With dividends or without? Dividend thread

Apologies for the repetition:

“I understand you are talking about profit distribution based on the values at the time of distribution, but please note that I am not arguing against share buybacks as a tool, but rather commenting on a good method’s sensitivity to prices at the time of purchase.”

If we boldly assume that it is better to buy shares cheap rather than expensive, then when a company delivers weak results, it would make sense to stop dividend payments entirely and use the full distribution capacity for buybacks. One would get the most shares at a low price, and those divesting their ownership would face minimal tax consequences.

Dividends could be paid during a peak in the cycle, where generating one’s own dividends by selling is not very tax-efficient for short-term owners, and the owner would be left with the responsibility of finding something to buy in an expensive market or waiting for a better offer.

4 Likes

I asked what the logic is behind the claim “the timing of the dividend payment is less significant than the timing of new purchases,” not whether you are arguing against buybacks or not.

When you speak of the “timing of new purchases,” I assume you are talking about the reinvestment strategy of the profit distribution received by the investor. That is, that the dividend (or creating one’s own dividends in connection with share buybacks performed by the company) is fine to receive at any time, but the investment decision made by the investor is better done over time, e.g., after a crash in the share value.

I agree with that. I would just like to point out that the investor’s investments are a different matter than the company’s profit distribution, and the effectiveness of the profit distribution does not depend on the investor’s actions or inactions.

But then you wrote the above, where the idea surfaced again that dividend payment is better than buybacks when the stock is expensive. Why?

Try to explain your thinking with a calculation example, for instance, because verbal explanations don’t seem to be leading anywhere.

I don’t doubt that factors other than theory also affect the matter. Such as if the stock is grossly overvalued, after the buybacks it might have time to drop so much that the investor does not have time to create their own dividends by selling the stock in the same proportion as the company performed its buybacks. But thinking intuitively, even in that case, the return on the dividend distribution would likely remain roughly the same, because the stock would also shed its overvaluation during a dividend distribution, and the value of the investor’s assets (share value plus bank account) is equally lower.

3 Likes

And for every such case, there is an identical scenario where a shareholder doesn’t have time to buy shares after a dividend payout before the price takes off. In those cases, the board isn’t blamed for a faulty distribution method.

On average, share buybacks are always more cost-effective due to the tax advantage. And since in many cases investors want to increase their ownership stake in the companies they own, the difference grows even larger when commissions are avoided. In my opinion, the default for profit distribution should definitely be buybacks or an emphasis on them—not dividends.

My portfolio would be significantly more valuable than it is now if the companies I own had done this for years. I would argue that this applies to almost all investors writing here. Because of dividends, every one of us loses money to the state.

And soon enough, someone else will chime in with “but what about Nokia!”.

7 Likes

The proposed model actually tries to avoid this by suggesting that buybacks are made when the price is low (to the detriment of the sellers, btw, if the undervaluation of the share is known) and dividends are distributed when the price is high. Of course, as you described, it puts those who would rather see their ownership stake increase following buybacks rather than keep the dividend in their account at a slight risk. It wouldn’t be the first time if mispricing doesn’t resolve itself (Handelsbanken A and B series, hello).

What irks me is that the justification for the matter is being left for the opposing party to figure out. It’s not my job to prove the other party’s claims. Even though I ended up calculating the impact of the time difference between the company’s share buybacks and the investor creating their own dividends — which is inherently an incomparable situation because two different scenarios are being created.

At the very least, share buybacks carry no tax disadvantage regardless of how they are managed. There is no ambiguity about this. I, for one, am not against buybacks as a method; rather, I am speaking about their suboptimal implementation.

The rationale for buybacks is the owner’s tax optimization, but that optimization is carried out by buying the most when the owner would face the largest tax consequences from capital gains. Tax optimization slows down or ceases entirely at the moment when the owner’s tax benefit would be at its peak.

As those who have read the thread already know from the previously presented graphs.

This is always a good principle. I already read the entire thread last autumn when I pointed out which arguments—suspected at the time of being groundlessly recycled—were actually new and previously unaddressed. I haven’t noticed any such arguments now, so your point is well-taken.

I am not “on the side” of buybacks or dividends; instead, I aim to buy companies capable of stable or, preferably, growing profit distribution from at least stable or, preferably, trend-like growing EPS (note! not just their net income!).

I find the clearly communicated profit distribution of Nordea and Sampo, consisting of both buybacks and dividends, to be very good, and both hold a large weight in my portfolio. Nordea has already grown into an overweight position as I haven’t brought myself to sell the position I started buying above five euros. I am keeping it, not just because of the outlook, but also because global diversification through passive funds and my wife’s portfolios keep my Nordea exposure acceptable for the family, even if 20% of a single portfolio would be some sort of alarm threshold.

Hopefully this is clear now?


Although I also see buybacks as a good thing for an owner who prefers to receive a stable dividend income, I see a clear optimization error in the average execution of buybacks, where the average price of the buybacks ends up as high as possible due to market timing.

Harshly put, but that’s what happens today.

It is, of course, a good argument to say that companies have the most money for profit distribution during a boom, especially when it peaks. That is quite true, but why is it that only the buyback policy follows the decrease in funds during a downturn, while the dividend policy does not?

Does no one else see a contradiction here?

Despite my sharp language above, I also see this counterweight to timing. If profit is not distributed or at least not used for share purchases as it accumulates, then money must be hoarded either in the company’s or the owner’s account. That money has an opportunity cost, and in the company’s coffers, it weakens earnings-per-share metrics.

Is there any real reason why buybacks must be concentrated at price peaks and cannot be done more steadily over time like dividends? That way, you wouldn’t get a timing gain, but you would at least avoid the timing loss that is currently being made.

And it wouldn’t be the first time that mispricing resolves itself multiple times a year (Kesko’s A and B series, between which I managed to switch with a good arbitrage a couple of times last year). These are very easy situations for timing purchases for either the company or the owner, and the probability of success is good.

Guilty as charged. I can’t be bothered to calculate the euro-denominated or percentage impact of buyback strategies that I don’t have enough voting power to change. However, from the previously cited volumes of buybacks over the market cycle, the trend is extremely clear even without a calculator.

1 Like

A company could decide every year how much of the profit it wants to distribute to owners, and from this distribution, then allocate a certain fixed portion as share buybacks every year. Preferably at least 50% of the distribution as buybacks – REGARDLESS OF THE SHARE PRICE. And this distribution (buybacks vs. dividends), it could clearly state in its distribution policy. For example:

“We aim to distribute at least 60% of our earnings to owners. 70% of the distribution will be implemented as share buybacks and their cancellation, and 30% will be distributed as dividends.” This way, at least 42% of the earnings would go to buybacks, at least 18% to dividends, and the rest would remain with the company for other uses.

Some owners prefer dividends for good rational reasons, so as far as I’m concerned, some part of the distribution can be dividends.

Thanks to @Mirko_Sampo_IR for the brave participation in a sensitive discussion :sweat_smile: Perhaps my main message to Sampo is that not all retail investors really crave dividends as some “Ilkka Parviainens” might suggest. Some of us know how to calculate taxes and we appreciate that the company also acts in the interest of the retail investor in this sense. The more Sampo buys back its own shares, the more my ownership stake grows without tax implications and commissions. Without even having to click a mouse. And I can get my pocket money with lighter taxation if I need it.

That update to Sampo’s distribution policy is exactly what I have been longing for: a concrete “commitment” to the fact that a certain part of the distribution will be carried out as buybacks regardless of the market situation. I hope others follow suit.

11 Likes

There has been no ambiguity regarding your own investment strategy. Your expression of your perception regarding profit distribution and tax efficiency appears problematic. For example, you wrote this:

Without any other information, I read that as you saying: “Since creating home-made dividends by selling shares results in a maximum of 80% (i.e., the deemed acquisition cost) of the distribution being taxable income for those who do it, dividends could be paid instead of buybacks, in which case everyone is guaranteed to pay 85% of the distribution as taxable income.”

Do you see the problem? Otherwise, I can think of many valid reasons for the distribution model you presented, but not why only paid dividends vs. the tax efficiency of creating home-made dividends is mentioned in the same sentence.

By the way, what did you mean by “short owners”?

Probably many of us so-called professionals in accounting and finance. The problem is usually specifically with shareholders demanding dividends, who are happy to give the boot to managers who don’t pay dividends. There are even surveys on the subject where the top 3 answers for the reasons for choosing a distribution policy, or reasons for distributing profit at the expense of investments offering better ROE, revolve precisely around shareholder pressure.

I do. Thank you for the feedback. I regret even mentioning dividends in that post you quoted, as it presented an erroneous comparison.

My intention is to compare steady dividend distributions to share buybacks, which as a method is tax-efficient, but is used suboptimally by focusing on buying as expensively as possible during the market cycle.

Exactly! The percentages are the opposite of what you hoped for, but the principle is clear, and dividend-haters can sell a company guilty of suboptimal profit distribution from their portfolio after seeing the dividend policy in Sampo’s 2025 financial statement release:

“According to Sampo plc’s dividend policy, Sampo will pay a stable and sustainable base dividend that grows over time in line with the Group’s operating result. In addition, excess capital will be returned in the form of share buybacks and/or extra dividends to the extent that it is not used for business development. According to Sampo plc’s dividend policy applicable to the 2025 distribution, the total amount of dividends paid shall be at least 70 per cent of the Sampo Group’s operating result.”

Many things are right here:

  • profit distribution consists of dividends and share buybacks
  • the limits of the payout ratio are expressed
  • the entire distribution is proportional to business development
    (unlike in the thread title, which is still broken)

I think this Nordea alternative is also good. If executed skillfully, the share buyback portion in this distribution might be even more profitable for the shareholder if the part hinting at opportunistic share buybacks is timed well. I try to do that in my own portfolio, but as the person responsible for the company’s buybacks, I wouldn’t dare take a strong view; instead, I would buy systematically with a continuous profit distribution ratio between buybacks and dividends, just as you suggested:

Dividend policy
Nordea’s dividend policy stipulates a dividend payout ratio of
60–70%, applicable to profit for the financial year. Nordea will
continuously assess the opportunity to use share buy-backs
as a tool to distribute excess capital.

1 Like

The taxation of dividends is always heavier than that of share buybacks and the subsequent sales.

It also doesn’t matter to the company at what price it buys, as the company doesn’t gain anything from it since all shares are cancelled. All the money goes directly to the shareholders, regardless of the share price.

It is the responsibility of the shareholders to decide whether they want to sell or increase their ownership stake, and this is where the share price matters.

2 Likes

Please note that that is the old dividend policy, which was applied to the dividend distributed for 2025.

Updated profit distribution policy, valid from 2026 onwards :backhand_index_pointing_down:

Sampo aims to return capital in the form of a reliable and progressive regular dividend, supplemented by share buybacks. To ensure that the Group’s balance sheet remains strong and efficient in accordance with the capital management framework, Sampo may take actions to return excess capital or to secure the balance sheet.

Sampo estimates that in a typical year, it can return approximately 90 per cent of its operational result to shareholders in the form of dividends and share buybacks. The annual dividend is estimated to represent more than two-thirds of this.

13 Likes

Thanks to Mirko for the update! :+1:

I recalled that definition regarding the ratio of share buybacks and dividend distributions in relation to profit distribution, but I couldn’t find that latest version anymore when quickly scanning the sources.

I remain a Sampo shareholder and added during the “lemonade discount,” even though I don’t usually like to “buy the dividend,” i.e., buying the stock in the spring just before it goes ex-dividend. Buying from the dividend dip allows you to get it cheaper by the amount of the dividend tax, if the dip happens to be of the “right” depth.

3 Likes

Ok. That stood out so much from the rest of the text that I thought it couldn’t be true and that something was being misunderstood. All good :grin:

A steady dividend at least provides a sense of security, and I too am willling to pay for that, for example in the D-shares of real estate companies. It is worth the tax disadvantage.

1 Like

Now we are on the same page. The topic was discussed in September 2025, and CitizenJ made a good summary of how share buybacks are used for profit distribution in the United States, where buybacks aim for the highest possible average purchase price:

The basics of dividends and buybacks have been listed previously; both have their advantages, so I consider the combination of buybacks and dividends a good way to distribute profits.

Anyone comparing the implementation of these distribution methods will notice that dividends are better timed than buybacks, at least in the United States. Robert Shiller shows in Irrational Exuberance how dividend volatility is significantly lower than value volatility. Over the years, the owner ends up buying in all phases of the market cycle with their gradually increasing dividend amounts. Thus, dividends include an automatic DCA element even if the owner doesn’t time anything themselves. You won’t beat the market with this, but you won’t lose either.

Even though share buybacks are a tax-efficient method, the American implementation is inefficient because, without asking the owner’s permission, the purchase of shares slows down when they should be bought at least as much as at price peaks.

Protecting cash reserves when fear takes over customers and revenue declines is, of course, a sensible way to secure the company’s future, but it is not a sufficient justification for stopping buybacks when profit distribution is nonetheless continued as dividends at the same time.

In my opinion, the distribution policy communicated by the already mentioned Nordea and Sampo is also to the advantage of an owner who prefers to take their income as dividends compared to this poor precedent, because a clear buyback method adds value steadily and at a better price. Every canceled share increases EPS and dividend per share in the coming years.

5 Likes

Earlier in this thread, the impact of share buybacks and dividend distributions on the share price and number of shares has been calculated. Let’s do another illustrative calculation where the buybacks are made at a “high” price, and then the valuation level corrects to that of a typical Helsinki laggard (hesulimörnijä).

The total profit distribution in euros (buybacks vs. dividends) remains the same.

Year 1:

Number of shares: 10,000; share price: €30/share; and the market cap is therefore €300,000. The profit is €10,000, i.e., €1.00/share, so the P/E is 30. The entire profit is distributed. In this example, the investor owns 100 shares (valued at €3,000, representing 1% of the total shares). The dividend investor receives €100 (minus taxes) and reinvests the dividends, buying 3.448 shares at a price of €29. Since the investor reinvested the dividends, their ownership stake in the company increased and is now 103.448/10,000, or 1.03448%.

Situation after the dividend distribution: the investor owns 103.448 shares valued at €29; their market value is still €3,000.

In the share buyback scenario, the situation is as follows: The company buys back its own shares from the market for €10,000, purchasing 333.333 shares and canceling them. The investor does not sell their shares but keeps their original 100 units. The number of shares decreases and, after the cancellation, is 100/9,666.667 shares. The ownership stake in the company is thus 1.03448%.

Since cash left the balance sheet, the market cap in both cases after the distribution is €290,000. In the company performing buybacks, the price per share is higher than in the dividend distribution case. The price didn’t rise, but it ostensibly stayed the same because the number of shares decreased accordingly. In other words, there is no difference compared to the situation of whether a dividend was paid or shares were bought back.

The following year, the company has again made a profit of €10,000, but due to general “Helsinki-style stagnation” (hesuloituminen), the P/E is now only 10. Due to uncertain times, the company decides to distribute only half of the profit and keep the other half in the treasury as a buffer. The distribution is therefore €5,000.

In the dividend example, the total number of shares is still 10,000, the share price is now only €10/share, and the market cap is thus €100,000. The profit is €10,000, i.e., €1.00/share, so the P/E is 10. A dividend of €0.50 per share is paid, and our example investor receives €51.724. After the dividend dip, the share price is €9.50, and the investor buys 5.445 additional shares. The total number of shares is now 108.893, or 1.08893%. The market value of the investment is €1,034.48 (and after the dividend distribution, the total market cap is €95,000).

In the buyback example, the company’s market cap is also €100,000, divided into 9,666.667 shares, meaning the share price is €10.345/share.

The company buys €5,000 worth of shares from the market at a unit price of €10.345 and receives 483.334 shares, which it cancels. After the cancellation, the company has 9,183.332 shares, and the investor still owns 100 of them. The ownership stake in the company is 100 / 9,183.332, or 1.08893%. The company’s market cap is the same as the dividend-paying peer, i.e., €95,000.

The bottom line? Both buying back shares and distributing dividends led to the same result. Either could have spent the dividends (or sales proceeds) on Lidl cottage cheese, but in this example, they were kept invested in the company. If the dividends had been spent, the situation would no longer be comparable unless an equivalent amount of money was raised by selling shares.

In the dividend example, the share price fell from €30.00 → €9.50, and the investor also received dividends of €1.00 + €0.50/share, which were reinvested in the company. The value of the investment at the end is €1,034.48, or -65.52%. In the case of buybacks, the share price falls from €30.00 → €10.3448, the value of the investment is €1,034.48, and the loss is the same -65.52%.

2 Likes

Shouldn’t a disclaimer be added to that: “unless the company’s earnings drop. Reasons for falling earnings could include, for example, intensifying competition, a (drastic) change in circumstances, or compensation resulting from misconduct or toxic products. Examples include the Nokia case and the Bayer/Monsanto case (I don’t know how extensively Bayer bought back its own shares).”

I don’t think it’s necessary, because the cancelled shares increase the EPS compared to a situation without share buybacks and cancellations.

3 Likes

EPS (Earnings Per Share) is a key financial metric that tells you how much profit a company generates per share.

But what if profit drops by 90%? How many shares would need to be bought back for the EPS to rise?

Your point of comparison is still incorrect. Please re-read the message you replied to once more, thoughtfully.

However, you did bring up the balance between profit distribution and business investment, which is also what the thread title aims for.