The stock market always looks through both the windshield and the rearview mirror.
How much of the former and how much of the latter there is at any given moment varies.
The market is most astute when it looks through the windshield as much as possible. It receives the least flattering evaluations when it looks through the rearview mirror to an exceptional degree.
Looking Through the Windshield:
Consider, for example, the year 2000. Stocks in the hottest sectors have insane expectations built into them.
An investor hears a juicy anecdote from a friend. The friend works in a hot sector where changes in customer activity are visible first.
The anecdote is that for the first time in a long time, customers have become just a tiny bit less active. It’s not yet visible in what companies report or announce.
The investor sells their shares.
Looking in the Rearview Mirror:
All the latest news flow and data represent this rearview mirror department.
Suppose the economic situation is dire. However, the market’s antennae pick up the very first weak signals that the worst might be over.
The market begins an uncertain, seesaw rally as the windshield and rearview mirror themes vie for dominance day after day.
Lagging data strong, economy likely not yet in recession in September, leading indicators point to recession
The U.S. economy looks quite strong when viewed from the rearview mirror. Through the windshield, a recession is visible, i.e., a situation where…
- real income generation, adjusted for transfers
- retail sales volume
- industrial production volume
and
- employment
…weaken in interaction with each other for more than a few months.
A recession does not mean that a “strong” economy becomes “weak.”
A recession means that a stronger economic situation becomes significantly weaker through the aforementioned process.
In most cases, this does not involve tremendous drama.
My recession guess is, of course, just one guess among many, but I still hold firmly to it.