Last night, I listened to an episode of Inderes’s podcast featuring an interview with Mikael Rautanen. For those who haven’t listened, Rautanen shared his journey as an equity analyst and imparted lessons learned along the way.
The episode was interesting to me, as I’m keen on a career as an equity analyst, and it’s quite possible, though probably not at Inderes, as performing for large audiences isn’t my strong suit.
While I gained a lot from the episode and found it enjoyable to listen to, one part grated on me. Towards the end of the podcast, Rautanen talks about the importance of understanding a company’s story and how focusing solely on numbers can lead to missing out too early.
As an example, Rautanen chooses Qt Group and says, “You can’t just stay in your Excel, thinking, ‘This is 50 euros, a really high EV/S multiple, can’t even calculate an earnings multiple for this year.’” A moment later, he adds, “You also need to analyze how long the music will play, at what point the sentiment will turn.”
It’s possible I completely misunderstood those statements, but to my ears, it sounded like this: An analyst has built a fancy DCF model with which they can calculate the value of any company, provided they can accurately estimate future cash flows. They diligently research the industry and the company, making their best estimate of future cash flows based on their research.
Now, the analyst inputs their numbers into Excel, and poof, the model gives a company value of 50 euros per share. However, the stock price is 60, and everyone is proclaiming how this particular company will conquer the world. The analyst looks at their model again and thinks, something must be wrong here. They add a few more percentage points to the growth rate and increase the margins. They hit enter, Excel crunches the numbers, and the new fair value is now 70 euros, and the analyst smiles. This cycle continues as the stock price rises, because they can’t afford to jump off the train, and somehow the price must be justified.
In my opinion, this is self-deception, and especially that last statement about keeping an eye on sentiment reinforces my view that this is happening. The stock price or investor sentiment shouldn’t affect the valuation of a company in any way, yet it clearly does, and “independent analysis” feels a bit much to me. There’s no escaping bias, and the most honest thing to do is to acknowledge and understand these biases.
On the other hand, I completely understand why target prices follow the stock price. No one wants to follow an analysis firm that says all companies are overvalued. Stock euphoria can last for years, and one quickly looks like an idiot if they call a stock expensive at 50 euros, only for it to be 180 euros a year later, with momentum only accelerating.
As an example of an “idiot,” Oksaharju comes to mind, who has received his share of criticism on this forum as well. Of course, Oksaharju and I clearly have different views on when stocks are cheap. I easily found buying opportunities in the COVID-19 dip; he did not. However, Oksaharju remained loyal to his own model, and for that, I do take my hat off to him. It takes courage not to jump on the bandwagon when you know that potential top returns might be missed, and on top of that, you might look like an idiot.
Finally, I want to say that I greatly appreciate the work of the Inderes team, and my intention is not to be unkind, but I do see a small point of criticism here. I also don’t know where such a discussion belongs, so I’ll put it in the coffee room.