Thank you for this message. I read through your entire text carefully and, even at the risk of some repetition, I subscribe to everything you said in this post.
The basics have already required so much explaining that I haven’t even dared to address in much depth why share buybacks usually slow down as stock prices decline. Protecting the company’s cash position by reducing profit distribution is a well-justified action when earnings collapse, but the way it is done in practice is suboptimal.
At least in the closely followed S&P, profit distribution as dividends continues almost as before, but buybacks slow down significantly exactly when even the most stubborn opponent of buybacks is forced by the facts to admit that it might be a quite clever time to buy more!
And that is exactly why the dividend policies communicated by Sampo and Nordea are a refreshing exception to prevailing practices, made by people who can do the math.