Exel does provide weak numerical guidance.
Is there a logical reason why range guidance isn’t used for this?
Is it wishful thinking to get something like this from the company for next year? This would certainly increase trust if a reasonable forecast exists.
The information that “there is growth” is not really enough for me if there is no clear guidance on this.
I wouldn’t even mind if this were segmented for their different factories, one for India, one for the USA, etc.