Furthermore, the market’s basic assumption does not seem to be that inflation will remain high, but if it does for one reason or another, the valuation levels of stocks would be something else.
It’s probably clear to everyone why bonds perform poorly in inflation: a 5% interest yield with 10% inflation is not a good return.
Stocks can be compared to interest rates: an investor buys a share of a company’s equity (either at book value, above it, or below it. Usually above it nowadays, the Helsinki Stock Exchange trades at about 1.7x its book value). The ROE of listed companies in the US has hovered around 13.5% for the last 30 years, and in Finland, it has been over 10% since the financial crisis.
If inflation is 10%, is a 10% “coupon rate” good? No, it’s not.
And listed companies cannot automatically increase their ROE.
Stocks are not a good inflation hedge!
I need to look into that when I have time, but I’ll ask before that. IF we assume that the situation normalizes at some point in the future, couldn’t one assume that things would go something like this: Company X does business with, say, a 10% return on equity and a 5% margin. Inflation wreaks havoc, and multipliers plummet. After N years, inflation returns to “normal levels,” and the company returns to its old return on equity and profit margin. During the inflation period, the value of money has halved, so one could imagine the nominal value of the company doubling. Thus, the investment would not have yielded any real return, but it would have performed better than, say, cash.
Of course, this includes a strong assumption that the inflation situation will return to its old form and that the company in question will again be able to achieve the same real results as before under those conditions. And even in this situation, a skilled speculator would certainly have an opportunity to sell everything and buy back cheaper in the deepest inflation trough.
Mainly, I’m perhaps trying to say that inflation is not a good situation for stocks, but neither is it for fixed-income securities, and with rising interest rates, it doesn’t seem to be a very good thing for real estate, and for some reason, gold and its digital version, cryptocurrencies, also seem to be going pretty much the same way as everything else.
So, one would have to speculate with timing or hit the right sector rotation. If the time horizon is 10+ years, shouldn’t stocks ultimately be a pretty good inflation hedge compared to other options?