out the theory. Same amount of money spent, shares bought at half the price. The ownership stake would have grown by 30% instead of 15%, right? Why wouldn’t this matter? And no, shares weren’t available at this price, but the point is to demonstrate the significance of the price.

If the reward is a specific number of shares, then it is quite clear that the purchase price matters. If the reward is a specific sum of money, then the purchase price does not matter.

I repeat: if you have a stupid strategy or if you invent artificial limitations for yourself, that is not the company’s problem. This shouldn’t be so difficult.

4 Likes

I think it has already been gone through quite a few times in this thread that it is by no means a stupid strategy.

This answer to a clear question is quite sufficient as a reply. In your opinion, buying back shares at a high price is the problem of the owner, not the company. This is precisely what I meant myself, that the company is acting wrongly. The matter is clear. Thank you.

1 Like

[quote=“Qwerty123, post:909, topic:353”]
I suppose it has already been discussed quite a few times in this thread that it is by no means a stupid strategy.

[/quote>

Preventing oneself from selling when it makes sense is, of course, a stupid strategy. Much like only buying stocks that start with the letter R. Or trading only during a full moon. Such things hardly apply to about 99.999% of investors.

4 Likes

Well, there came the R-word since nothing else came up. Good job and thanks for respecting my request. Indeed, those buy and hold investors probably make up only about 1 per mille of all investors. :winking_face_with_tongue:

By the way, could you also tell us, just as an example, which stocks you’ve managed when your purchases were too expensive by selling them, at what price, and did you perhaps buy them back later? And give us a couple of examples of when you didn’t sell even though your purchases were at too high a price, explaining why you didn’t sell even though, according to your words, that would be the only correct course of action
 or do you think all your purchases have always been at the right price? I’m terribly curious to know how you manage to pull this off in practice in such an optimal way. I can also share that I have never sold a single security I own for that reason.

Oh, and in the future, please let us incompetent members of the per mille club know when you think it’s time to sell. That way we won’t waste money with our incompetence.

3 Likes