# Inderes Analyses (formerly Inderes's New Recommendation Policy)

**URL:** https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397
**Category:** Kehitysideat
**Created:** [September 11, 2020, 7:31am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397 "2020-09-11T07:31:17Z")
**Posts on this page:** 20
**Page:** 13

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Pohjolan\_Eka](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/pohjolan_eka/32/38260_2.png) [@Pohjolan\_Eka](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Pohjolan_Eka)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 9:47am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/249 "2022-08-02T09:47:24Z")

</div>

In the latest Verner’s Quarter (Vernerin Vartti), it was mentioned that due to the busy earnings season, only one Quarter would be produced this week, which is, of course, completely understandable from the community team’s perspective. However, it sparked a thought in my head that has been lingering on the fringes of my consciousness for a very long time. Namely, often _analysts themselves_ have communicated that earnings season is a particularly busy time, which I find quite peculiar and strange, and it feels like it’s just somehow taken for granted as an inherent part of the analysis industry.

As an investor, however, it’s very difficult to relate to this, because the majority of analysis work is done when one first gets acquainted with a company, going through every tiny detail, and based on that, models, forecasts, and scenario and sensitivity analyses are created. After this, the analysis work is done, and if the work has been done well, no further analysis may be needed for years, and earnings reports only cause minor corrections to Excel figures (max 1h), as the company’s story and direction remain unchanged. Investing is largely about twiddling one’s thumbs, pondering, and waiting, so busyness is the antithesis of investing.

Especially now that Harvia, Qt, and Remedy’s negative reports have been visibly ridden with overly high target prices and recommendations, it feels to me, as an outsider, that Inderes’ analysis process is far too slow and the analysis cycle does not encourage or enable sufficiently rapid reactions and being correct. I even consider it likely that this same phenomenon will unfortunately repeat itself with Kamux next week because the analyst won’t have time to update the analysis before the interim report.

The fault cannot be with the analysts, because we know that Inderes employs the cream of analysts and reliable individuals who perform their work conscientiously and with a focus on quality. In fact, in my opinion, this method of publishing analysis reports at Inderes is an extremely old-fashioned and cumbersome way of doing analysis. Why publish some strange printable PDF reports at all in 2022, instead of having a dynamic company analysis page with texts, numbers, and models that analysts could iteratively update as part of a continuous analysis process, and to whose text and figures, community members could constantly leave precise comments and observations (a feature like this exists, for example, in Microsoft Word).

I therefore suggest that the community could and should be more strongly involved in analysis activities in the future and abandon these cumbersome PDF analysis blobs, and instead move towards modern agile analysis 🕶  
Ping @Mikael_Rautanen, @Antti_Viljakainen @Yu_Gong

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Systempuulaag](https://forum.inderes.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/s/6f9a4e/32.png) [@Systempuulaag](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Systempuulaag)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 9:52am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/250 "2022-08-02T09:52:23Z")

</div>

> [@Pohjolan\_Eka](#):
>
> After this, the analysis work is done, and if the work is done well, then no further analysis may be needed for years, and quarterly reports only cause minor adjustments to Excel figures (max 1h), as the company’s story and direction remain the same.

I wouldn’t be surprised if some analyst takes offense at that, or maybe just takes it as a joke, but that comment was off the mark in any case 😀

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Pohjolan\_Eka](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/pohjolan_eka/32/38260_2.png) [@Pohjolan\_Eka](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Pohjolan_Eka)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 10:54am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/251 "2022-08-02T10:54:42Z")

</div>

> [@Systempuulaag](#):
>
> I wouldn’t be surprised if some analyst takes offense at that, or just takes it as a joke, but in any case, the guess was off the mark on that front 😀

Honestly, I don’t understand how one could even think about Elisa’s quarterly report for more than 30 minutes without falling asleep 😃  
With all due respect to analysts and their work, I still feel that most quarterly reports are so boring and predictable that it’s extremely difficult to produce any truly mind-blowing analysis for them, and they should practically run on autopilot.

> [@KohtiVapautta](#):
>
> Perhaps, however, quality analysis requires a bit more than an hour to familiarize oneself with the numbers? It was interesting to compare the analysis made by Inderes when the H1 presentation was still ongoing, while SEB’s analysis had already been released (well, yes, the results had been out for 2 hours by then). But on the other hand, it was a very “condensed” comment on the results. So, I personally prefer these slightly more thought-out comments from Inderes, which usually come out on the next trading day. I appreciate an analyst going through all the lines thoughtfully. The live commentaries often show that things aren’t chewed through very quickly, even if the main idea can be conveyed fast.

At least I feel that an analyst is paid, in addition to the investor communication work strongly emphasized by Inderes, for three things:

1. Digging up information and bringing it to the attention of investors, i.e., the so-called Comprehensive report.
2. Quick thinking, where new information is reacted to immediately, and it’s explained what one should think about it. At this point, it doesn’t matter if the capital tied up by the third production line of the new factory has been calculated correctly; what’s important is that the speed and direction of thinking are correct and that they are communicated to investors immediately, so we know what to think about the new information.
3. Slow thinking, which requires a lot of time and contemplation in a comfortable armchair. At this point, the actual analytical work and precise calculations are done, so that assumptions, models, and the investment story are in order, and that sufficient groundwork has been laid to react immediately and correctly to almost any new information.

From these starting points, an analyst’s work is intellectual work, where it is important to know a lot, be right, and react quickly to new information. From my outsider’s perspective, Inderes’ analysts are currently operating with some kind of hybrid thinking, where fast thinking is not fast enough, and slow thinking might not get enough space, as the analysis activity revolves so heavily around quarterly reports. 🤠

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Systempuulaag](https://forum.inderes.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/s/6f9a4e/32.png) [@Systempuulaag](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Systempuulaag)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 11:01am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/252 "2022-08-02T11:01:18Z")

</div>

> [@Pohjolan\_Eka](#):
>
> Well, honestly, I don’t understand how one could think about Elisa’s (company name) interim report for more than 30 minutes without falling asleep 😃  
> With all due respect to analysts and their work, I still feel that most interim reports are so boring and predictable that it’s very difficult to do any truly mind-blowing analysis on them.

Well, it quickly takes an hour to read through the interim report carefully. Then another hour is spent digesting what was read and thinking about the questions that arose. Then one drives to the company’s press conference. An hour for that. Then an hour of discussion with management. Then one drives back to their own workplace. Digests what was heard and the answers received. By then, the workday is already in the evening, but the writing of the entire analysis report hasn’t even begun yet 🙂

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Pohjolan\_Eka](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/pohjolan_eka/32/38260_2.png) [@Pohjolan\_Eka](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Pohjolan_Eka)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 11:12am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/253 "2022-08-02T11:12:11Z")

</div>

I question whether such an analysis truly has any value, because other market participants have already had time to do their own analysis, and the conclusions of that analysis have already been factored into the company’s share price. So, it’s quite insignificant whether an analyst watches the briefing and talks to management on the same day or, say, a week later. The chewing and pondering must be done in advance, because with new information, the speed of analysis and the correct immediate reaction is precisely the value driver of earnings analysis. It cannot be that an analyst’s main job is to follow a company, yet it would still be faster to do the analysis oneself, if an analyst has to fuss over some report for an eternity 🤨

Edit: My intention here is not to criticize Inderes analysts, but rather to shake up and challenge current practices, so that we don’t get stuck in this current model in a comfort zone, but hopefully reach the next level in analysis operations 😘

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Systempuulaag](https://forum.inderes.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/s/6f9a4e/32.png) [@Systempuulaag](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Systempuulaag)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 11:17am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/254 "2022-08-02T11:17:51Z")

</div>

Well, that’s a bit of an extreme take now 😀 Other market participants don’t really have time to do a very deep analysis any faster, even if they’re eager to buy or sell as soon as the market opens. And yes, Inderes analysts often provide a quick comment after the earnings report, even before the market opens, stating how it looks at a glance. You can’t really chew on it and think about it beforehand when you haven’t received the earnings report to read in advance.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![KohtiVapautta](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/kohtivapautta/32/80543_2.png) [@KohtiVapautta](https://forum.inderes.com/u/KohtiVapautta)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 12:03pm UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/255 "2022-08-02T12:03:13Z")

</div>

Here are three scenarios when considering the issued earnings forecasts:

1. **Earnings meet the analyst’s forecast** → There are unlikely to be major issues, and a closer look will tell whether there was a significant deviation from the forecast on individual lines (i.e., one business segment might perform better and another worse). Of course, even that is still quick to ascertain in the big picture. This probably doesn’t require much comment from the analyst in addition to the forecast/the analyst can update the forecast to an analysis fairly quickly.
2. **Earnings exceed the analyst’s forecast.** This usually seems to require stronger sales or some one-off items? Should be quick to grasp? However, this might involve a bit more in-depth analysis, according to my own understanding, i.e., why the analyst’s assumptions didn’t hold?
3. **Earnings fall short of the analyst’s forecast.** There seem to be several possible reasons for this, such as did the company mess something up, was the market more difficult than expected, did costs rise more than anticipated, etc. Companies usually try to explain things at this point and, at worst, downplay the problems (at worst, numbers are massaged – I know this shouldn’t happen, but…). The point is, this is clearly a more challenging situation for an analyst to grasp.

So, can the forecast, along with a potential consensus, be considered the element that provides investors with a tool for quick reaction? Of course, you’re right, some commentary on the situation relative to the forecast would be nice to get quickly. Scenarios 2 & 3 could both include cases where the analyst’s message might be that the big picture isn’t changing vs. now the big picture is indeed changing. With the difference that in scenario 2, investors are popping champagne bottles and patting themselves on the back, perhaps not even having time to consider the analyst’s thoughts? 🙃

And what then is the significance of one quarter to the big picture? It can be a lot or not much, and it depends on the company and the situation.

So, in that respect, I completely agree about the constant churning around results; the goal should be better anticipation of situations. And fundamentally, I believe there’s a need for development in all activities, so in that sense, everyone is probably on the same page here 🙂. I just want to believe that the creators themselves also dedicate a lot of bandwidth to these development matters, and often the reality is quite brutal at the execution level when ideals meet reality.

And at a very general level, I, again, have started to question the rationality of quick reactions and to value slow thinking more than quick reactions (it’s also good to remember Kahneman’s generalizations about human thinking here). Fast thinking inevitably relies either on ready-made models or on primitive reactions, and I don’t yet have enough experience to assess the significance of these matters in investment activities. However, the literature I’ve read strongly suggests avoiding fast thinking and reactions.

Would analyses need more different scenarios or the inclusion of probabilities as part of the analysis? My competence strongly ends here, but this is something that has given me pause based on everything I’ve read (here we are talking about predicting the future, which has many influencing factors, including human behavior).

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![tuuliviiri1](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/tuuliviiri1/32/81874_2.png) [@tuuliviiri1](https://forum.inderes.com/u/tuuliviiri1)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 12:12pm UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/256 "2022-08-02T12:12:58Z")

</div>

When reporting results, you always read how company X exceeded/fell short of forecasts. In fact, the same company can simultaneously fall short of and exceed forecasts depending on the news outlet. What stands out most from Inderes is Kone’s analyst Erkki, who held his line even when stock populists were against him. This is the value of analysis and what you can maximize. What is the company’s position in its industry and its realistic expectations relative to its price? When you listen to Sampo’s earnings conference, for example, you can say that stock analysts are looking for 80% short-term changes. This is more of a zero-sum game, in my opinion.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Musti](https://forum.inderes.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/m/aca169/32.png) [@Musti](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Musti)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 12:42pm UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/257 "2022-08-02T12:42:24Z")

</div>

> [@Pohjolan\_Eka](#):
>
> I question whether such an analysis actually has any value, because other market participants have already had time to do their own analysis, and the conclusions of that analysis have already been transferred to the company’s stock price. Therefore, it is quite irrelevant whether the analyst watches the press conference and talks to the management on the same day or, say, a week later.

I agree with Eka here. For most companies in Helsinki, the cycle currently goes like this with earnings releases:

1. The analyst prepares an earnings preview 1-2 weeks before the earnings release. At this point, the market situation and external factors are dissected as thoroughly as possible.
2. (A surprising change before the earnings, e.g., an earnings warning from the company, might intrude here, especially during this Q2 earnings season).
3. The company’s earnings are released at 8-9 a.m. The analyst types a quick comment for the morning report, mainly comparing the results to their preview.
4. The stock exchange opens, and the market prices in the new information.
5. The analyst listens to the management’s collected storytelling, ponders, and updates their company report.
6. The first trading day after the earnings report is over, a new report, recommendation, and target price are published.

As Eka noted, point #3 is, after all, largely very mechanical. Comments often just repeat certain figures and state how they were exceeded/missed. Most of this could be handled with a dynamic company page (or similar), where the figures could be entered automatically without human slowness (and at the same time, focus on visual aspects, for example). The expert’s work should be focused on picking out and commenting on something significant – not on dropping numbers into PDF tables. If this phase is challenged further, is there even a need for any typed comment when results are well within forecasts?

Point #6 also rarely brings any terribly big surprises, because analysts (regardless of the firm) have already seen the market’s reaction and how the market prices in the event. Often, updates then mainly follow this and fine-tune forecasts slightly one way or the other. In practice, there isn’t time to create anything new and groundbreaking. My question, then, is whether there is any compelling need at all to push out that updated report immediately after the earnings report, somewhat hastily done?

Currently, Inderes, for example, produces essentially three types of comments/analyses on companies:

- Quick comments (at least once a quarter)
- Report updates in connection with earnings releases/warnings (sometimes otherwise if the market is active enough). Roughly as often as above.
- Comprehensive reports. Every second or third year.

I believe many others would also highly value comprehensive reports. Would it, for example, be better to keep quick comments as quick comments and instead invest in having a slightly more comprehensive report come out, say, semi-annually? By this, I mean something that would be closer to a comprehensive report than those quick scribbles? Since the core, they say, was the analysis, not the recommendations or target prices?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![anon38833097](https://forum.inderes.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/a/49beb7/32.png) [@anon38833097](https://forum.inderes.com/u/anon38833097)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 1:53pm UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/258 "2022-08-02T13:53:08Z")

</div>

> [@Pohjolan\_Eka](#):
>
> The fault cannot lie with the analysts, because we know that Inderes employs the cream of analysts and reliable individuals who perform their work conscientiously and with a focus on quality. Actually, in my opinion, Inderes’ way of publishing analysis reports is an extremely outdated and cumbersome way to do analysis.

Yep. Partially related to this (and the analysts’ workload), I’ve generally noticed when reading company reports or comprehensive analyses that they repeat the same things an awful lot; at best, nearly or even exactly the same sentences are repeated in several different sections, and otherwise, they sometimes seem like partial content filler. I haven’t mentioned this aloud before, but now I couldn’t resist since the topic is being discussed. It’s as if the company report “has to” be an 18-page monster that analysts try to force-fill. As if it’s not an analysis or worth anything if it’s not a proper novel. For my part, the company report could be a page or two long with updated figures in an Excel sheet, and that’s the end of it.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![DayTraderXL](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/daytraderxl/32/1690_2.png) [@DayTraderXL](https://forum.inderes.com/u/DayTraderXL)
#### Post date: [August 2, 2022, 8:01pm UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/259 "2022-08-02T20:01:57Z")

</div>

Well, a trader only needs technical analysis and reactions. Honestly, most of Inderes’ active users are traders, in their own way.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![katuviisas](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/katuviisas/32/30064_2.png) [@katuviisas](https://forum.inderes.com/u/katuviisas)
#### Post date: [August 3, 2022, 6:30am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/260 "2022-08-03T06:30:46Z")

</div>

Would this be the business model for this millennium:

1. Immediately after company X’s earnings release, the analyst opens a live stream and shares a link to a document where they are preparing a report.
2. The analyst ponders the target price in the live stream, and the agony of creating the entire written work is preserved for posterity.

🤠

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![STUKA](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/stuka/32/30885_2.png) [@STUKA](https://forum.inderes.com/u/STUKA)
#### Post date: [August 3, 2022, 6:59am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/261 "2022-08-03T06:59:18Z")

</div>

What if an analyst reacts by saying that it has a positive effect on the share price, but Mr. Market decides to lower the price for the first couple of days? Would the analyst be lynched in this same discussion for jumping to conclusions too quickly? If one needs such strong support from an analyst, it’s probably not advisable to try to play the market with very quick moves. Time is always on the investor’s side, as long as one is patient enough to take it in sufficiently long periods.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Seinakadun\_Keisari](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/seinakadun_keisari/32/4493_2.png) [@Seinakadun\_Keisari](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Seinakadun_Keisari)
#### Post date: [August 3, 2022, 12:40pm UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/262 "2022-08-03T12:40:33Z")

</div>

There was a lot in P1’s text and I largely agree; this same model has been used by all analysis firms for ages, and maybe it’s time to consider a completely new approach to this. Start with a small company (or a non-paying client) and observe reactions. If it doesn’t work, then revert to the old model.

The PDF behemoth is usually outdated the second it’s published on Inderes’ (Inderes) website. What if there was a dynamic company website where key figures and so on update in real-time, and new information is updated blog-style with entries? This could be automatically linked to this forum whenever a new entry comes out.

I admit here and now that I haven’t read a single comprehensive report cover-to-cover. There is, to put it a bit bluntly, “filler” (for me, personally) that disrupts the reading experience, so it becomes a “skim.”

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![kapteeni\_indeksi](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/kapteeni_indeksi/32/65693_2.png) [@kapteeni\_indeksi](https://forum.inderes.com/u/kapteeni_indeksi)
#### Post date: [August 3, 2022, 4:50pm UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/263 "2022-08-03T16:50:51Z")

</div>

The discussion shows how different needs readers of the analysis have. For some, the most important thing would be to immediately get information about the potential impact of the earnings report on the share price; every second counts. Some look at the biggest upside potential to the target price and hope for outperformance on a 12-month scale. Then there are also those wild ones who are interested in moats and management’s share ownership.

I agree with the need for development regarding the 12-month target price. Fundamental investing generally works best long-term, and the most successful investors usually own shares for years or decades, and rarely is the target a 12-month return potential. So why should the recommendation and target price be made for that timeframe?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![anon27152108](https://forum.inderes.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/a/82dd89/32.png) [@anon27152108](https://forum.inderes.com/u/anon27152108)
#### Post date: [August 3, 2022, 6:00pm UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/264 "2022-08-03T18:00:02Z")

</div>

One can strive for better in all areas. In my opinion, there is much room for improvement specifically in presenting the results of analyses. I will soon present practical suggestions for improvement and, at the very end, a new idea for leveraging crowd power, but first, a little motivational speech from a small shareholder to Inderes’ decision-makers, @Mikael_Rautanen, @Juha_Kinnunen, @Sauli_Vilen, @Verneri_Pulkkinen ☺

I quote Inderes’ mission here [https://group.inderes.fi/:](https://group.inderes.fi/:)

> Inderes’ mission is to connect listed companies and investors. Our clients include approximately 190 listed companies that want to serve their owners and the investor community by providing better investor communications. Our societal goal is to democratize information in the financial markets so that everyone has equal opportunities to invest and save for their future, in terms of information.

Inderes provides target prices, recommendations, comments, and analyses. It is often written that the analysis is the core and that one should read analyses. I don’t dispute this. The challenge is that reading the analyses of 190 companies takes an unreasonable amount of time. Furthermore, an analysis is a product of its writing moment, and in market disruptions, a 3-month-old analysis can become outdated. A situation seen 3 months ago that led to a certain recommendation might have changed, and the recommendation might need to be completely reversed.

My point is that no member of the Inderes community can remember the content of 190 analyses and change their own view amidst market disruptions. This would, however, be the ideal goal. The goal becomes more distant the more companies are in the Inderes service.

Investing is simple. Buy low and sell high. And every investor aims for the highest possible annual return. It is often said that the responsibility lies with the investor themselves. Of course, it does, but an investor is willing to pay if someone can reduce the risk associated with timing. Inderes can create a permanent competitive advantage for itself if it can help investors choose the moment of purchase and sale in a way that no one else can. This competitive advantage will grow the community and increase Inderes’ value for both clients and community members.

Suggestions for improving analyses:

1. The following figures are brought to the page [Osakevertailu - Inderes](https://www.inderes.fi/fi/osakevertailu).
2. Alongside the 12-month target price, fair values are introduced (fair value) using different valuation methods and different time horizons. Fair values are updated automatically when the analyst records a change in the view affecting them.
3. For each price, the annual return compared to the current price is calculated and displayed. This % updates in real time.
4. For each price, a recommendation to buy/add/reduce/sell is determined in real time, depending on the aforementioned annual return.
5. For each fair value (i.e., recommendation), the date it was last updated is displayed.
6. Valuation methods: Discounted Cash Flow (DCF), valuation multiples, peer group analysis, sum-of-the-parts analysis. This can be company-specific.
7. Time horizons: 3 months, 6 months, 12 months, 2 years, 3 years, 4 years, etc. This can be company-specific.
8. The current 12-month target price and investment recommendation are less prominently displayed but are still offered to various external services that require it from all analysts.
9. The scores of the company survey conducted on Inderes’ pages are displayed (Long-term attractiveness, Strength of competitive advantages, Reliability of management, Clarity of strategy, Earnings growth prospects for the coming years).
10. The current single risk figure is replaced by risk figures for subcategories (operating environment, business model, financing risk, predictability, and stock risk).
11. A thread is opened for every company in Inderes’ service, if one doesn’t already exist. Analyst updates appear automatically in the thread.

💭  
In addition to analyses, Inderes can use the power of the community to screen companies worldwide. This is conducive to growing the community and would support Inderes’ growth in Finland and abroad. @Heikki_Keskivali presented 19 criteria for a perfect company in his blog “Characteristics of a Perfect Company” [Täydellisen yhtiön ominaisuudet - Inderes](https://www.inderes.fi/fi/artikkeli/taydellisen-yhtion-ominaisuudet) on May 18, 2022.

The criteria are so comprehensive that finding perfect companies is hard work. I pondered that this could be a suitable task to share with the Inderes forum. Together, we could analyze the companies in our portfolios. Any company is suitable for analysis. One point is awarded for each criterion met, meaning 19 is the maximum score.

I opened a new thread to brainstorm this matter.

> **[Täydellinen yhtiö](https://forum.inderes.com/t/taydellinen-yhtio/33682?u=moneywalker)**
>
> Inderesin analyysien lisäksi voimme hyödyntää yhteisön voimaa maailman kaikkien yhtiöiden seulontaan. @Heikki\_Keskivali esitti 18.5.2022 blogissaan “Täydellisen yhtiön ominaisuudet” Täydellisen yhtiön ominaisuudet | Inderes: Osakeanalyysit,...

If this leads to action, the results could be displayed in the Inderes service. Meeting a criterion could, for example, require approval from at least three Master-level forum members, and the usernames of the approvers would remain visible. An approver can change their stance. This approval would require software development work on Inderes’ pages.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Tipitityy](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/tipitityy/32/145236_2.png) [@Tipitityy](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Tipitityy)
#### Post date: [August 4, 2022, 9:12am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/265 "2022-08-04T09:12:53Z")

</div>

> [@MoneyWalker](#):
>
> If this leads to action, the results could be displayed in the Inderes service. Fulfilling the criteria could, for example, **require the approval of at least three Master-level forum members** , and the usernames of the approvers would remain visible. An approver can change their stance. This approval would require software development work on Inderes’ pages.

Otherwise good, but having a master title on the forum does not guarantee that the person understands anything about the matter.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![anon27152108](https://forum.inderes.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/a/82dd89/32.png) [@anon27152108](https://forum.inderes.com/u/anon27152108)
#### Post date: [August 4, 2022, 9:24am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/266 "2022-08-04T09:24:35Z")

</div>

I was wondering the same, but couldn’t think of anything else. Did you come up with anything better?

The current company survey on the Inderes website has a mechanism that builds ranking lists under “Investor Perceptions” here: [Osakemarkkinoiden indeksit ja päivän kurssit - Inderes](https://www.inderes.fi/fi/porssi). If I recall correctly, users are asked a few questions, and the answers are given using sliders.

“Investor Perceptions” is probably intended for Inderes’ client companies, but perhaps the same could be used to find the perfect company.

Maybe I’m naive about the power of the community, but I’m holding out hope 🙏

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Seinakadun\_Keisari](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/seinakadun_keisari/32/4493_2.png) [@Seinakadun\_Keisari](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Seinakadun_Keisari)
#### Post date: [August 4, 2022, 10:49am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/267 "2022-08-04T10:49:16Z")

</div>

This might be in the wrong thread, but @Verneri_Pulkkinen will probably move it to the right place.

I’m a little bothered by the company interviews; they don’t really offer much other than an opportunity for management to present their own views. The companies are hardly challenged at all, and the so-called difficult questions are not put to management, which would be of the greatest added value to viewers and investors. Even avoiding difficult questions tells you something about the companies.

Is it true that interviews are no longer granted if one dares to challenge or ask difficult questions?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Pandakarhu](https://forum.inderes.com/user_avatar/forum.inderes.com/pandakarhu/32/5811_2.png) [@Pandakarhu](https://forum.inderes.com/u/Pandakarhu)
#### Post date: [August 4, 2022, 10:55am UTC](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397/268 "2022-08-04T10:55:14Z")

</div>

Also, analyst interviews have started to repeat themselves a bit. The pattern usually goes like this:

1. How did the last quarter go?
2. Future outlook
3. Risks, valuation, recommendation

Of course, depending on the analyst, the answers vary, but they follow the same pattern; some analysts provide more insight than others.

Perhaps, in video format, one could also get more of a “roast” type of content? 🤷‍♂️

[Previous page](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397.md?page=12)

[Next page](https://forum.inderes.com/t/inderesin-analyysit-aik-inderesin-uusi-suosituspolitiikka/7397.md?page=14)
