Tokmanni - House of Opportunities?

Kind’s dismissal is concerning. It would be good to get comments from Rautiainen at an appropriate time, one way or another, regarding the background of the disagreements.

I don’t remember how long Kind was the head of Dollarstore, but if he was a well-liked leader, other key personnel might also be on their way out now that the management is coming from the group.

6 Likes

My own understanding is that he was hired a few years before Dollarstore’s sale by the main owner specifically to get the company ready for sale and to bring the process to completion. I was a bit surprised by how little Dollarstore’s involvement was visible in the group’s background operations. Kind was only recently promoted to Tokmanni’s management team. Now that the matter has come to light, it would be crucial to find a replacement for him who genuinely knows the Swedish market and retail trade (perhaps a local?) expert.

Regarding differences in opinion and Tokmannisation, it has been noticeable. At CMD, Kind had a clear vision for Dollarstore’s concept remaining relatively similar or as it was when it was integrated into Tokmanni. Tokmanni’s management also emphasized this. Now, towards the end of 2024, I started noticing elements that have been seen in Tokmanni’s story. Clearance sales, increased advertising, an increase in the number of product items (Kind was strongly of the opinion that this would not happen), the implementation of Miny into Dollarstore, etc. Against this background, I am not surprised that differences in opinion have arisen. Dollarstore has enormous potential, and from Tokmanni’s perspective, I hope these things bear fruit in the future.

17 Likes

Kind started at Dollarstore in April 2023. Tokmanni bought Dollarstore in August 2023.

6 Likes

Hmmm… This is what Kind said at the CMD held in February 2024. He might have meant some other position than CEO. Or he got confused with the calculations :slight_smile:

image

And here’s the background for the Dollarstore sale

image

4 Likes

Next week, samples will start arriving in stores.
Source: Tokmanni / SPAR Instagram

IMG_2662

40 Likes

Press release regarding SPAR products. The first SPAR fresh food department is opening in the summer. Shout out to the channel if you see renovations in any Tokmanni fresh food store this early summer!

25 Likes

CEO Mika Rautiainen gave a presentation at the Annual General Meeting. The slides can be found on the following page:

Direct link to the file.

Briefly about Dollarstore. Timo Heino is Dollarstore’s CEO. Nina Anttila has been appointed as the director responsible for the supply chain in his place, starting in the autumn.
Screenshot_20250507_165607_edit_1569070796789830

Tokmanni’s and Dollarstore’s general merchandise side will be fully integrated, but differences in groceries will remain. It was still hinted, of course, that Spar does not operate in Sweden.

Screenshot_20250507_165619_edit_1569040879828070


Here is the release:

9 Likes

Am I understanding correctly from this and the meme thread that @Vanerihands was physically present at the general meeting in Mäntsälä!? I myself can’t really come up with any more reasons why I wasn’t there this year either; the lottery choice, however, was the cancellation of the ride, which I don’t think has been used yet :slightly_smiling_face:. The slow arrival of spring naturally prevented me from using rail transport and the brisk 3.5-kilometer scenic walking route from Mäntsälä station to the administration and logistics center.

Later in the afternoon, however, I met several people who had been there, at the general meeting of Nokian Rinkulat. As I understand it, no explanation was given for Anders Kind’s disappearance from the management team in the best Stalinist era style, and Seppo Saastamoinen had promised to serve as an active rank-and-file member of the board, now that he had stepped down from the chairmanship. I didn’t remember to ask about the refreshments; I expect someone to remedy this shortcoming and inform us how Mr. Tokmanni remembered the shareholders this time :slightly_smiling_face:!?

11 Likes

“It was revealed on site that a vehicle combination was parked in front of the store’s front door, and its driver was unloading cargo with a forklift. During the unloading, an elderly person moving in the store’s yard was run over by the forklift, according to the police statement.”

Most likely, the forklift driver was operating in an unprotected area, and the customer was run over by the forklift.

Such situations are seen daily on summer streets, when no one seems to care about the safety of outsiders. And this was not the first fatality due to this negligence (and probable violation of the law).

May the deceased rest in peace, and strength to the loved ones.

Hopefully, Tokmanni updates its employee guidelines, monitors compliance, and thus prevents serious accidents in the future.

6 Likes

Here are Arttu’s preview thoughts as Tokmanni reports its Q1 results on Friday. :slight_smile:

We expect Q1 growth to have been moderate due to Finland’s challenging operating environment and the differing timing of Easter compared to the comparison period. Our earnings forecast, which is at the level of the comparison period, is explained by a combination of moderate volume development and growth investments. We anticipate the company reiterating its guidance. From the results day, we expect comments on the development of the market situation, the effects of US customs policy on discount retail, the competitive situation, and the progress of procurement integration. We will go through Tokmanni’s results in a live broadcast starting at 7:55 AM on InderesTV.

5 Likes

It’s interesting to see, by the way, when Tokmanni will announce the financial targets for the next strategy period, as the current one ends this year. The Capital Markets Day concerning them will at least be in the autumn, as no announcement has been made yet. Another thing to consider is that Rautiainen’s (b.1962) retirement age is approaching, though I have nothing against him continuing past due :slight_smile: .

7 Likes

It’s unlikely that those truck drivers are on Tokmanni’s payroll.

2 Likes

Mr Tokmanni often seems to drive a truck, at least according to television.

2 Likes

Nordea julkaisi päivitetyn Tokmanni-analyysinsä. Suositus (PIDÄ) ja Fair value (12,30 €) pysyvät ennallaan. :point_down:

Key upside risks: Tokmanni could post higher-than-expected LFL growth and increase its gross margins further. An increasing share of high-margin products, e.g. clothing and other private-label products, could support earnings going forward. A sudden recovery in consumer confidence could affect Tokmanni’s sales and earnings. In a downturn, the co mpany could increase its market share considerably without hurting its gross margin. The integration of and synergies from the Dollarstore acquisition could also offer more upside than expected.

Key downside risks: Gross margins and earnings could be negatively affected if Tokmanni refrains from increasing its selling prices to defend market share. Its product assortment remains sensitive to weather. Consumers could shift from general discounters to specialised discount stores. A general downturn in the economy could have an impact on performance, as witnessed by the recent profit warning. Ambitious growth targets could operationally increase risks due to more challenging category management. The Dollarstore acquisition increases leverage, and integration synergies might not be achieved.

10 Likes

Nordea seems to be the most bearish on Tokmanni, whereas yesterday I spotted in Kauppalehti’s flash news: SEB raises Tokmanni’s target price to 18 euros from 16 euros, reiterates buy recommendation.

Quite a bold move to raise the target price just before Q1; I don’t have access to the assumptions. I myself am positioned for a potential disappointment. On the other hand, there were quite early spring days in March, at least somewhere in Finland, and it wasn’t until April-May that spring’s progress faltered. Somehow I still believe that when the stars align properly, Tokmanni can really hit it big. After all, synergies have been gained from the Dollarstore acquisition, and cost discipline has certainly been strict otherwise. The cost of financing has also slightly decreased from peak years, so now, if we could get good spring sales, things would start looking nice. Tokmanni has probably only once reported a positive result in Q1, was it in 2021!?

20 Likes

Exactly. Q1 is almost always at a loss, as was the case with Anttila, for example. The delayed spring season probably weighs on sales. Christmas sales then largely determine the result.

2 Likes

@Sijoittaja-alokas already linked @Arttu_Heikura’s preview comment, at the end of which there was a link to this live stream, but just in case someone missed it, today, indeed, the first ever Tokmanni live stream is coming up in just a moment! :star_struck:

8 Likes

Thanks @Arttu_Heikura for the good live stream.

image

Ugly result. As far as I understand, Tokmanni disappointed in terms of revenue and Dollarstore in terms of profit.

Link to Tokmanni’s release: https://ir.tokmanni.fi/fi/news-and-media/pr-story?itemid=712857963A281572

18 Likes

Sweden’s result is, as one might have expected after Dollarstore’s CEO left the company. And Tokmanni didn’t even consider this information worthy of a press release? Poor conduct from the company to conceal this, luckily I came across it on Twitter.

12 Likes

“After a challenging first quarter of the year, it is very nice that the second quarter has started on a positive note. Sales of SPAR products have started briskly in all our Tokmanni stores, and the product assortment will significantly expand this year. The sales of spring season products are also clearly ahead of last year, and for the first time, a wide range of Tokmanni Group’s private label spring season products are available in stores in Sweden and Denmark.”

9 Likes