After the holidays, I wrote a bit more extensively about my thoughts on the merger, the data from recent months, Rocket’s future, and the market situation.
The stock has risen by well over +100% since hitting rock bottom in April (@$10.94) to its peak before the September interest rate cut (@$22.56), but the journey has not been straightforward.
The journey to the current peak has been quite bumpy, and the stock is plagued by significant volatility, which was also experienced today when big money exited its $20-21 call options opened last week immediately after the open, and in the evening there was a quick dip when the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) issued a challenge to Redfin (and thus Rocket) and Zillow Group, accusing them of “an unlawful agreement that eliminates Redfin as a competitor in the market” (direct quote).
Simply put, Zillow paid Redfin and the companies made an agreement which stipulated advertising, and Redfin agreed, in exchange for $100 million, to stop competing for certain properties. The authority saw the practice as harming competition and consumers. More detailed information on the matter can be found via the link:
Today is the last day Mr Cooper trades as a separate company, and COOP owners will receive 11 shares of Rocket stock and a $2.00 dividend upon the merger taking effect. Starting tomorrow, Rocket, Mr Cooper, and Redfin will form a new conglomerate whose goal is to manage the entire home buying process from start to finish, meaning Redfin provides the data, Rocket handles (re)financing, and Mr Cooper manages loan servicing (services).
AI is at play in the background, whose advertised capabilities and the trio’s synergies will only truly be tested in the coming months and years. Currently, for example, the refinancing process takes about half an hour thanks to AI, and the goal is to compress that time to 10 minutes. Rocket still believes it can be significantly more efficient than competitors thanks to its scalable AI, i.e., its Model Context Protocol. Reportedly, a lot of groundwork has already been done regarding the merger, but mergers and corporate cultures rarely hit the ground running immediately after the initial whistle.
There is already some evidence of Redfin’s synergies, however. In the first three weeks, over 200,000 people clicked the “Get Prequalified” button on Redfin’s housing search website, of whom 12% started a loan application and 23% shared enough information for contact. The target remains $200 million in synergy savings, and an increase in synergies has also been hinted at.
Last quarter, every month in the housing market showed an upward trend from April to June, which could promise a longer summer season as the tariff war shock finally began to clear. In the last quarter, Rocket helped over 100,000 people start the loan process in a challenging market, which is +19% compared to the previous year, while at the same time, Existing Home Sales fell by -2.7% from May to June. This achievement can be considered excellent, as Rocket advertised that customer retention was a whopping 97%, so a host of new customers emerged from a difficult market, looking to the future. This bodes very well for the future, as customer churn has always been very low in Rocket’s business. In addition, many Rocket customers have taken out new additional loans on top of older, lower-interest loans to cover living expenses, which has brought additional business to Rocket.
Last summer, for the first time in a long while, it was a buyer’s market, and sellers outnumbered buyers by 35.2% in August. There were 506,000 homes for sale on the market. June marked the highest gap between buyers and sellers in history dating back to 2013, with sellers outnumbering buyers by 36.3%. The number of willing buyers was also the lowest since 2013, with only 1.44 million intending to buy. High housing prices and persistent interest rates still make home buying challenging, although the pace of price increases has moderated in recent years. Canadians are also no longer as eager to move to the US, as their buying interest has dropped by -19.5% from last year, and the decline began when Trump came to power. The weak Canadian dollar, battered by the tariff war, has also negatively affected the willingness to move.
At these prices ($19-22), the stock has priced in many future successes, lower interest rates, perhaps even Trump’s upcoming Housing Crisis measures, such as the privatization of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and the removal of MBS limits, which I wrote about earlier. This measure could quickly lower interest rates, stimulate the market, and heat up the housing market very rapidly, giving Rocket’s stock a new driver. If one believes in that scenario, then buying Fannie Mae’s OTC stock could still be a viable option even after a significant rise. I calculated that FNMA’s value would at least double on that news.
On the statistics side, I monitor the interest rates Americans currently have, as they provide a hint about the timeline for refinancing them. Currently, 19.7% of US homeowners have a mortgage interest rate above 6%, which is the highest figure since 2015, and the number is increasing by approximately 0.8-1.4% each quarter. For example, mortgage rates below 3% taken during and before the COVID era now only account for 20.4%, and this number has been steadily decreasing each month. At its peak, 24.6% of all homeowners enjoyed rates below 3% in 2022. Rates below 6% are now held by only 80.3%, whereas three years ago the figure was 92.7%.
The data suggests that refinancings are steadily increasing, especially if interest rates fall below 6%. Indeed, refinancings grew by +58% in mid-September from the previous week, although applications for new loans only grew by +3% in the same period. According to Redfin, people are waiting for interest rates below 6%, so that threshold can well be considered critical, at which point refinancings will increase and home sales will begin to pick up.
Currently, Rocket’s P/E at approximately $19.00 is a whopping 82, i.e., 7x higher than its peers, but in Rocket’s case, everyone who invests in it is taking the view that the mergers will succeed, synergies will materialize, interest rates will fall, Trump will do everything to bring mortgage rates back to reasonable levels and affordable for the average voter by the midterm elections, or at least that the situation will not worsen from here.
Analysts’ consensus currently is that earnings will first fall by -7% in 2025, rise by +206% in 2026, and continue to climb by +55% in 2027. Capex is also on the rise, approximately 33% YoY, which is well above its peers, but it also indicates how aggressively Rocket is investing in AI development/utilization and the efficiency it brings. Competitors might be severely disadvantaged in terms of investments if the housing market were to show a clear turnaround next year.
In light of the figures for the coming years, the stock is no longer so expensive for a market-leading company that genuinely utilizes AI, but the stock has already priced in the approximately +100% scenario that I expected to happen only before the November 3, 2026, midterm elections. The market is indeed forward-looking, and especially in a rising market, it sometimes fronts the future quite quickly and efficiently. For the future, a positive point is that in an emerging bull market, the largest expenses and investments are already behind, and margins should rise sharply, potentially making the stock’s valuation forward-looking again. There is ample cash, i.e., $6 billion (plus $7.6 billion in loan repayments receivable), so there is no need to worry about financing. At least all the building blocks are in place starting tomorrow; all that’s needed now are lower mortgage interest rates.I stuck to the Sell The News plan and on the day of the FED interest rate cut, I sold all my COOP shares and 25% of Rocket, based on the principle that interest rate cuts are always front-run and then cool down for a while. Some have compared Rocket to the housing market’s “Carvana,” which has similar leverage potential. I once bought Carvana as a trade near the bottom without researching or understanding its leverage effect and sold a small position with a +50% profit. I wouldn’t want to repeat a similar mistake with Rocket, although a +9000% rocket won’t be achieved from this.