Earlier in this thread, the impact of share buybacks and dividend distributions on the share price and number of shares has been calculated. Let’s do another illustrative calculation where the buybacks are made at a “high” price, and then the valuation level corrects to that of a typical Helsinki laggard (hesulimörnijä).
The total profit distribution in euros (buybacks vs. dividends) remains the same.
Year 1:
Number of shares: 10,000; share price: €30/share; and the market cap is therefore €300,000. The profit is €10,000, i.e., €1.00/share, so the P/E is 30. The entire profit is distributed. In this example, the investor owns 100 shares (valued at €3,000, representing 1% of the total shares). The dividend investor receives €100 (minus taxes) and reinvests the dividends, buying 3.448 shares at a price of €29. Since the investor reinvested the dividends, their ownership stake in the company increased and is now 103.448/10,000, or 1.03448%.
Situation after the dividend distribution: the investor owns 103.448 shares valued at €29; their market value is still €3,000.
In the share buyback scenario, the situation is as follows: The company buys back its own shares from the market for €10,000, purchasing 333.333 shares and canceling them. The investor does not sell their shares but keeps their original 100 units. The number of shares decreases and, after the cancellation, is 100/9,666.667 shares. The ownership stake in the company is thus 1.03448%.
Since cash left the balance sheet, the market cap in both cases after the distribution is €290,000. In the company performing buybacks, the price per share is higher than in the dividend distribution case. The price didn’t rise, but it ostensibly stayed the same because the number of shares decreased accordingly. In other words, there is no difference compared to the situation of whether a dividend was paid or shares were bought back.
The following year, the company has again made a profit of €10,000, but due to general “Helsinki-style stagnation” (hesuloituminen), the P/E is now only 10. Due to uncertain times, the company decides to distribute only half of the profit and keep the other half in the treasury as a buffer. The distribution is therefore €5,000.
In the dividend example, the total number of shares is still 10,000, the share price is now only €10/share, and the market cap is thus €100,000. The profit is €10,000, i.e., €1.00/share, so the P/E is 10. A dividend of €0.50 per share is paid, and our example investor receives €51.724. After the dividend dip, the share price is €9.50, and the investor buys 5.445 additional shares. The total number of shares is now 108.893, or 1.08893%. The market value of the investment is €1,034.48 (and after the dividend distribution, the total market cap is €95,000).
In the buyback example, the company’s market cap is also €100,000, divided into 9,666.667 shares, meaning the share price is €10.345/share.
The company buys €5,000 worth of shares from the market at a unit price of €10.345 and receives 483.334 shares, which it cancels. After the cancellation, the company has 9,183.332 shares, and the investor still owns 100 of them. The ownership stake in the company is 100 / 9,183.332, or 1.08893%. The company’s market cap is the same as the dividend-paying peer, i.e., €95,000.
The bottom line? Both buying back shares and distributing dividends led to the same result. Either could have spent the dividends (or sales proceeds) on Lidl cottage cheese, but in this example, they were kept invested in the company. If the dividends had been spent, the situation would no longer be comparable unless an equivalent amount of money was raised by selling shares.
In the dividend example, the share price fell from €30.00 → €9.50, and the investor also received dividends of €1.00 + €0.50/share, which were reinvested in the company. The value of the investment at the end is €1,034.48, or -65.52%. In the case of buybacks, the share price falls from €30.00 → €10.3448, the value of the investment is €1,034.48, and the loss is the same -65.52%.