The dollar has moved somewhat aggressively over the past week, with a weakening of approximately -3.5% against the euro.
Trump said today that the USD (dollar) is a yo-yo that could be moved at will. Over the coming months, we may have to prepare for “sandbox games” until the November midterms, and possibly the utilization of the USD as one part of the political game.
The image shows the EURUSD-weighted SPX over two years (white) and the USD-based SPX (red). If you invested in an S&P 500 ETF about a year ago, you have practically received a 0% return on your investment. The negative movement of the dollar has been significant, especially for Euro investors over the past year, and the movement accelerated due to the trade war last spring. In the big picture, the movement is not yet alarming, but in my opinion, it is definitely worth noting because of its impact.
Moving forward, it is good to consider the impact of the dollar on all your USD-based investments and think about the reasons why Trump might want a temporarily weaker dollar, even though in the video he says the dollar “finds its own level.”
Trump’s “yo-yo” comment today regarding the maneuverability of the dollar—which according to him is theoretical—is peculiar in itself, and it erodes the already weakening trust to some extent, but ultimately it remains to be seen how much. Additionally, Trump has previously liked to test the system’s reaction, so a little hinting and nudging can help him see how bonds, interest rates, and stocks react to a weaker dollar. Based on that, one can guess what might happen before the elections and why Trump might see significant benefits in a clearly weaker dollar and want to manipulate it more broadly in a favorable direction. Listed below are reasons that benefit Trump’s goals:
-
Reviving exports and industry. A weaker dollar makes US products cheaper abroad, which should increase exports and, in Trump’s view, bring manufacturing back to the US (reshoring and “America First,” which are Trump’s priorities).
-
Reducing the trade deficit. Aggressive tariffs and a weak dollar make imports more expensive and export products more competitive, which should narrow the large US trade deficit.
-
Easier management of national debt. Weakening the dollar reduces the real value of the debt through inflation, among other things, which makes managing the giant debt burden ($38–39 trillion) easier without unpopular budget cuts. Of that, $9–10 trillion must be refinanced one way or another this year.
-
Compensating for the disadvantages of tariffs. Tariffs raise import prices and weaken consumer purchasing power and can slow economic growth, but a weaker dollar potentially balances the situation by making US exports more attractive.
-
Boosting the economy and political victories. In my opinion, the entire operation aims for power; the midterms are the next milestone, before which we will see several stunts to ensure a midterm victory for Republicans supporting Trump.
A weaker dollar generally supports the stock markets (including risk assets, metals, and possibly cryptos), making 401k holders, voters, and cronies happier. It also supports real estate acquisitions, tourism, and corporate foreign inflows, which can bring quick benefits directly to voters (e.g., cheaper mortgages, better jobs before the elections). Trump even promised last week that the stock market would double in the aftermath of the Greenland controversy.
However, there are downsides, so the “easily controlled yo-yo” comment may be put to the test if a policy of dollar manipulation is pursued and if trust eventually erodes, the speculated manipulation gets out of hand, or other countries respond in kind.
As the value of the dollar decreases, imported goods become more expensive—such as energy, raw materials, and consumer goods—which can directly hit voters’ purchasing power. Investors may also begin to demand higher interest rates for their investments as compensation for the weakening value of the dollar, which can lift stocks but simultaneously also bond yields, mortgage rates, and corporate loans, which would be contrary to Trump’s goals. On the other hand, the $200 billion purchase of mortgage bonds aims to lower mortgage rates before the elections, and that could even be an effective way to lower mortgages, especially if the amount is increased before the elections, making it an indirect stimulus past the Fed via the housing market.
A lack of trust is already in the air and it could increase if the sharp weakening of the dollar continues. Large foreign investors may ultimately exit quickly if the risk-reward tips in the wrong direction, which would naturally destabilize the financial system. There is always something brewing under the surface and Japan is lurking in the background, but for now, things are under control and the dollar’s movement is within normal limits, even though every Euro investor investing in the US who follows their portfolio every fifteen minutes has seen the effects of the last week.
A possible capital flight would be a bad blow to Trump, and the possibility of it perhaps grows if hints about manipulating the markets continue. Most, of course, assume such actions are part of the “Trump brand,” so it’s debatable if it even matters. Fortunately, Trump has been relatively predictable in his recent actions, although understanding “orange financial theory” and the Trump administration’s “block math” courses have been hard schools this and last term, and the intensity of the lessons might only be at the preschool stage.
A volatile and manipulated system works for those who know how and have the energy to keep up with every turn, or are on the inside, but at some point, other asset classes and markets may become more attractive than the US. For now, options are quite limited as the bubble still seems to be inflating.
The EU and China could also make a counter-move by devaluing their currencies, which could lead to an unstable cycle. Black swan scenarios could also involve a complete erosion of trust in the world’s reserve currency, which would lead to an uncontrolled plunge of the dollar. There is, of course, still a long way to that scenario, but with Trump, one has to think through even the craziest scenarios in advance, question everything normal, and increasingly ask oneself: have I become a conspiracy theorist?
If this thing holds together and guidance remains at least above expectations, my own SP500 target for this year is 7300–7350, with AI continuing as the engine.