One can strive for better in all areas. In my opinion, there is much room for improvement specifically in presenting the results of analyses. I will soon present practical suggestions for improvement and, at the very end, a new idea for leveraging crowd power, but first, a little motivational speech from a small shareholder to Inderes’ decision-makers, @Mikael_Rautanen, @Juha_Kinnunen, @Sauli_Vilen, @Verneri_Pulkkinen ![]()
I quote Inderes’ mission here https://group.inderes.fi/:
Inderes’ mission is to connect listed companies and investors. Our clients include approximately 190 listed companies that want to serve their owners and the investor community by providing better investor communications. Our societal goal is to democratize information in the financial markets so that everyone has equal opportunities to invest and save for their future, in terms of information.
Inderes provides target prices, recommendations, comments, and analyses. It is often written that the analysis is the core and that one should read analyses. I don’t dispute this. The challenge is that reading the analyses of 190 companies takes an unreasonable amount of time. Furthermore, an analysis is a product of its writing moment, and in market disruptions, a 3-month-old analysis can become outdated. A situation seen 3 months ago that led to a certain recommendation might have changed, and the recommendation might need to be completely reversed.
My point is that no member of the Inderes community can remember the content of 190 analyses and change their own view amidst market disruptions. This would, however, be the ideal goal. The goal becomes more distant the more companies are in the Inderes service.
Investing is simple. Buy low and sell high. And every investor aims for the highest possible annual return. It is often said that the responsibility lies with the investor themselves. Of course, it does, but an investor is willing to pay if someone can reduce the risk associated with timing. Inderes can create a permanent competitive advantage for itself if it can help investors choose the moment of purchase and sale in a way that no one else can. This competitive advantage will grow the community and increase Inderes’ value for both clients and community members.
Suggestions for improving analyses:
- The following figures are brought to the page Osakevertailu - Inderes.
- Alongside the 12-month target price, fair values are introduced (fair value) using different valuation methods and different time horizons. Fair values are updated automatically when the analyst records a change in the view affecting them.
- For each price, the annual return compared to the current price is calculated and displayed. This % updates in real time.
- For each price, a recommendation to buy/add/reduce/sell is determined in real time, depending on the aforementioned annual return.
- For each fair value (i.e., recommendation), the date it was last updated is displayed.
- Valuation methods: Discounted Cash Flow (DCF), valuation multiples, peer group analysis, sum-of-the-parts analysis. This can be company-specific.
- Time horizons: 3 months, 6 months, 12 months, 2 years, 3 years, 4 years, etc. This can be company-specific.
- The current 12-month target price and investment recommendation are less prominently displayed but are still offered to various external services that require it from all analysts.
- The scores of the company survey conducted on Inderes’ pages are displayed (Long-term attractiveness, Strength of competitive advantages, Reliability of management, Clarity of strategy, Earnings growth prospects for the coming years).
- The current single risk figure is replaced by risk figures for subcategories (operating environment, business model, financing risk, predictability, and stock risk).
- A thread is opened for every company in Inderes’ service, if one doesn’t already exist. Analyst updates appear automatically in the thread.
![]()
In addition to analyses, Inderes can use the power of the community to screen companies worldwide. This is conducive to growing the community and would support Inderes’ growth in Finland and abroad. @Heikki_Keskivali presented 19 criteria for a perfect company in his blog “Characteristics of a Perfect Company” Täydellisen yhtiön ominaisuudet - Inderes on May 18, 2022.
The criteria are so comprehensive that finding perfect companies is hard work. I pondered that this could be a suitable task to share with the Inderes forum. Together, we could analyze the companies in our portfolios. Any company is suitable for analysis. One point is awarded for each criterion met, meaning 19 is the maximum score.
I opened a new thread to brainstorm this matter.
If this leads to action, the results could be displayed in the Inderes service. Meeting a criterion could, for example, require approval from at least three Master-level forum members, and the usernames of the approvers would remain visible. An approver can change their stance. This approval would require software development work on Inderes’ pages.