We are currently living through an Auto1 investor’s “dream month”: a 25% drop without any significant events or news. I have continued lowering my average price, but the direction should change soon or I’ll run out of liquidity. Feel free to come rescue me from an Auto1 bankruptcy if you have identified the factor explaining this drop. Something is being revalued here, but I haven’t managed to find any single factor. Below are my own observations.
Recent News:
The larger banks have kept their buy ratings and price targets unchanged, but according to a mini-news item, the small Dr. Kalliwoda Research has initiated coverage with a sell rating. I couldn’t find any more news on this, and even AI didn’t have access to it. The news is odd in that it also cannot be found among the latest analyses on Dr. Kalliwoda’s own website. Since I haven’t seen the report, it’s difficult to comment on its impact on the stock price development.
If you have followed the markets at all in recent weeks, you know that AI fears have wreaked havoc on software company valuations. For some reason, these fears have also been linked to Auto1 in the news (1), (2). I don’t really know if this can be the root cause either, and if it is, I suspect the baby is being thrown out with the bathwater. I find the fear strange because, for well-founded reasons, Auto1 is more than just a software firm.
Yes, in the future, someone could “vibe-code” software with desired parameters that scans cars from the internet and attempts to estimate the car’s condition and history based on images and registration data, as well as secure financing for the buyer. This could certainly be done with significantly less personnel and infrastructure.
However, “tire kicking” has long been one of the final frontiers that online sales haven’t managed to disrupt. As I see it, this is due to the inherent lack of trust between buyer and seller: in car deals, the buyer fundamentally believes the seller is trying to hide defects or at least suspects the seller will conveniently forget to mention them, as the seller has a financial incentive to do so. Software alone is not enough to bridge this trust gap. Beyond software and financing, Auto1 still has a 1.6 billion euro car inventory and an annual reconditioning capacity of 250,000 cars, where cars are photographed and appraised with AI assistance. During reconditioning, mechanics read the car’s fault codes, check dozens of different parameters of the car’s condition, and repair defects if necessary. All of this is documented and presented to the potential buyer. After that, Auto1 has a network of over 600 drop-off points and the transport capacity to move the car to the customer in less than ten days in most of Europe. After the car is delivered, the customer still has a warranty, the option to return the car, and get their money back. Building the trust necessary for a transaction in online car sales requires sufficient transparency, as with every new buyer, trust can only be lost once.
In addition, Auto1 is surely one of the most AI-positive car dealers, already integrating many AI-enabled features into its software (90% automated pricing, car buying and selling leads, part of customer service). In practice, the company aims to use AI to industrialize the components required for building trust.
In light of recent market events, I could well believe this is one reason behind the depressing stock price development. If online car software starts being built with the help of AI, this could in principle have a margin-eroding effect on Auto1.
A third risk could relate to fears about the adequacy of free cash flow at a time when the company is trying to grow its car inventory while used car prices are falling in Europe. The company has just raised its “credit card limit” to 1.6 billion euros with next year’s growth in mind, but in the latest January price index, it signaled that prices have dropped, albeit still moderately, by 1.2% month-over-month. In the same publication, however, half of the dealers believe the price drop will continue as the year progresses.
The company has substantial cash reserves mainly because they can transfer consumer loans to banks with a 95% financing rate. ABS (Asset-Backed Securities), on the other hand, covers the price of a purchased car with an 81.25% financing rate—meaning when the company buys a car for 10,000 euros, it only has 1,875 euros of its own money tied up in it after ABS financing, and the remaining 8,125 euros of the purchase price is freed back into the company’s cash reserves. I understand this as the company having essentially found a way to have banks pay for 80-95% of its growth, and the partnership works as long as its margins hold. One reason for the 81.25% financing rate is surely the use of the company’s own reconditioning centers, which cannot be replicated by vibe-coding either. Banks trust the company’s car inspection and reconditioning processes and therefore dare to finance the majority of its car inventory.
However, price fluctuations are part of the used car business, and as I understand it, the company keeps its cash reserves high to prepare specifically for price drops, or practically a collapse, and the resulting problems with bank financing. For this reason, I also don’t believe the company will use its cash reserves for inorganic acquisitions in the near future, as it serves as a backstop for the financing instruments used.
Thus, the outfit likely aims to continue growing its cash buffer in proportion to the growth of ABS financing and car loans. One possibility is that there is a revaluation, at least momentarily, regarding a decoupling from this connection as a result of continued price declines. This is apparently a conflict between the cash shown in reports and accounting FCF, but that deserves its own message if I ever find the time to understand it properly. Feel free to explain it to me in layman’s terms.
In practice, the share price started its final downward slide exactly on the day the price index was published (Jan 28th), so based on circumstantial evidence, this is one smoking gun.
As can be inferred from the stock price, the rubber band is stretched quite tight heading into the next quarterly report. A good result will (hopefully) be rewarded, and the outlook for the coming year will certainly be under the magnifying glass. Weaker results are hopefully already mostly priced in by now, but unfortunately, the times have proven to be quite unpredictable.